A lawsuit brought by the Michael Crichton estate against the team behind Pittsburgh-set Max medical drama “The Pitt” has been allowed to continue by a Los Angeles Superior Court judge, numerous outlets including Variety have reported.

Filed in August by Sherri Crichton, author and “ER” creator Michael Crichton’s widow, on behalf of his estate, the lawsuit accused Warner Bros Television of attempting to create an unauthorized version of “ER” under a new name after failing to come to terms with the family on a proposed reboot of the hit medical drama that premiered in 1994. Several members of the team behind the “The Pitt” are named as well, including executive producers John Wells, R. Scott Gemmill and Noah Wyle, who also stars in the show.

Wyle was a main cast member of “ER,” while Wells served as executive producer and Gemmill as supervising producer and writer.

Los Angeles Superior Court judge Wendy Chang on Monday struck down a motion to deem the lawsuit “frivolous” and have it thrown out under California’s anti-SLAPP statute, according to Variety, with Chang stating that the suit met the minimum standards of merit.

Advertise with us

”The Court has rejected Warner Bros.’ attempt to avoid responsibility for breaching its contract with Michael Crichton, finding that the Crichton Estate’s claim has merit and should proceed,” a spokesperson for the estate told Variety. “Sherri Crichton was thrilled that the original team behind ‘ER’ wanted to do a reboot and was shocked when Warner Bros. abruptly broke off negotiations and announced ‘The Pitt’ — a carbon copy of the ‘ER’ reboot that was pitched to her. The Crichton Estate looks forward to presenting its case to a jury and is confident it will prevail.”

Warner Bros., Max’s parent company, released its own statement on Tuesday.

“The judge has not decided any of the claims in this case,” said a company spokesperson. “She simply ruled that the case will proceed. We continue to believe in the strength of our position and that we will ultimately prevail.”

Warner Bros. has argued that “The Pitt” is an entirely different show, while Wells has maintained any similarities between the two series are inherent to medical dramas.

“‘The Pitt’ was not based on ‘ER,'” Wells told Variety. “In fact, our goal at (John Wells Productions), while working on the project was to produce an entirely new medical drama — that viewers would see as different from any other medical drama that has been on television to date. Our intent with ‘The Pitt’ is to examine — and contribute to the public discussion on — the challenges facing emergency medical providers in the post-COVID world.”

Advertise with us

Aside from the involvement of Wells, Wyle and Gemmill in creating a medical drama, the lawsuit alleges numerous similarities between the show, claiming the “the structure, plot, themes, setting, pace, characters, and sequence of events of the pilot screenplay for ‘The Pitt’ all mirror Crichton’s original screenplay for the 1994 pilot episode of ‘ER.’”

The complaint states that Wyle’s character is “Dr. John Carter from ER in all but name, only 30 years later, and imbued with the experience and lessons learned during the 15-year run of the original series.”

“ER” in part follows the career arc of Carter, a wealthy Chicagoan who starts out as a nauseous third-year medical student and works his way to attending physician.

While “The Pitt” has focused less on its characters’ personal lives to date than “ER” did, Wyle’s role on the series, Dr. Michael Robinavitch, is developed slowly across the seven episodes that have aired. Viewers largely see “Dr. Robby” concentrated on the job of overseeing the emergency department of the show’s title, though occasional fissures in his work persona reveal the PTSD he suffers from related to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The suit also cites the idea that both series’ pilots occur during a single day and are set in the emergency room of “a large urban city.” The “ER” pilot, “24 Hours,” covers a full day in one hour; “The Pitt” pilot covers one hour in what’s meant to be real time, with the remaining episodes of Season 1 building on that to cover a continuous 15-hour shift. And of course, “ER” was set in Chicago, while “The Pitt,” though largely filmed in Los Angeles, is set on Pittsburgh’s North Side. The production filmed exteriors at Allegheny General Hospital across a few days in September, including a scene where Dr. Robby is on the roof.