WASHINGTON -- The U.S. Senate today rejected a permanent end to earmarks but its leadership consented to a one-year extension of a temporary ban already in place.
Sponsored by Sens. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., and Claire McCaskill, D-Mo., the measure would have stopped budget carve-outs that have provided funding for such things as Alaska's infamous Bridge to Nowhere, Boston's Big Dig and North Carolina's $500,000 teapot museum.
The Senate rejected the ban 40 to 59.
Mr. Toomey and Ms. McCaskill contend that earmarking lacks transparency, circumvents scrutiny and opens the door to corruption and abuse.
Mr. Toomey said it's the process he opposes, not the projects, some of which, he said, have merit.
He has sponsored earmarks himself.
"In his early years as a congressman he did, and then he learned how terrible the process was and stopped and became a leading voice against earmarks," his spokeswoman, Nachama Soloveichik, said.
Some, like Senate Appropriations Chairman Daniel Inouye, D-Hawaii, say earmarks keep states' needs from being ignored by bureaucrats who don't understand local issues.
Members should be able to direct investments to their states and districts, he said.
Still, Mr. Inouye agreed to continue a moratorium for a second year, even as he insisted earmarks have been beneficial to his and other states.
"Hawaii is a long way from the capital city," he said. "It is simply not possible for a bureaucrat here in Washington to understand the needs of my home state as well as I do, and I believe such is the case for all 50 states."
Without earmarks, local needs either won't be met or will be funded through backdoor "phone calls, conversations, winks and nods" from unelected bureaucrats, he said.
Mr. Toomey and Ms. McCaskill intend to keep working toward a permanent ban, but meanwhile took credit for inspiring Mr. Inouye to agree to extend the moratorium.
"It is unlikely that this decision would have occurred without the heightened attention raised this week by the Toomey-McCaskill Earmark Elimination Act." Mr. Toomey said.
The Toomey-McCaskill measure was introduced as an amendment to the STOCK Act -- or Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act, scheduled for a vote later tonight. The measure would prohibit senators from making stock trades based on non-public knowledge acquired through their work as lawmakers.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.