HARRISBURG -- Gov. Ed Rendell thinks the Legislature is showing "recklessness'' about a looming budget shortfall by failing to close tax loopholes and leaving several hundred million dollars on the table.
At a news conference today, he said it's "senseless'' for Pennsylvania to ignore the $100 million or more that could be generated by imposing a "reasonable'' extraction tax on the thousands of cubic feet of natural gas being pumped from areas of underground Marcellus Shale.
He said he had offered a compromise tax plan that is "fair and reasonable'' to the drillers and the state, and it's also is less than his original tax plan, proposed in February and modeled on the tax used in West Virginia.
He criticized legislators for taking large campaign contributions from the shale drillers, claiming there is "no question'' that those donations have led to the Legislature's reluctance to enact a shale tax.
He singled out the "Senate President,'' meaning Sen. Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, who has received $143,000 from the shale industry, for lack of action on a tax. Mr. Scarnati has said he has worked hard this summer and fall to try to find a compromise, but thinks legislative Democrats want the tax to be too high.
He favors a tax of 1.5 percent on the selling price of gas at the wellhead for the first five years of a tax, and later rising a bit. Mr. Rendell favors a 3 percent tax the first year, rising to 4 percent the second year and then 5 percent thereafter.
Mr. Scarnati said many jobs in his district, especially in Tioga County, result from the growing shale drilling industry and he doesn't want drillers to go to other states if Pennsylvania enacts too high a tax.
Mr. Rendell said all other states where Marcellus shale drilling is going on have an extraction tax and said it makes no sense for Pennsylvania to be the only state without such a tax, especially when the state faces a budget shortfall of $3 billion or more by next June.
Mr. Rendell called on Senate leaders to return to session after the Nov. 2 election to work on a shale tax. "I will negotiate night and day,'' he said.
But the GOP has said it won't meet during the "lame duck'' session after the election. The Democrat-led House plans to come back for a few days in November, but without the Senate, no tax bill could get final action.
Mr. Rendell also criticized legislators for failing to enact a tax on cigars and smokeless tobacco, which most other states also have. He called the lack of such a tax here "an absurd situation.'' Estimates are that such a tax could add $50 million or more to state coffers annually.
Also, Mr. Rendell was critical of the Legislature's failure to end a sales tax "discount'' given to large retailers, such as Wal-Mart and Target, for sending the state their sales tax receipts on time. He said the state is missing out on $75 million a year from this loophole.
"Why are we giving these large retailers such a large gift?" he said. "The General Assembly should enact these common sense revenue-raising measures.''



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.