The one thing clear from an initial public meeting for Medicaid consumers affected by the state’s pending Community HealthChoices program is how very unclear many of them are about about its goals and details.

Aging Edge, in its well-intentioned but ultimately superficial (due to space constraints) way, did its best on Monday to give an overview of what the new managed care program is all about. Despite the limits on what all could be included in the front page story, you won’t find too many such articles elsewhere. If you seek information beyond what’s in the state mailings (assuming you received them because you’re among the 80,000 southwestern Pennsylvanians directly affected) or available by calling the state’s 1-844-824-3655 hotline, it’s largely a case of either relying on what we provide or navigating the state’s Community HealthChoices website.

Several blog posts here over the next week will attempt to sum up additional details, based on recent interviews. In this first one, we’ll delve deeper into the Wolf administration’s explanations for what it hopes to accomplish, as described by Jennifer Burnett, deputy secretary of the state’s Office of Long-Term Living, and Kevin Hancock, chief of staff for that office.

While imposing managed care upon long-term care services and trying to coordinate them with medical health care is new in Pennsylvania, thus provoking confusion and concern, the officials maintain they have benefited from waiting until more than 20 other states implemented something similar — although details of each state’s program vary.

Advertise with us

“We’ve been able to talk to and get information from our colleagues in other states as to what did and didn’t work,” said Ms. Burnett. That has led to, among other things:

• Phasing in the program in stages in various parts of the state — the southwest is first Jan. 1 — instead of doing it all at once.

• Setting a 180-day transitional period in which consumers are guaranteed the right to retain their existing long-term care services.

• Soliciting planning input from the outset from numerous consumer advocacy groups as well as stakeholders.

While individuals affected by the program may not be happy with the information they have received describing it and explaining what they need to do, Ms. Burnett said the state has been committed to a “transparent” process in which consumer representatives serving on an advisory committee hear about the plans and weigh in. Information is also being provided at more than 40 community meetings, like the one this week in Squirrel Hill, to anyone interested.

Advertise with us

“We’ve heard and listened to people and made changes” since planning began two years ago, Ms. Burnett said. (Various advocates in the Pittsburgh area, in separate interviews, confirmed a belief that the state properly solicited their input, even while observing that information distributed to the average consumer has been hard for them to understand.)

To sum up the state’s motivation, it’s looking at how to better utilize the existing $6 billion in Medicaid spending in Pennsylvania that covers nursing home stays, home assistance and other types of long-term care help for older adults and younger ones with disabilities. Those currently receiving home and community services typically do so under one of a myriad of waiver programs, for which they qualify by income as well as health status and which are being consolidated into Community HealthChoices.

In many cases, however (about 58,000 out of 80,000) people mandated to sign up for Community HealthChoices receive no special Medicaid-funded home services now, as they are relatively healthy. The program is designed, through improved service coordination, to help maintain their independence as long as possible and smooth their transition to government-funded services once they need them.

That’s essential, the state officials say, as baby boomers surge into the ranks of the dependent elderly in the years ahead. Continuing to spend on Medicaid in the same fee-for-service manner could cripple the state’s already strained budget.

Ms. Burnett stressed that the state is not looking to cut Medicaid spending (the federal government actually pays a little more than the state for each Medicaid recipient in the shared-cost program), but it does want to manage it better.

Advertise with us

“We’ve never said this is about saving money,” which is unlike some other states, Ms. Burnett said. “Ours goals have to do with quality and accountability and service innovation and helping more people in the community. This will give us some budget predictability and help us bend the cost curve, because costs will up otherwise.”

The state is taking that $6 billion in annual long-term care spending, which is now paid directly to nursing homes and providers of waiver services such as home care, and redirecting that amount to the three contracted managed care organizations: AmeriHealth Caritas Pennsylvania, PA Health & Wellness, and UPMC Community HealthChoices. The MCOs will take responsibility for the 80,000 affected southwestern Pennsylvanians Jan. 1, and eventually some 400,000 across the state.

The MCOs will receive a per-client rate determined by those individuals’ frailty level and geographic location in the state rather than by each individual service they receive. It’s known as a “capitated” payment system, with actuaries setting a reimbursement rate designed to deliver a profit of about 2 percent to the MCOs.

The idea is that rather than profiting by cutting consumers’ access to services, however, the MCOs meet that financial goal with care and monitoring that avoids unnecessary utilization of nursing homes, where Medicaid pays more than $70,000 annually per individual, or other expensive care.

Mr. Hancock said limits built into the payment structure prevent the MCOs from achieving excessive profits. Despite those controls, state officials say the real deterrent to MCOs in denying anyone services they should be receiving — whether it be home aides, therapists, nutritional help, medical transportation or other wide-ranging help — is that the client’s health would inevitably decline faster and cost the MCO more in the long run, such as for a lengthy nursing home stay. There’s also an appeals process to the MCO and the state for consumers denied services.

Advertise with us

“It’s been proven effective,” Ms. Burnett said of managing long-term care services and coordinating them with health care providers. “If they cut services and people decline ... that’s not helpful to their bottom line at all. They have motivation to keep people as healthy and well-served as possible.”

More than 11,000 regional Community HealthChoices clients are currently nursing home residents. The MCOs will be offering them more extensive assistance than what may have been possible in the past to move back into the community, but, “I don’t think there’s going to be a major exodus.” Ms. Burnett said. “I think there will be a big push to divert people — to keep them from going into nursing homes to begin with.”

No one currently in a nursing home is required to leave that facility, under the program. “That’s a tremdendous safeguard for people — they’re not going to be dumped out of a facility,” Ms. Burnett said.

Program representatives have advised consumers to consider their existing providers of health care and home help, and then call the hotline to enroll with whichever MCO has the providers with whom they are satisfied. Each MCO also offers some extra plan benefits that are different from the others, which may form the basis for a decision. Individuals are asked to select their MCO by Nov. 13, or else they will be automatically assigned to one of the three, although they can also change at any time.

Ms. Burnett has stated a goal of having 75 percent of consumers make their own selection, but she acknowledged fewer than half do that in other states. The state hotline received nearly 5,000 phone calls in the first 10 days of October from people either with enrollment questions or decisions, officials said.

Advertise with us

Due to UPMC’s Western Pennsylvania brand name and medical provider network, it’s likely to have an advantage in signing up people in the local market, the state officials acknowledged. They said that would be true of AmeriHealth Caritas, however, in the densely populated southeastern corner of the state. PA Health and Wellness is a subsidiary of Centene Corp., a St. Louis-based firm that has been involved in such programs in other states but is new to Pennsylvania.

Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.