One of the toughest financial decisions facing any older working person is when to begin claiming Social Security retirement benefits. It’s like giving a kid a choice of a cup of ice cream after school or a big bowl as a reward if he waits until after downing a vegetable or two during dinner.
Beneficiaries can claim Social Security as soon as 62, but for each year they postpone doing so through age 70, they’re rewarded with 7 to 8 percent more in monthly payouts. For a person born from 1943-1954, the government defines “full retirement age” as 66, though that’s not the same as maxing out on benefits.
If you take retirement benefits starting at 62, you receive just 75 percent monthly of what you could collect at 66. But if you wait until age 70, you’ll collect 32 percent more per month than you would at age 66. So for someone whose monthly check would be $1,000 at 66, if that’s what annual working income entitled, there’s a variation from $750 monthly to $1,320 monthly throughout retirement, depending on when payments start.
It’s a big call of “pay me less now or pay me more later” in terms of how to get back all that money deducted from your paycheck for Social Security over the years. People might weigh their desire to continue working, their health, their immediate financial needs and, if they’re as strategic as they should be, how long they’re likely to live.
If you outlive your life expectancy, you’re much better off having delayed taking benefits in order to have a few hundred dollars more per month included in your Social Security check. I think I’ve heard somewhere, however, that no one can predict the future, most particularly how long they’ll live. (Some predictions are available based on data you provide about yourself, such as this one developed by some University of Pennsylvania professors.)
The government itself, in offering advice on the Social Security website, says, “We’re often asked, ‘What is the best age to start receiving retirement benefits?’ The answer is that there’s no one ‘best age’ for everyone, and, ultimately, it’s your choice. You should make an informed decision about when to apply for benefits based on your individual and family circumstances.”
A lot of people prefer their money now, as soon as they can get it, regardless of the shrinkage. About 36 percent of men and nearly 40 percent of women who turned 62 in 2013 filed immediately to collect benefits. It used to be that more than half the people did so, which is probably an indication that people realize they need to work longer now to save for their retirement years. (You can take the benefit while still working, but there’s a penalty for doing so.)
Some of those who take the immediate benefits presumably would be better off in the long run by waiting. Olivia S. Mitchell, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School, has a proposal to change the payout structure that she believes would assist such individuals. She wrote about it for The Wall Street Journal Monday in an essay, “Here’s How to Get More People to Delay Claiming Social Security.”
Ms. Mitchell’s alternative: For those who wait to take benefits, reward them with a lump sum benefit at the age they retire instead of merely making their monthly check amount higher. In her example, for instance, if someone were entitled to $1,500 a month at age 62 but she waits until 67, give her the $1,500 a month starting at 67, but provide her a one-time $109,000 payout at that age also to compensate for the years she delayed.
In a survey of 6,000 adults shown the alternative, which is cost-neutral to the government, Ms. Mitchell found “many people would be willing to claim later and work longer, if they can get the attractive partial buyout from Social Security.” Even some people who had already stated they intended to take benefits at the youngest age possible changed their minds when offered the partial buyout concept. Ms. Mitchell said that would be grand, because ”incentivizing longer work lives could lead to better mental and physical health at older ages for many people, so there could be ample positive social benefits.”
The Social Security Administration, however, is not known to be considering any such alternative. You’ll likely have to select your ice cream the old-fashioned way.
Upcoming Events in Aging:
The Allegheny County Area Agency on Aging is offering free workshops educating caregivers on various topics on upcoming Wednesdays. They’re held from 10 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. at the AAA office at 2100 Wharton St. on the South Side, second floor. Participants can choose any number of sessions to attend, but advance registration is required by calling 412-350-4996.
The dates and topics are:
May 18: General caregiving skills and positioning and mobility assistance.
May 25: Home safety and caring for someone with dementia.
June 1: Legal and financial issues and healthy eating.
***
The Pennsylvania Department of Aging will hold a local public hearing on its next four-year State Plan on Aging on the South Side on Wednesday, May 18.
The public is invited to take part by attending or testifying at the session scheduled from 10 a.m. to noon at the office of the Allegheny County Area Agency on Aging, 2100 Wharton St., second floor.
The state is required every four years by federal law to update an outline of how it will provide services and programs assisting older adults. A draft of the next plan, to cover 2016-2020, is to be made available to the public on May 13.
Those interested in testifying should register in advance by sending email to stateplanonaging@pa.gov or calling Abby Fox from the state Department of Aging at 717-783-6128.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.