HARRISBURG -- Acting Department of Environmental Protection Secretary Michael Krancer is defending the agency's recent enforcement policy changes, saying this morning that consistency is needed to shield inspectors against court challenges.

Mr. Krancer, responding to comments from another member of the governor's Marcellus Shale Advisory Commission during a work-group meeting on environmental issues, said the DEP changes were not meant to deter inspectors from taking action against violators.

"In order to be the groundwork for an enforcement action, [notices of violation] need to be clear, they need to be precise, they need to be focused on important environmental matter, they need to be consistent," said Mr. Krancer, shortly after the morning's discussion got underway.

If there are discrepancies in how inspectors decide to issue notices, those decisions can become the subject of "second-guessing" from lawyers during a legal appeal, he said.

Advertise with us

The department has drawn criticism for requiring top agency officials to review and sign off on all violation notices issued to Marcellus Shale drillers. After the policy change was revealed through several leaked internal memos, a DEP spokeswoman said it was a response to concerns from lawmakers about inconsistent citations between the state's regions.

Various environmental advocates and Democratic lawmakers have since called for reversing that policy, arguing that it could slow down corrective actions and prevent inspectors from reporting problems they see.

Mr. Krancer described himself as "an enforcer," citing opinions he authored during his time on the state's Environmental Hearing Board as evidence of that stance.

"Enforcement needs to be vigorous, not just in Marcellus Shale by the way," Mr. Krancer said. "I do want regions to do what they've always done, and that is to communicate with us in Harrisburg."

Decisions on whether to issue a violation notice already involve consultation, tending to take place after an inspector has returned to the office, he said. "It's a very, very rare occasion when a person in the field will shut a facility down," he said.

Advertise with us

A group within the department will be reviewing all notices of violation that are issued, across all industries, to look for ways to ensure consistency and protection against challenges, he said.

Mr. Krancer also said the agency has demonstrated how "agile" it can be when quick action is needed, by recently shutting down two gas drilling facilities.