Perhaps you heard last week that Will Ferrell was planning to star in a “comedy” about Ronald Reagan taking on dementia symptoms while still president.

Perhaps you saw that Mr. Reagan’s children and others, including the Alzheimer’s Association, denounced the film project as terribly offensive on a subject they find hard to imagine anyone finding funny.

And perhaps you’re aware that Mr. Ferrell backed out of the project after the uproar, and the future of the film is now uncertain. If you want the details from Variety after the fact, you can read all about it here.

One might wonder where the line is drawn concerning what can be made fun of in the mass media. After all, a half-century ago “Hogan’s Heroes” was a popular CBS show portraying the Nazis as bumbling oafs whose mismanagement of POW camps was worth a chuckle or three every week. Oh, that Third Reich!

Advertise with us

We don’t know of any advocacy group for POWs complaining about that sitcom at the time, but as to the Ferrell/Reagan flick, the Alzheimer’s Association said before Mr. Ferrell’s withdrawal that it was “appalled that anyone would plan to develop a film that satirizes an individual living with Alzheimer’s or another dementia. Would filmmakers consider using a fatal form of cancer or another deadly disease for comedy? It’s time to stop this forever.”

We should point out, for the record, that the 2011 film ”50/50,” in which Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s character confronted cancer in his 20s, was a pretty funny film about cancer. But it was also written by someone who had had similar experiences to the main character to draw upon, and it was an honest drama as well as comedy.

And therein lies the rub. If Will Ferrell were doing a witty one-man show about a personal experience he’d had dealing with a family member’s Alzheimer’s, it would be one thing. I’ve interviewed numerous spouses and children of Alzheimer’s patients who laughed about the things these afflicted individuals said or did, because their actions or statements can just be so bizarre. But the family members were laughing through their tears — they’d earned the right to be amused by virtue of all of the hardship of caring for their loved ones day to day, with laughter sometimes the only way to survive it.

There’s probably a sense that neither Mr. Ferrell nor anyone else in Hollywood has earned the right to make fun of President Reagan’s dementia. (Mr. Reagan’s Alzheimer’s diagnosis also came six years after he was out of office, and while dementia can quietly diminish someone’s abilities while undetected for many years, his legion of supporters wouldn’t be amused by the suggestion he was mentally impaired while running the country.)

It doesn’t mean the topic is totally out-of-bounds to comedians. It just depends on who’s making the jokes and how they’re doing it. Are they mining whatever comic side exists to this tragic disease for profit and celebrity status, or rather using it to make a point and educate?

Advertise with us

When longtime entertainer Art Linkletter came to Pittsburgh in 1999 as keynote speaker for a fund-raising event related to care of the elderly, the 87-year-old tickled the crowd greatly with one-liners about the foibles of aging, including losing one’s faculties.

He said he’d been on a tour of an Alzheimer’s facility in which he asked a patient if she knew who he was. “She said, ‘No, but if you go to the front desk, they’ll tell you.’”

No one complained of Mr. Linkletter committing any offense.

Upcoming Events in Aging:

The Allegheny County Area Agency on Aging is offering free workshops educating caregivers on various topics on upcoming Wednesdays starting this week. They’re held from 10 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. at the AAA office at 2100 Wharton St. on the South Side, second floor. Participants can choose any number of sessions to attend, but advance registration is required by calling 412-350-4996.

Advertise with us

The dates and topics are:

May 4: Caring for the caregiver and assisting with personal care.

May 18: General caregiving skills and positioning and mobility assistance.

May 25: Home safety and caring for someone with dementia.

June 1: Legal and financial issues and healthy eating.

Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.