Shayla Smith didn’t mince words when asked for her perspective on the Pittsburgh dating scene.
“The dating pool in Pittsburgh is a little dirty,” the 27-year-old Mount Washington native and resident told the Post-Gazette. “It’s a mess!”
In her experience, a lot of Western Pennsylvania singles “genuinely don’t know what they want” and have thus fostered a “very chaotic” environment for finding anything resembling a lasting romantic connection.
That level of disillusionment with her hometown’s dating culture is partially what led Smith to become the first central single on “Local Love,” which premieres Jan. 9 on the Hearst-owned Very Local streaming service.
Each episode consists of one single going on three dates at various locations around the Steel City before selecting one candidate for a second date. After watching the show’s pilot episode, it was clear that Smith was straight out of central casting as the kind of gregarious personality capable of drawing viewers into the “Local Love” universe.
“It was definitely something different,” said Smith, an independent sales representative for a health/telecommunications company. “It definitely had a lot to it that I didn’t anticipate. ... It was really, really fun, though!”
Read More
Very Local launched the first iteration of “Local Love” in Kansas City, Missouri, in October 2022. Since then, the franchise has expanded to Boston; Cincinnati; Louisville; Sacramento, California; Omaha, Nebraska; and Des Moines, Iowa.
Michael Callahan, Very Local’s vice president of production, likened the sincere tone of every “Local Love” outing to “‘House Hunters’ but for dating.” “Local Love” has generated buzz and increased Very Local viewership across multiple cities, and Callahan expects that trend to continue with this latest edition.
“Pittsburgh has been such a fruitful market for us,” he said. “We feel like Pittsburgh, just as much as any market in our footprint, has wrapped its arms around what we’re doing. Even if we have a franchise that started somewhere else, we’re likely to bring it to Pittsburgh because we know we have the support there.”
This region has hosted a variety of Very Local programming over the last few years. That includes the food competition show “Plate It, Pittsburgh,” the Day Bracey and Ed Bailey-led “Ed and Day in the ‘Burgh,” and Frank Nicotero’s return to game shows with “Wait, What Happened?”
A series focused on Pittsburgh’s dating scene with the added bonus of showcasing local singles and businesses, though? That’s a new one.
“Your community is amazing,” Callahan said. “You have unique and wonderful personalities you can celebrate. This is the chance to celebrate the guy or girl next door in an interesting way and have some fun while doing it.”
“Local Love” will begin its initial six-episode run by celebrating Smith, a Pittsburgh CAPA and Point Park University graduate with a thirst for adventure. She was hesitant at first to try out for “Local Love,” but was ultimately convinced after her mother threatened to sign up Smith herself.
“No matter what way this goes,” Smith recalled thinking, “I’ll at least get a cool new experience, meet some cool new people and experience new parts of Pittsburgh.”

She ended up going on three dates last July over the course of about a week at Gaby et Jules Patisseries et Macarons in Squirrel Hill, Shorty’s Pins x Pints on the North Shore and Spring Street Studios in Zelienople. Smith got to bake pastries from scratch at Gaby, destroy her date in a duckpin bowling game at Shorty’s and make some glass art at Spring Street.
All “Local Love” date locations were chosen with input from the folks vying for the main single’s attention, according to Callahan. He said that future episodes will feature dates involving a National Aviary sloth encounter and “a pirate ship adventure.”
It didn’t take long for Smith’s extroverted nature to shine through once she grew accustomed to having every moment of her dates filmed. Anyone familiar with what it’s like to search for love in Pittsburgh won’t be shocked to learn that one of Smith’s dates knew her best friend and another went to CAPA around the same time she did.
After teetering “up until the final second,” Smith chose a man for a second date that didn’t end up leading much further. Still, she has no regrets about giving “Local Love” a shot. She recommends that other frustrated Pittsburgh singles strongly consider throwing their names in the ring as well.
“They’ll probably find something they didn’t even know they could do in Pittsburgh,” Smith said. “[The show] could be interesting enough to pique someone’s interest to go on a date.
“If someone had called me up and said, ‘I had a date where I drank champagne and broke glass,’ I’d definitely be down!”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.