There’s a pretty obvious reason why Amy Baumgardner and Sarah Simone decided to name their podcast “The Unqualified Therapists Inc.”: They are not therapists, nor are they qualified mental health professionals.

It’s a name Baumgardner, 42, of Whitehall, and Simone, 39, of Baldwin Borough, came up with over a couple of White Claws one day when they realized their natural chemistry and off-kilter brand of humor might lend itself well to a podcast.

To them, the moniker was a catchy way to explain that their mission is not to replace traditional therapists but rather to remove the stigma around the idea of seeking one through sharing stories about their own hard-earned life experiences.

“The purpose of this podcast is not to give advice,” said Simone, a native of Wheeling, W.Va. “We’re here to let people know they’re not alone and that the weird [expletive] they’re thinking, they’re not the only ones thinking that.”

Advertise with us

Launched in November, “The Unqualified Therapists Inc.” features Simone and Baumgardner shooting the breeze about whatever topic has their interest on a given day, no matter how taboo. That could be anecdotes from their past or present, wide-ranging conversations about sex (with a sex therapist on hand to provide expertise), yarns about the trials and tribulations of motherhood, and much, much more.

An average episode is essentially the kind of witty banter that begins every episode of the true-crime-meets-comedy podcast “My Favorite Murder” minus the murder story. For an example of their sense of humor, “The Unqualified Therapists Inc.” has the tagline “the only UTI you’ll ever want.”

“We’re off-color a little bit,” said Baumgardner, who grew up in Greensburg. “We’re not for everybody. We make some what I think are hilarious jokes that somebody might be offended by.”

Ultimately, their goal is “to help diminish the stigma of seeking professional mental health help,” Baumgardner says. To that end, they consult with actual licensed therapists (including their own) and often have them on as guests to steer listeners and themselves in the healthiest possible direction.

They may not be certified therapists, but they are educated. Simone has a psychology degree from Bethany College and is now a stylist for clothing-curation site Stitch Fix. Baumgardner earned a master’s degree in education from Ohio University and is currently an elementary school teacher. The two met through the LuLaRoe clothing company while trying to launch their own businesses that didn’t end up panning out.

Advertise with us

Both know a thing or two about life’s curveballs. Simone had a mastectomy after being diagnosed with breast cancer at age 36. Baumgardner got a crash course in mental health care when her husband, who was living with bipolar disorder, took his own life in 2019.

They have been clinically diagnosed with anxiety and depression, which is partially why they have become amateur mental health advocates. Simone said part of the reason she and Baumgardner bonded so quickly was because “we had so much of this trauma and bad experience inside of us.”

“I really needed to know that other people have lived this story before and made it to the other end,” Baumgardner said. “We’ve lived this [expletive], and here we are, still standing. Still a mess, but still standing.”

People seem to be tuning in so far. “The Unqualified Therapists” got close to 4,000 downloads in its first six months and is averaging about 100 downloads an episode. They only recently got public relations representation, so most of that initial growth was purely organic.

Going forward, Simone and Baumgardner hope the podcast will become big enough that they can start booking more experts and, in a post-pandemic world, eventually do live shows.

Advertise with us

“We are here to support everyone, and we are a safe space for all,” Simone said. “We are going to fight for and use our voices to advocate for those who cannot.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.