Nursing home quality issues received press coverage recently because of Auditor General Eugene DePasquale’s report on how diligently — or not — the Pennsylvania Department of Health makes sure they are meeting care standards, particularly with regard to staffing.

The care offered in these nursing facilities is in the spotlight again in an Aging Edge report about a recent Beaver County lawsuit and its impact. A jury in May awarded $2,250,000 to the son of an octogenarian seriously injured in a 2011 fall when unsupervised at Providence Care Center in Beaver Falls. That amount may still be reduced on appeal or by a future settlement, but it got our attention because it is nearly $2 million higher than any local jury is known to have awarded previously for a nursing home injury or death.

The story will no doubt prompt some other families unhappy with care in a nursing home (we have heard from few readers over the years in praise of nursing home experiences, unfortunately) to wonder if they should be pursuing their own lawsuits and seeking similar compensation. If you’re one of them, there are a few things to consider:

1.Our understanding is there is a two-year statute of limitations for a suit to be filed after alleged neglect caused harm.

Advertise with us

2. Not many law firms have experience or interest in handling nursing home cases. We have no ability or authority here to recommend legal counsel to anyone, but we can tell you that the local firms we have heard to be most interested in such cases — and some of these will be familiar to you from their advertising — are Robert Peirce & Associates; Massa Law Group; Wilkes & McHugh; and Bordas & Bordas.

3. As the story notes, the vast majority of complaints brought by families to law firms — even the ones identified above who specialize in this field — are turned down as potential cases. It’s not sufficient to be unhappy with the care someone received as he or she went downhill at the nursing home; lawyers want to have evidence that the facility and its staff were guilty of improper or negligent conduct that harmed a patient.

4. Assuming the case has merit in the eyes of an attorney, families have to be prepared for a long, arduous process. It is not unusual for a case to take two years or more to reach settlement or trial. It can be difficult for families to hear and rehash details of suffering encountered by their loved one during that process.

5. If a case gets to trial, as few do, it’s much more common that juries side in any kind of personal injury or medical malpractice case with the defense rather than with the plaintiff. And if a plaintiff wins, the type of multi-million dollar award given in the Providence Care Center case is the exception rather than the rule. The story notes that juries are given no guidance about how much money is proper compensation for a nursing home patient’s injury, and no specific figure can be requested under Pennsylvania law. As one lawyer told me, “If you put together 10 different juries and presented the same case to them, you’d probably get 10 different results.”

All that said, there’s no reason not to pick up the phone and make an inquiry with a law firm if you think you’ve been wronged. It shouldn’t cost you anything — if they believe a case has merit to proceed, the firms offer representation on a commission basis, typically taking a third or more of any settlement or jury award, plus reimbursement of their tangible costs.

Advertise with us

If you’re looking for some kind of reprimand of the nursing home rather than economic compensation, your better avenue than the court system is the Pennsylvania Department of Health, which is required to investigate consumer complaints. Those investigations can lead to fines or licensing actions against nursing homes, although those remain infrequent. More commonly the department, if it finds something amiss, will issue the home a “deficiency” citation and require a response to address it. The 24-hour phone line for filing a complaint with the state is 1-800-254-5164.

Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.