Matt Smith would’ve guessed that The Muppets and Taylor Swift were the greatest obstacles standing between his “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood” Lego set and a store near you. It turns out he underestimated the allure of prize machines and steamboats.

The New Jersey-based designer unveiled his Lego re-creation of Mister Rogers’ living room and Neighborhood of Make-Believe sets almost a year ago via the company’s Lego Ideas website. Thirty-eight days later, Smith’s prototype eclipsed Lego Ideas’ 10,000-vote threshold and joined 2023’s pool of 49 product ideas that Lego was considering for mass production.

Last week, Lego revealed that only the miniature prize machine and western river steamboat builds had been selected for manufacture from that group. It wasn’t an ideal ending for Smith, but as he told the Post-Gazette on Thursday, Pittsburghers likely haven’t seen the last of him — or his Mister Rogers-themed Lego sets.

“I don’t feel like it was a waste or a failure,” he said. “The amount of joy and enjoyment people got out of it ... is something they did just from a picture. They didn’t need a set to have that joy. I’m really happy that took place.”

Advertise with us

This project began as a way for Smith to bond with his young son over both Legos and Mister Rogers. It quickly morphed into a phenomenon that caught the attention of Mister Rogers fans nationwide. Western Pennsylvanians eventually caught wind of Smith’s efforts and helped spur him to 10,000 votes.

Smith is still unclear exactly why Lego didn’t choose his design. Lego Ideas’ May 2 update on Smith’s original post states that “the LEGO Review Board has decided that we will not produce this project as a set” and thanks Smith “for the passion and creativity that went into this project.” He was provided with a list of reasons why his set might have been eliminated, but no specific critiques.

“The amount of information I have is the same amount of information anyone who accesses the blog has,” he said.

It’s worth noting that the two winners were not based on any preexisting intellectual properties. A Fred Rogers Production spokesperson confirmed to the Post-Gazette that Lego never reached out to anyone there about Smith’s endeavor.

Despite his disappointment, Smith is already moving forward with a few other Lego projects. He currently has a set on Lego Ideas dedicated to Dream Theater, his favorite band. Like his Mister Rogers design, the Dream Theater set includes moving parts and intricately crafted replicas of things like the metal band’s drum sets and even its lead singer’s mic stand from 2019’s Distance Over Time tour.

Advertise with us

His Dream Theater build has been up since Feb. 26 and currently has 351 days to reach the 1,000-vote benchmark that will extend his quest to 10,000 votes by another 180 days. Smith also has a mystery build that he expects to upload onto Lego Ideas soon and is also kicking around another Mister Rogers concept that will likely be smaller than his first one but still leave room for six mini-figures.

As Smith mentioned, there’s nothing stopping him from re-submitting his original Mister Rogers set that took a little over a month to reach 10,000 votes. He’s “very well-inclined to do that,” though most likely after his next Lego trip to Fred Rogers’ neighborhood.

He thanked all the Pittsburghers who supported his first Lego Ideas foray and said “it was just otherworldly” to watch in real time as so many folks discovered and expressed their admiration for his family’s hard work.

“The No. 1 thing [Western Pennsylvanians] can do is to keep Mister Rogers’ memory alive, with or without a Lego set, and the way he treated people,” Smith said. “I hope that all my Pittsburgh neighbors are ready and awaiting the next project to come out!”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and X @jaxelburgh.