PASADENA, Calif. — Remember Bill Hader’s Stefon character from “Weekend Update” on “Saturday Night Live”? It’s easy to imagine Stefon describing Fox’s new legal drama: “‘Proven Innocent’ has everything: heavy-handed exposition, plot holes galore, a hip-for-today true-crime podcast, Kelsey Grammer as a mustache-twirling state’s attorney without a mustache, and a bearded Vincent Kartheiser wielding a sword!”
Premiering at 9 p.m. Friday on WPGH-TV, “Proven Innocent” takes an everything-but-the-kitchen-sink approach to storytelling.
Sure, there are moments of winning courtroom drama — mostly of sub-“The Good Wife” variety — but the show packs in a lot more. Early in Friday’s pilot, that pace works, but, eventually, it bogs down after the show piles one too many bits of ridiculousness on top of the last.
The series follows criminal defense lawyer Madeline Scott (Rachelle Lefevre, “Under the Dome”) who fights to free prisoners she believes were wrongly convicted. She’s often up against prosecutor Gore Bellows (Mr. Grammer, in “Boss” mode), who sent her and her brother, Levi (Riley Smith), to prison as teens for the murder of a friend.
Madeline has a vendetta against Bellows, who, because this is a black and white broadcast network drama and not a shades-of-gray cable show, really is villainous despite his protestations otherwise.
Madeline has set up her innocence project law firm with Easy Boudreau (Russell Hornsby, “Grimm”), who helped exonerate her. The team includes investigator Bodie Quick (Mr. Kartheiser) and communications director/podcast host Violet Price (Nikki M. James, “The Good Wife”).
Written by David Eliot (“G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra”) and executive produced by Danny Strong, who co-created Fox’s “Empire,” “Proven Innocent” mixes case-of-the-week stories featuring hot-button themes (media narratives, abortion, etc.) and the occasional welcome left turn (see the end of episode four). There’s also a serialized story about who really murdered Rosemary, the friend Madeline and Levi were initially convicted of killing.
But the writing often sounds like it’s from one of those bad shows within a show that characters on a smarter series watch (see: “Darkness at Noon,” which Alicia used to watch on “The Good Wife”).
“It’s the end of the road, can’t kill your way out of this one,” Madeline tells a suspect in the opening moments of Friday’s premiere.
“Says you, lady,” the perp replies before calling her bluff in an entirely predictable way.
‘Doom Patrol’
Give credit where it’s due: “Doom Patrol,” a new live-action superhero series debuting Friday on streaming service DC Universe, understands the media environment it enters.
“More TV superheroes, just what the world needs,” sneers narrator Mr. Nobody (Alan Tudyk, “Firefly”). “Be honest, have you hung yourself yet?”
From there he explains it’s actually a story about “super losers, achingly pathetic meta-humans.” Of course, Mr. Nobody is the villain of the piece, so his perspective will be skewed, but “Doom Patrol” offers an entertaining, illuminating pilot episode that distinguishes itself by doing a deep dive into the backstories of its characters. The premiere explains through flashbacks how race car driver Cliff Steele (Brendan Fraser) became encased in metal as Robotman, how ace pilot Larry Trainor (2000 Carnegie Mellon University grad Matt Bomer, “White Collar”) turned into bandage-wrapped Negative Man, and how ’50s screen star Rita Farr (April Bowlby) mutated into Elasti-Woman. Now they’re all living in a mansion with modern-day mad scientist Niles Caulder, aka The Chief (Timothy Dalton).
Episode two will introduce Cyborg (Jovian Wade), who sets the Doom Patrol on a mission, but showrunner Jeremy Carver said the 15-episode first season will really be about the characters finding themselves.
What you wouldn’t find on the set is Mr. Bomer in bandages or Mr. Fraser in the robot suit. Mr. Bomer and Mr. Fraser share the role with actors who do the suit scenes; the big-name stars only appear as the characters in flashback before they’re covered up.
“Sometimes there can be a slight misperception about what it is to be a suit actor,” Mr. Carver said during a press conference at the Television Critics Association winter 2019 press tour. “Riley Shanahan and Matthew Zuk [the actors in the suits] are tremendous actors. … Early on we had a lot of discussion on how to deal with this, and both sets of actors sat there studying one another to make sure they were in sync before we really got this show launched. I think we're all pretty hopeful that it’s paid off.”
Channel surfing
“Friends” reruns, currently on Netflix, will ultimately relocate to and live exclusively on the streaming service being developed by WarnerMedia. … Hulu’s “The Handmaid’s Tale” will return for season three on June 5. … Hulu ordered four animated series from Marvel Television — “Marvel’s M.O.D.O.K,” “Marvel’s Hit-Monkey,” “Marvel’s Tigra & Dazzler Show” and “Marvel’s Howard the Duck” — which will culminate in a special, “Marvel’s The Offenders.” … One of the subjects of the 2018 documentary film “Science Fair” (8 p.m. May 9, National Geographic Channel), Abraham Riedel-Mishaan, is now a student at Carnegie Mellon University.
Post-Gazette TV writer Rob Owen is attending the Television Critics Association winter press tour. Follow RobOwenTV at Twitter or Facebook. You can reach him at 412-263-2582 or rowen@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.