Earlier in the week this Aging Edge blog summarized the state’s rationale for embarking upon its Community HealthChoices program, the managed care program for Medicaid recipients who are at least 65 — or who, if younger, have disabilities qualifying them for government support.
Today, we delve more into what consumer advocates think.
The program, which starts Jan. 1 in 14 southwestern Pennsylvania counties, has created considerable confusion and concern (assuming its on their radar at all) among the nearly 80,000 individuals who have received letters directing them to select one of three managed care organizations by Nov. 13.
Those MCOs will be responsible for coordinating both long-term care services (such as home aides and nursing home stays) and medical services (primary care physicians, medical specialists, therapists, etc.) used by the program participants. The consumers will be required after a transition period (two months for medical care and six months for long-term care) to use only providers who are part of their MCO’s network.
Community HealthChoices does not replace Medicare for the affected individuals, who generally will still be using a Medicare Advantage or other health plan to help with medical costs. But the MCO coordinators assigned to each individual are supposed to help consumers arrange services paid for by both Medicare and Medicaid in a way that doesn’t exist today.
The consumer representatives we’ve spoken to think the additional coordination will be a positive, helpful step for many people who get lost trying to navigate the health care system on their own — frequently doing so at the same time their problems worsen and they become vulnerable. The advocates believe the knowledge and tools of these service coordinators could better link needy adults to various ways of maintaining their health at home, rather than resorting to hospital visits or nursing home stays.
Read More
“I’m hoping we start to see services that are more individualized, enabling people to start getting what they need instead of just what’s offered in a certain category where they meet diagnostic criteria,” said Brenda Dare, an independent living supervisor for Transitional Paths to Independent Living in Washington, Pa. “I believe there’s going to be growing pains, but it’s an opportunity to create better services for people in our commonwealth.”
Ms. Dare and Fred Hess, a civil rights coordinator for the New Castle-based Disability Options Network, are consumer advocates from the local area who serve on a state advisory committee for the launch of Community HealthChoices. They have praised both the goals and the openness to their suggestions from the state’s Office of Long-Term Living, which is running the program.
That’s not the same, however, as suggesting that officials have done a good job of educating those affected about what’s coming — a difficult task for this population, by almost everyone’s admission. In addition to a round of community meetings taking place through early November across the region, the state sent multiple mailings. A number of advocates have commented, however, that they believe individuals have received insufficient information to make decisions and have been given too little time to research their choices.
Rev. Sally Jo Snyder, director of advocacy and consumer engagement for the Consumer Health Coalition advocacy group on the North Side, deemed one recent letter far too formal in its language and presentation for any average person to understand — or to even want to try to read.
“If I wanted to design a mailing that would confuse people and make them not want to sign up, I would have sent this,” Rev. Snyder said of the letter.
Regardless, people have to select an MCO by Nov. 13 and are encouraged to call the representatives of the state’s “independent enrollment broker” — at 1-844-824-3655 — to have questions answered and sign up. They presumably will want to know which MCO networks have included their primary care physician or other providers to whom they’re accustomed (providers can affiliate with more than one MCO).
If individuals take no initiative, the state will automatically assign them to one of the three insurers: UPMC Community HealthChoices, AmeriHealth Caritas Pennsylvania or PA Health & Wellness. Individuals can change their MCO at any time, whether it’s one they selected or if the state picks one for them.
“If a month in, it’s not working [in terms of satisfaction with the MCO], you can change it,” noted Fran Chervenak, Pittsburgh senior attorney for the Pennsylvania Health Law Project. “That’s a positive thing, that the state did not apply a lock-in.”
Pennsylvania is joining about two dozen other states that have adopted managed care of their long-term care services, typically as a way to get better control of costs while trying to shift more emphasis to home services instead of institutional care.
“If you look across the country, our perspective is the rollout and results have been a mixed bag for consumers,” said Alice Dembner, a senior policy analyst for Community Catalyst, a Boston-based advocacy group. “There both have been benefits and some harm.”
She said disruptions and complaints have occurred in states that implemented programs more quickly than Pennsylvania. In some cases, budget considerations by the state or the MCOs appeared responsible for cuts in services.
“The tension between trying to save money and providing good care can be problematic,” Ms. Dembner suggested.
Consumers have better protection in states that have contracted with independent ombudsmen to advocate on their behalf when complaints occur and challenges of MCO decisions are called for, Ms. Dembner said. She was concerned that Pennsylvania has not yet committed to a Community HealthChoices ombudsman program, although the state has laid out a plan for reviewing the quality of the performance by MCOs, including consumer satisfaction.
Larry Polivka, executive director of the Claude Pepper Center at Florida State University, has studied programs similar to Community HealthChoices in his state and elsewhere, and he’s not convinced of their value. The often-stated goal, as is the case in Pennsylvania, is to redirect more care to homes than institutions, but Mr. Polivka said that shift has been taking place significantly for years under the direction of government and nonprofit agencies.
“Why hand it over to proprietary HMOs” with their profit motives, he mused. “The nursing home population is already down a couple hundred thousand from where it was 15 years ago, while the aging population has been growing.”
Mr. Polivka said it’s fair for affected consumers or their families to be concerned whether “they’re going to get enough help to meet their needs and have acceptable quality of life in the community, or are they going to receive less than they need, and informal caregivers will be expected to take up the rest.”
Consumer advocates in Pennsylvania are hoping the latter won’t be the case.
For those individuals seeking help with their questions about Community HealthChoices from consumer advocates, rather that through the state independent enrollment broker hotline, they may consider contacting the Pennsylvania Health Law Project at 1-800-274-3258 or the Pennsylvania Health Access Network at 1-844-474-2643.
Note: For those who received notices and would embrace even more managed care coordination than Community HealthChoices will provide, they have another option if they are at least 55 years old and have health problems of the kind that would qualify them for subsidized nursing home care.
They can enroll in one of the LIFE (Living Independence for the Elderly) programs in the state. Those clients frequently attend day care activities and meal sites with attached health clinics, while also receiving careful monitoring that provides them comprehensive home help. Call 1-800-753-8827 for more information.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.