People are pretty dumb about the proper considerations in financial planning for retirement, which is why it’s all the more important that safeguards be in place when they turn to professionals to advise them.
That was the message presented by Micah Hauptman, financial services counsel for the Consumer Federation of America, to a group of journalists studying retirement issues recently at the National Press Foundation.
He and his group, unlike a good (or bad, depending on your viewpoint) portion of the financial services industry, support the U.S. Department of Labor’s new “fiduciary standard” regulations requiring higher accountability than has been the case for brokers and many other advisers handling retirement accounts for millions of Americans.
As evidence of how easily the average person might be misled by a self-interested adviser, Mr. Hauptman pointed to results of the Financial Literacy Quiz offered online by the FINRA Investor Education Foundation. When people taking the short quiz are given relatively basic questions relating to common economic issues such as interest rates, inflation and mortgage payments, they average a success rate of only 2.8 out of 5, Mr. Hauptman said. (I took it — nailed 4 out of 5. Yeah, I’m a whiz compared to the average rube, so come bring me your portfolio to manage for a 10 percent commission.)
“Survey after survey shows investors lack a basic understanding of how to make financial decisions on their own,” Mr. Hauptman said. He said the new federal standards, scheduled to take full effect on Jan. 1, 2018, will close loopholes that allow financial advisers to knowingly make recommendations that profit them more than their clients, through various fees and incentives brokers may receive.
Certified financial planners already have fiduciary rules they’re supposed to meet, but they don’t apply to all advisers. If someone’s a “fiduciary,” it means he has a legal obligation to act in the best interest of whomever it is he’s representing. The Labor Department rule will broaden the scope of those falling under that obligation when it comes to retirement accounts.
“It’s making sure when faced with various options they don’t let conflicts [benefiting the adviser] determine their recommendations,” Mr. Hauptman said. “They must act like objective experts not engaged in self-dealing.”
The whole issue — and continued debate, with different groups in the financial services industry having filed suit since April seeking to block the new fiduciary standards — might be a little surprising to those who assumed their welfare was already the top priority of anyone they hired. That would be a faulty assumption, said Mr. Hauptman, noting studies have shown conflicts of interest cost retirement investors billions of dollars a year collectively.
The Post-Gazette’s Tim Grant gave an overview of the pending change in this article when the rule was finalized in April after six years of proposals, discussions, complaints and tweaks.
Or for a delightfully lighter, but nonetheless insightful, analysis of the complex fiduciary rule, retirement planning snafus and the average American’s ignorance about such matters, you could take a look at John Oliver’s report in June on his HBO show.
UPCOMING EVENTS IN AGING
Volunteers 55 and older are being sought to join the new Beaver County Senior Environment Corps, assisting local officials in monitoring water quality, wildlife and other tasks. A training session is to be held July 21. For more information, phone Melinda Hughes of Nature Abounds at 814-765-1453, ext. 203, or email her at sec@natureabounds.org, by July 18.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.