Billy Gardell and Aaron Donald have two important things in common: They’re both from Pittsburgh, and they both have giant hearts.
Their capacities for good will be on display over the next few weeks on season two of “Secret Celebrity Renovation,” a CBS show where the rich and famous give back to loved ones by gifting them a free home renovation. The show’s cast and crew stopped by Pittsburgh twice earlier this year to help Gardell upgrade his best friend’s mother’s house in Penn Hills and Donald do the same for his parents’ abode in Lincoln-Lemington.
Season two of “Secret Celebrity Renovation” premieres Friday with Gardell’s episode. There’s no release date for Donald’s yet, although it will most likely be some time in August or September. The Post-Gazette recently caught up with “Secret Celebrity Renovation” host Nischelle Turner and lead contractor Rob “Boston Rob” Mariano to talk about working with two of Pittsburgh’s favorite sons on home improvement projects.
“I was happy to be highlighting a place that often gets overlooked in the contributions that cities make to America,” Turner told the Post-Gazette. “For me, it was really, really great to not have one, but two episodes there really highlighting the city.”
Feel good content loading...????
— CBS (@CBS) July 22, 2022
IN ONE WEEK don't miss the season premiere of Secret #CelebrityRenovation featuring @BobAbisholaCBS very own @BillyGardell Friday, July 29 at 8/7c on CBS. pic.twitter.com/T2fMjptQTd
Turner said that season two of “Secret Celebrity Renovation” was somehow more of a whirlwind than the first season, which was shot in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic. Season one had more leeway time-wise than the three-month deadline they had for season two. That tight production window included having to go back and forth to Pittsburgh for a month and a half to get Gardell and Donald’s episodes done.
Since Mariano’s wife — fellow “Survivor” alumnus Amber Brkich — is from Beaver, he had been to Pittsburgh quite a lot prior to these two renovations. Turner, who grew up in rural Missouri, had never been to the Steel City before but quickly identified with the region’s blue-collar spirit. She was amused to watch the finished cut of Gardell’s episode and hear herself declare: “Billy Gardell is the person who got me to Pittsburgh.”
Read More
Gardell was doing this good deed for Marianne O’Connell, the mother of his best friend, Joey O’Connell. Her house hadn’t received a significant update since the 1980s, which provided a unique renovation challenge for Mariano and designer Sabrina Soto.
“The carpet I think was the original carpet of the house from when he was a kid over there playing,” Mariano said. “The entire project, we started fresh. That’s all you can do. There’s nothing you can really salvage when it’s 40 years old.”
They also had to battle some nasty weather in early May while trying to refurbish the exterior of O’Connell’s house. At one point, Mariano had Gardell running a jackhammer. It all worked out, though, and the shoot culminated with the comedian taking Mariano to Rocco’s Tavern in Swissvale.
Turner said that the scene at Rocco’s was “one of the most heartwarming, beautiful scenes that I’ve seen on television in a really long time.” Mariano was just honored that Gardell was willing to a show a diehard Boston sports fan one of his favorite local watering holes.
“In a lot of ways, despite the rivalry in sports, Pittsburgh and Boston are very similar,” he said. “The neighborhood bar thing is something that I understand from growing up. ... I know it meant a lot to Billy to show me this place.”

Most “Secret Celebrity Renovation” episodes feature someone that Turner has come across in her role as a host of “Entertainment Tonight.” She had never met Donald, though, even during her time as an NFL sideline reporter. It was a little daunting for her and Mariano to meet the Los Angeles Rams defensive tackle and recent Super Bowl champion, but Turner was ”pleasantly surprised at how fun he was.”
The main focus with that renovation was on “The Dungeon,” the gym Donald’s father built in the house’s basement that served as an early training ground for the future NFL superstar. Mariano “brought it into the 21st century” with some assistance from Donald and his brother, Archie Jr. They also helped remodel the kitchen, and Mariano was in awe of how Donald was able to rip up the countertop all by himself.
“It was the fastest demolition we had done at that point,” he said. “He’s a force of nature for sure.”
Donald’s father was kept in the dark about what his son was really doing back home. He was led to believe that the crew following his son around was filming a football-related documentary, and Mariano said that it was “completely satisfying” to see the look of shock on his face when the final renovation was revealed. It led to some special father-son moments that Turner will never forget.
“Seeing this play out with two Black men on television with the love, emotion and care, it filled my heart,” Turner said. “It was everything to me.”
Looking back at it, Turner thinks that Gardell and Donald’s episodes “were the most emotional episodes of the season.” She can’t wait for everyone to see their stories and more during season two of “Secret Celebrity Renovation.”
“Things are rough all over in America right now,” she said. “This show is goodness from start to finish. It’s escapism for an hour a week. For me, it’s inspirational and aspirational TV.
“That’s something we all need a little more of right now.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.