Aging Edge has devoted a certain amount of negative attention to nursing homes lately, so it’s only right that we also point out those that the government recognizes as offering quality care.
On its Nursing Home Compare website, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services since 2008 has been using a rating system that awards facilities up to five stars based on their state inspections, reported staffing levels and various quality measures such as the incidence of bed sores, falls, pain and restraints.
Of 62 nursing homes in Allegheny County, eight currently receive five stars: Concordia at Rebecca Residence, Concordia of the South Hills, HarmarVillage Care Center, Harmony Physical Rehabilitation, Little Sisters of the Poor, Southwestern Veterans Center, UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital Transitional Care Unit and UPMC McKeesport Long-Term Care Facility.
There are caveats here, of course. (Aren’t there always caveats?) For one thing, nursing homes that are specialized rehabilitation centers or attached to hospitals tend to be much smaller and less available for general public use and have an easier time reaching five-star status.
But the CMS star system itself is also questioned by some, based on how much of the information used in developing the rating comes from the nursing home’s own data instead of objective measurements.
An analysis from a Philadelphia personal injury law firm, Rosenbaum & Associates, pointed out that it’s possible for a nursing home to achieve an overall rating of four or five stars while getting much lower scores for problems that patients and their families may find important, such as unusually high weight loss and bed sores (known as pressure ulcers in the reporting) and wide use of anti-psychotic drugs on patients.
“While a facility’s star rating can be a helpful tool, you should always look deeper and examine several factors,” including observations from personal visits, the law firm’s analysis said.
Nursing home quality advocate Diane Menio made similar points in a Q-and-A we did with her offering advice about how to select a nursing home. In fact, she pointed out separately in our interview that a lower score like two or three stars by a nursing home shouldn’t necessarily put it off-limits, because she was happy with one for her mother that scored in that range.
So looking at star ratings might be a good start and better than nothing if you lack time for research — it would seem to reason that if you have a choice of a five-star home or a one-star home, one is a better bet for mom than the other — but it’s better to educate yourself on what’s behind the ratings, what state inspection reports have specifically said, what other people have to say about the home and what your own senses tell you on a visit and tour.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.