HERSHEY -- U.S. Senate candidate Pat Toomey faced veteran news anchor Ted Koppel Monday night for an exchange of ideas that ranged from timely topics like Social Security and education to less pertinent issues like a military draft and the demise of journalism.
Mr. Toomey sat catty-corner to Mr. Koppel on stage before a crowd of business leaders at a Pennsylvania Chamber of Commerce annual event. It was meant to be a 45-minute debate between the Republican Mr. Toomey and U.S. Rep. Joe Sestak, but the Democrat didn't come, citing a scheduling conflict. Mr. Koppel reminded the crowd three times of Mr. Sestak's absence.
At the start, Mr. Koppel stressed that he would not take Mr. Sestak's place as the opposing voice to Mr. Toomey, but at many times during the conversation, it appeared as though Mr. Koppel wanted to debate.
Mr. Koppel and Mr. Toomey went back and forth over how much unspent money is left in the economic stimulus package, after Mr. Toomey said rescinding it would be one way to draw down the deficit. Mr. Koppel told him that would only be $31 billion, but Mr. Toomey insisted it is a few hundred billion dollars.
"We'll have to agree to disagree about what that exact number is," Mr. Toomey said.
Mr. Koppel also pushed back on Mr. Toomey's long-standing and somewhat controversial stance on allowing American employees to invest their Social Security privately. Mr. Koppel pressed that if President George W. Bush had been successful in getting such a plan through, then people would have lost their savings during this recession.
"The big question is whether you're bullish on America," Mr. Toomey said. "If you think in the long run that America is not going to grow, is not going to thrive, then you should be worried about this approach."
Mr. Toomey spoke at length about his support for school choice, saying accountability could be achieved through a competitive marketplace wherein parents decide where to send their students for education, as is done at the college level.
Mr. Koppel seemed determined to get his own views on two topics heard -- a military draft and journalism. It was a strange choice during a "debate" that was billed on the Chamber's website as a conversation about job creation in the state.
He pushed Mr. Toomey hard, saying volunteer soldiers are doing it all, serving multiple tours, while the rest of America sits back. He asked if it was fair, and whether Mr. Toomey would support mandatory service.
"I think one of the things most precious about this country is personal freedom," Mr. Toomey said. "So to have the government say we're going to focus people to do x, y, z because we want them to ... Virtue can't be coerced. It can be encouraged and it's good to encourage it, but it can't be coerced. In my opinion, personal freedom is a very important goal as well, so we just disagree."
Mr. Koppel, who hosted Nightline for more than 20 years, looked back, comparing his time as a young reporter to the reporting of today. He asked Mr. Toomey about the difference between providing information people need versus providing information people want.
"I prefer leaving it up to the consumer to decide what he needs rather than having the person providing the information make that decision," Mr. Toomey said, to Mr. Koppel's apparent dismay.
Earlier in the day, Mr. Toomey accepted an endorsement from the former mayor of Harrisburg, Stephen Reed, a longtime Democrat.
Mr. Reed said he choose Toomey because of his business know-how and understanding of the economy. He said the "choice is very simple" and that Mr. Toomey is "by far" the better candidate of the two Pennsylvanians have to pick from this November.
At the end of the conversation with Mr. Toomey, Mr. Koppel too took a not so subtle swing at Mr. Sestak.
"I think it's only fair since you at least showed up, that you tell me and through me, what is it that you came here hoping you'd get a chance to talk about?" Mr. Koppel asked Mr. Toomey.
Mr. Toomey took the opening to deliver a brief rundown of his typical stump speech -- lean on the private sector for growth while scaling back government regulation of that sector.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.