Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge Josepth James today rejected separate ballot challenges to the Democratic county controller candidacies of Chelsa Wagner, a state representative from Brookline, and George Matta, a Rivers Casino worker and former county official.

While striking 10 signatures from one of Ms. Wagner's petitions, Judge James ruled the candidate affidavit she included remained valid, a decision that left her more than enough petition signatures to remain on the May 17 primary ballot.

Mr. Matta's signatures were challenged because copies of his nominating petitions circulated by his campaign were not exact copies of election forms, as they included a union printer insignia.

The judged ruled that was a de minimis violation of the rules that copies have to be exact and thus he rejected the challenge.

Advertise with us

Those were the two first decisions in what is regularly a marathon court hearing on petition challenges during municipal election years, with the judge expected to hear more well into Thursday.

Mr. Matta and Ms. Wagner are joining county real estate department manager Valerie McDonald Roberts in the race for the Democratic nomination for controller. Activist and former PPG executive Bob Howard of Marshall is running on the GOP side.