When Gabriella DeLuca began working for WPXI-TV in 2017, the Hampton native was just thrilled to be covering her hometown. She was excited to learn from Channel 11 stalwarts like Renee Wallace and Amy Marcinkiewicz, who had spent long careers in Pittsburgh.

Less than five years later, neither Wallace nor Marcinkiewicz work at WPXI anymore, leaving the 32-year-old reporter feeling like a seasoned veteran.

“They were always on the big story every single day and I really respected that,” DeLuca told the Post-Gazette. “Slowly, as they have left, it’s like, who’s going to be on the big story for the day? Oh wait, that might be me! I’ve definitely felt like I’ve had to step up.”

Anyone who watches local TV news regularly has noticed major changes in on-air talent over the last year across all three stations. Local news legends like Stacy Smith and Kelly Frey are no longer on the air at KDKA-TV and WTAE-TV, respectively, and established reporters like WTAE’s David Kaplan and WPXI’s Michele Newell have left for Washington, D.C. and Atlanta, two bigger media markets.

Advertise with us

In response, KDKA, WPXI and WTAE have brought in an influx of broadcast talent from other markets. Many are younger and are still getting to know Pittsburgh and its intense interest in the people they see on TV every day. Will this changing of the guard mean a dip in the quality of TV news? Insiders who agreed to talk to us don’t think so.

“Today, these kids are coming out of school and they’re ready to go right on the air,” said Sally Wiggin, a WTAE anchor and reporter from 1980 until her retirement in 2018. “And that was just beginning to happen when I was coming into it. They’re so much better off than I was. ... Just because they have this fresh, young face doesn’t mean that they aren’t skilled journalists.”

From L-R: Christine McMahon Tumpson, Joy Martino and former KDKA-TV reporter Paul Martino pose for a photo during an event at The Oaklander Hotel in December. (John Colombo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The old guard

Wiggin turned down an anchor job in Atlanta to join WTAE’s news team, which speaks to what a big news market Pittsburgh was in the late 20th century. Times have changed, with the latest Nielsen market-size rankings placing Atlanta at No. 7 in the country and Pittsburgh at No. 26 behind markets like St. Louis, Raleigh-Durham and Indianapolis. Jobs in Pittsburgh broadcast news are still highly coveted, “but it ain’t a top 20 market” anymore, as Wiggin put it.

It took the Michigan-born Wiggin a while to get her bearings in the Steel City, and she remembered feeling like viewers didn’t take her seriously at first because of her perm hairdo and wardrobe. As other reporters and anchors moved on, however, Wiggin became one of WTAE’s best known personalities, not an easy achievement.

Advertise with us

“This is a business that is not kind to older people, especially older women,” she said.

More than 40 years after she began at Channel 4, many of the viewers who watched her back then are now in their 60s, like her. “They have their habits baked in,” which explains why they might bristle at all the new blood on their favorite news stations. Wiggin also had some theories about why there may have been so much turnover in the last year.

“I think COVID has had something to do with this. ... Some people have decided they don’t want to do it anymore. They don’t like the hours and they walk away from being at the beck and call of management.”

Paul Martino, a KDKA reporter and anchor for 37 years before his June retirement, said it was “a huge boon for me to come to Pittsburgh” from a station in Mobile, Ala. But as he became an elder statesmen at KDKA, he began to realize how fragile his seniority truly was. That was hammered home in the mid-1990s when he saw reporter and anchor Patti Burns leave Channel 2 over a contract dispute.

“If they get rid of her, they can get rid of any of us,” he said. “It’s the nature of the beast.”

Advertise with us

In Martino’s mind, one of KDKA’s greatest strengths over the years has been the consistency of its journalists. With all the recent turnover, he’s heard many longtime viewers saying things like: “I don’t know anybody anymore on that station.”

“There’s a lot less stability in an already unstable profession,” he said. However, Martino has been impressed by the new wave of reporters, anchors and producers.

“The young people that are getting hired are really talented and hard-working people working under the most difficult of circumstances,” he said. “It’s much more difficult to do the job than it was 20 or 30 years ago.”

A cyclical industry

Scott Trabandt has been WPXI’s news director for about 2½ years. The Washington, D.C. native came to Channel 11 from NBC Washington and quickly realized that fans of Pittsburgh’s local news stations “have an appreciation and care of who’s coming, who’s going and what perspective different people are bringing.” That’s a sign of how passionate Pittsburghers are about their local news, he said.

Advertise with us

“The consistency of anchors, meteorologists, reporters over the past 10 to 15 years in Pittsburgh was remarkable,” Trabandt said. “When you’re celebrating journalists for 20, 30, 35 years, there’s going to be a point when they’re ready for the next steps in their lives. And I think that’s what we’re seeing right now. It’s cyclical, and we’re certainly seeing some of that.

“I think that cycle has been pushed forward by the pandemic and people re-evaluating their priorities. But we’re also seeing a lot of new folks come in and wanting to put down roots and being here for the long haul. I think those folks will hopefully be the story in 10 to 20 years, too.”

KDKA and WTAE’s news directors declined to comment for this story or make any of their current on-air talent available for interviews.

Despite Pittsburgh’s shrinking market size, Trabandt said the new reporters being hired have already proven their skills at smaller or comparably sized stations. Viewers “can feel good about the values and interests and motives of the journalists” who are still here, he said.

That includes veterans like Rick Earle, who has been at WPXI since 1994. For him, the most tangible loss from all the retirements and relocations is the network of sources they leave behind that can take years for new reporters to cultivate.

Advertise with us

Even with that in mind, Earle still sees an “insatiable appetite for news in Pittsburgh,” which he calls “a great place [for television reporters] to set up shop and raise your family.

“From a viewer’s perspective, they have to give the younger reporters a chance,” he said. “I think they do in general. For gosh sakes, they took a chance on me in 1994. I think the viewers are very open and realize there’s change in this business and for the most part welcome in new faces.”

Gabriella DeLuca is a 32-year-old WPXI-TV reporter who has been with the station since 2017. (Photo provided by Gabriella DeLuca)

‘Here for a reason’

Wiggin advises any journalist starting out in Pittsburgh to study the city’s history and not think of it as a “stepping stone” in between their previous job and the next one.

“There’s nothing wrong with ambition, but also know this is a wonderful place to grow and have a career,” she said. “You can do great journalism at a local station.”

Advertise with us

For Martino, success in local news is all about figuring out how to get viewers to tune into the 6 p.m. news instead of watching Netflix, playing video games or the myriad of other media options at their fingertips. Journalists need to “concentrate on your work and your skills, and good things will come,” he said.

Trabandt said the changing picture is not just of younger reporters coming from smaller markets. In July, WPXI hired KDKA and WTAE veteran Susan Koeppen to anchor its new 4 p.m. newscast and in September brought over reporter Nicole Ford from KDKA. Soon after Ford’s move, WPXI reporter Shelley Bortz left Channel 11 for KDKA.

Plus, there are still lots of familiar faces across all three stations, including DeLuca and Earle. DeLuca believes all the recent departures and arrivals are “just part of this business.” As somebody still striving to reach the stature of predecessors like Wallace and Marcinkiewicz, all she can promise is that she and her colleagues will continue to put their best efforts into every story.

“If you are seeing a reporter on TV, they’re here for a reason,” DeLuca said. “They’re here because they proved themselves in some way. They deserve to be embraced, just like the people who have been there for decades. ... It might seem like a new face to you, but they’ve done the work and I feel they should be treated with the same respect that everyone is here.

“We’re all trying our hardest to put good local news on TV.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.