Not all dating shows are built for maximum drama and debauchery. Some just genuinely want to help singles find their special someone.

Take “Jewish Matchmaking,” Netflix’s “Indian Matchmaking” spinoff that dropped its full eight-episode first season earlier this month. The premise is simple: Jewish singles looking for their perfect match are set up on dates, provide regular reports on how said relationships are progressing and learn valuable lessons about what they truly want from a significant other along the way.

The person in charge of setting up these prospective love connections is Aleeza Ben Shalom, a seasoned matchmaker whose journey to becoming a Netflix dating-show host began as an interdisciplinary studies major at the University of Pittsburgh. The Post-Gazette recently caught up with Ben Shalom to discuss her time in Pittsburgh, how one becomes a matchmaker, her thoughts on how season one of “Jewish Matchmaking” played out and more.

“I think everybody left satisfied,” she said. “They understood why I made the match. They appreciated if I was trying to help them stretch and grow.”

Advertise with us

Ben Shalom is a Philadelphia native who had no idea matchmaking was even a viable career path when she first got to the Steel City. She picked Pitt because it was an affordable, in-state option that allowed her to live in an urban area and create her own major. In Ben Shalom’s case, “interdisciplinary studies” meant that she was able to spend four years focusing on three very different subjects: Jewish studies, children’s literature, and public policy and the environment.

She recalled living in Oakland’s Litchfield Towers for her first two years at Pitt before becoming the head resident assistant at Sutherland Hall. Ben Shalom was heavily involved with the local Jewish community both on and off campus, including teaching in area Hebrew schools and working with special-needs students. Pittsburgh is also where she met Amazing Books & Records owner Eric Ackland, who she made a point to shout out.

“Pittsburgh was a very warm, welcoming, friendly, community,” she said. “I found it to be a very kind, easy place to be.”

Her first foray into the world of professional matchmaking was with the online dating service JMatchmaking, which sets Jewish singles up based on perceived compatibility. That work basically amounted to “playing Yente,” as Ben Shalom put it while referencing Anatevka's resident matchmaker in “Fiddler on the Roof.”

It was there that Ben Shalom realized she loved all aspects of the matchmaking process. She said that some matchmakers are just introducers, while others continue on with clients as mentors and “closers” who keep checking in with folks as their relationships move forward and help them determine whether “we’re getting married or moving on.”

Advertise with us

What sets Ben Shalom apart is that she specializes in all three phases of matchmaking for Jews of all ages, religious backgrounds and stages of life.

“I fell in love with that because even if I made the most beautiful match, if people didn’t have the right support and guidance, that just broke my heart,” she said.

Matchmaker Aleeza Ben Shalom and participant Ori Basly in the Netflix dating series “Jewish Matchmaking.” (Netflix)

One would think that helming her own show may have been a nerve-racking experience for Ben Shalom. Instead, she found that all the “visual feedback” she had gotten from appearing in media outlets worldwide, leading weekly singles seminars and monthly matchmaking trainings on Zoom during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, and even appearing as herself on the YouTube series “Soon By You” left her feeling quite at home in front of Netflix’s cameras.

“When this came along, I had both an intuition and an understanding because of ‘Indian Matchmaking’ that they had the capability to do the type and quality of a show that I would really want,” Ben Shalom said. “That gave me the confidence to say, ‘OK, we hit the jackpot.’”

The first season of “Jewish Matchmaking” featured singles living in Florida, California, Missouri, Wyoming and multiple cities in Israel. On the notion of doing some future Jewish matchmaking in Pittsburgh, Ben Shalom said, “I’ll keep it in mind for a hopeful, wishful season two.”

Advertise with us

While shooting season one, Ben Shalom found that not everyone was comfortable having their dates televised. That led to a few odd on-screen pairings, though she did introduce some of season one’s main figures to the other singles she had in mind for them after filming wrapped. There was also meticulous planning that Ben Shalom said Netflix didn’t show, including most of her initial 90-minute meetings with each new client and a lot of pre-date preparation.

It warmed Ben Shalom’s heart to see “Jewish Matchmaking” participants like Kansas City’s Nakysha Osadchey connect with a guy who brought her flowers on their first date. She wasn’t bothered to see seemingly well-matched duos like Fay Brezel and her date Shaya call it off due to their different levels of religious intensity.

The whole experience only made her more passionate about Jewish matchmaking, specifically about getting “all the wannabe matchmakers in the world trained.” She organized an international matchmaking conference that took place in Jerusalem last month, and its second iteration is set for June 4 in New York City.

For now, Ben Shalom is enjoying the warm reception “Jewish Matchmaking” has gotten since its Netflix debut. She urged all Jewish singles out there to never give up on finding love, take advantage of all the resources at their disposal and remember that “your person is out there, also looking.” She also offered this prayer:

“May each and every one of you searching for your soulmate find them this year, with ease, and may you both have clarity. Amen.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.