State Sen. Jane Orie testified today that she never directed staffers to work on campaigns during office hours and had in fact repeatedly stressed to her employees that any political work had to be on their own time.
Taking the stand in her own defense, the North Hills Republican portrayed Jamie Pavlot, her former chief of staff, as the overseer of all operations in her district offices, and said she trusted her "wholeheartedly" to see that her directives were carried out.
"Some staff would volunteer after hours . . . other than that, they had absolutely nothing to do with my special election," she said of the 2001 contest in which she first won her Senate seat.
She insisted that she had been similarly scrupulous in each of her subsequent elections. She identified a series of memos or e-mails in which she had reiterated a policy of separating political work from staff time. The descriptions were in sharp contrast to the testimony of prosecution witnesses, including Ms. Pavlot, who had described an office culture in which campaign chores were a routine part of the work day.
Sen. Orie frequently looked directly at the jury as she described her years in office. She spoke in an even, unemotional tone after a morning of testimony in which scores of friends and colleagues had testified on her behalf.
Under questioning from her attorney, William Costopoulos, she identified a series of messages in which she had ordered Ms. Pavlot to be sure that political work was barred form the office.
"I always believed Jamie would follow my directives and enforce my directives," she said.
Earlier today, more than 50 character witnesses, many of whom traveled to the Allegheny County Courthouse from the North Hills on a chartered bus, vouched for Ms. Orie's character.
Jane Orie, R-McCandless, and her sister Janine Orie are charged with using state resources for campaign purposes.
Eleven character witnesses took the stand to laud the senator's reputation. They included police officers, former prosecutors, a former radio newsman and a retired teacher.
After Mr. Costopoulos set that stage, he turned to a courtroom, which was filled with another 50 or so supporters. They were sworn in en masse and affirmed that they would have echoed the stellar depictions of Ms. Orie's character.
Bruce Edwards, the president of the Pennsylvania State Troopers' Association, told the jury that she had "an excellent reputation in the law enforcement community."
Bob Kopler, a retired KDKA reporter, attested to her "stellar reputation" and Joe King, the head of the Pittsburgh firefighters union, said it was "impeccable."
Martha Atwell, a retired teacher, told the jury that "Everybody loves Jane," then, as she attempted to elaborate, Judge Jeffrey Manning sustained a prosecution objection that her testimony was straying beyond the bounds allowed for character witnesses.
"When you get to be 91 years old, you like to talk," she said in a smiling apology that drew of round of laughter and applause from the packed courtroom.
Their testimony followed another defense witness, Kevin Lee Derr, a legislative staff attorney, who worked for the senator in two stints, during the 2003-04 legislative session and again from 2007 to 2008.
Mr. Derr testified that he had never been asked to perform campaign work and that he never observed other staffers doing such work.
Lawrence Claus, the lead prosecutor, asked him if he was aware of fund-raising work for the senator's annual contributors' breakfast.
"It was my understanding that Ginger Hope did that at home," he said.
Testifying for the prosecution earlier in the trial, Ms. Hope, an aide in Sen. Orie's Harrisburg office, said that she had done such work in the office on public time.
After the jury left the room for a recess, Judge Manning ruled against Mr. Costopoulos' attempt to have the jury view pictures of a mock photo array that an unnamed assistant district attorney had posted on the wall of the prosecutor's Dormont offices. Among the photos were depictions of Ms. Orie, an investigator in the case, and two demonic looking figures.
More details in tomorrow's Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.