This scenario might be common for an adult son or daughter whose parent is being admitted with illness or injury to a nursing home: Stop at the admissions office, answer a few questions, sign some paperwork automatically, hurry to mom or dad’s room to see how they’re settling in.
But as elder advocate Diane Menio explains in the newest Aging Edge Expert Q-and-A, often tucked in that admissions contract is a legal provision people may want to think twice about signing. It forfeits the patient’s right to sue the nursing home for any care problems, agreeing instead that any such disputes will go through a binding arbitration process.
When Ms. Menio admitted her mother to a nursing home, she crossed out that provision while signing the contract. It did nothing to hold up her mother’s admission, even though the nursing home’s admissions director wasn’t sure Ms. Menio was allowed to cross it out.
“I said, ‘Yes, I can,’” she recalled. “I said, ‘I don’t expect to need this, but I’m not going to sign it away now.’ I think most people sign and they’re not even aware of it.”
Such arbitration provisions have been increasingly debated and disputed, as a matter of both law and policy.
The nursing home industry says an arbitration process using neutral judges is a fair way of serving unhappy consumers more expeditiously than using the courts, while also protecting facilities from high jury awards that can cripple an operator’s finances. A jury in Beaver County recently awarded a family $2.25 million in a nursing home injury case, a new high for the local region, but awards in other states have reached tens of millions of dollars.
Lawyers who specialize in representing plaintiffs argue that families are asked to sign away fundamental rights at a vulnerable time, unaware of what they’re doing. In some cases, courts have thrown out an arbitration agreement because the person signing it lacked legal authority to do so (for example, a son or daughter without power of attorney) on behalf of the patient.
“They’re fairly prevalent because, statistically, it’s well known and very clear that nursing homes save money through arbitration,” said Martin Kardon, a Philadelphia lawyer who opposes the agreements.
The arbitration agreements have captured the attention of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services as part of broad new regulations proposed to cover nursing homes. It considered the possibility of banning such provisions in admissions contracts but decided instead to try to regulate them with certain consumer safeguards.
Its proposal, which is awaiting final federal review and approval, states that such agreements must be both well-explained and voluntary, with no one to be denied admission to a nursing home based on whether they or their representative sign the agreement.
The American Health Care Association, a trade association of long-term care providers including nursing homes, has maintained that no such regulations are needed and that they have the potential to drive up costs by creating more lawsuits against facilities.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.