TORONTO — How do you inhabit an icon?

For Tom Hanks, a film actor who has portrayed a number of real-life personalities, Fred Rogers was a special challenge.

Unlike Chesley Sullenberger, pilot of the Miracle on the Hudson flight in “Sully,” there were no big heroics on screen.

Same with astronaut Jim Lovell in “Apollo 13,” among other roles.

Advertise with us

Fred Rogers? The children’s public television host and advocate who died in 2003? First off, Mr. Hanks said, “Make sure he remains a human being.”

Mr. Hanks was speaking Sunday at a news media panel during the Toronto International Film Festival, where “A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood” had its world premiere the night before. Shot in the Pittsburgh area in 2018, it is scheduled to debut in theaters Nov. 22.

“Fred required of me to somehow still the wild horses,” he said. “Letting go of that reality, that pressure. It helped, being able to put on that suit of armor, those khaki pants that made my butt look really big.”

“The truth is, I think one of the hardest things to do as an actor is be so totally open at all times,” said Marielle Heller, the film’s director, whom Mr. Hanks referred to as “Boss.”

“Being totally present, without affectation or, not having your walls up. It’s painful in many ways.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Hanks delivers a nuanced performance as the host of “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood.” It’s hard to imagine that Mr. Hanks won’t be an Oscar nominee for supporting actor. Matthew Rhys, as a cynical journalist whose character is central to the story, is also getting rave reviews from critics.

The film is 100% fresh on Rotten Tomatoes.

“Tom is incredibly funny, boisterous, alive. He walks into the room and shakes everyone’s hand; he’s a really charming person,” Ms. Heller said.

Yet, “we asked him to go to a vulnerable place. … I think people will be really blown away. He transforms. It’s not a showy performance, but it’s really, really affecting.”

The screenplay by Noah Harpster and Micah Fitzerman-Blue was about 10 years in the making. Mr. Harpster recalled setting down his cranky toddler one day and as they watched the show, an amazing thing happened.

Advertise with us

The child did a few tumbles, per Mister Rogers’ suggestion, then settled down. The idea for a film was born.

The script kicked around Hollywood for a few years; the writers actually made a visit to what was then the Fred Rogers Company as it was moving out of WQED Multimedia in Oakland.

Mr. Hanks and Ms. Heller, who had not worked together previously, eventually found their way to the treatment. It’s based on the Esquire magazine article “Can You Say … Hero?” by Tom Junod.

The movie takes a few fictional liberties in a story about Mr. Rogers’ life-changing influence on the cynical journalist, played by Mr. Rhys as “Lloyd Vogel.”

“The biggest thing for me was, [Mr. Junod] and Joanne [Rogers, Fred Rogers’ widow] and Bill Isler [former Fred Rogers Company CEO] all felt that the essence of this relationship was right and that the dynamics of it were right, and that the heart of it felt right,” Ms. Heller said in a private interview.

Advertise with us

Throughout the Toronto festival’s news media events for the film, multitudes of people perhaps unfamiliar with Fred Rogers seemed surprised by his genuine concern for others.

“You realize how many lives he touched,” said Mr. Rhys, whose character is central to the film. “I think this one story of Tom Junod is the perfect vehicle of showing who Fred was and what he did. How he transformed peoples’ lives.”

“For many audience members, [Junod] is us. We come into this movie thinking, ‘Eh, I don’t know if I’m going to buy into any of this,’” Ms. Heller said.

At the Sunday panel, two journalists from Spain asked what Rogers, the Latrobe native who was also an ordained minister, stood for.

Mr. Hanks and others answered that Rogers was a soothing, reassuring presence in a world that often gravitates toward cynicism as a default mode.

Advertise with us

“Because it’s easy and there’s good money to be made of it,” Mr. Hanks said. “It’s a great product to sell, cynicism. … I think when Fred Rogers first saw children’s programming, he saw something cynical. Why in the world would you put a pipeline of cynicism into the minds of 2-year-old kids?

“That you are not cool ’cause you don’t have this toy, that it’s funny to see someone being bonked on the head. That ‘Hey kids, be the first in line to get blah blah blah.’ ”

Ms. Heller’s choice of an opening scene, Mr. Hanks said, was “brilliant.” It’s that familiar entrance into Mister Rogers’ house on the WQED show, accompanied by that opening theme song.

And speaking of that scene …

“If you think you have a lot of time in that song, you try to come in, take your jacket off, close the door, take one pair of shoes off and put the other shoes on,” Mr. Hanks said.

Advertise with us

It took 22 takes. Just getting the handmade red cardigan sweater properly zipped up was a challenge, he said.

Ms. Heller interrupted: “I’m going to tell you something I never told you.”

“Please,” Mr. Hanks replied.

“When we finished those 22 takes, I realized I made it harder for you than it ever was for Fred,” she said.

It seems Rogers already had the tennis shoe laces pre-knotted. Ms. Heller noticed this after the scene was shot.

Advertise with us

“That movie was a living hell,” Mr. Hanks joked.

Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or @MariaSciulloPG.