Group exercises for seniors are often done sitting in chairs. It’s safe and easy, while still potentially benefiting strength and flexibility for older adults unaccustomed to strenuous activity.
A recent University of Pittsburgh-based study found, however, that people over 65 doing their exercise in a standing position stand to gain more improvement in their mobility.
The researchers reached that conclusion after studying multiple groups of people who were able to walk on their own, lived independently and participated in either seated or standing exercise classes. Nearly 300 people with an average age of 80, most of them women and many with chronic health conditions, were divided into either seated or standing exercise groups for the study. For both types of exercise, they met in small groups twice a week for 12 weeks, 50 minutes at a time, at senior centers or other community settings.
The seated exercise groups did a range of aerobics, stretching and strength exercises, sometimes using playground balls. The standing groups used a program called On the Move, which focused on stepping and walking patterns that were made progressively harder over time.
In comparing the physical ability of the participants before and after the three-month exercise period, the researchers led by Pitt associate professor of physical therapy Jennifer Brach found the On the Move exercisers showed significant improvement compared to the sitting group in the speed and distance of their walking. No other significant differences in outcomes for the two groups were identified.
Although the On the Move group reported a few minor injuries and somewhat lower adherence to participation, the researchers found those in it to feel equally safe and satisfied with the more challenging program. The difference in results, the researchers suggested, justifies additional study of any long-term benefits that a program like On the Move can provide in reducing disability.
“From a community-based health promotion and wellness exercise programming perspective, the On the Move group exercise program was more effective at improving mobility than a usual-care group exercise program, despite lower attendance,” said the study results published this month in JAMA Internal Medicine. “Additional research examining the impact of the intervention on long-term disability outcomes is needed before routine implementation into clinical practice can be recommended.”
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.