This month two scripted series debut using Area 51 as a backdrop, History’s “Project Blue Book” and The CW reboot “Roswell, New Mexico.” Not all alien-themed series are created equal.

“Project Blue Book”

Imagine a more obvious, predictable version of “The X-Files” without the smart character development or opportunity for romance between the lead characters and you’ll know what to expect from History’s “Project Blue Book” (10 p.m. Tuesday).

Supposedly “inspired by” the personal experiences of Dr. J. Allen Hynek (Aidan Gillen, who played Littlefinger on “Game of Thrones”), the series is told from Hynek’s point of view. He’s the Mulder — albeit more questioner than true believer — to Air Force captain Quinn (Michael Malarkey, “The Vampire Diaries”), who’s a soldier more devoted to career advancement than to scientific skepticism. Hynek wants to find the truth; Quinn just wants to close cases.

Advertise with us

In early episodes, the pair investigates a dogfight between a fighter jet and UFO over North Dakota and a potential crashed UFO in West Virginia.

Slathered over the top is a running mystery about a man in a black hat whom Hynek keeps seeing. Black Hat leads him to an abandoned amusement park where a film playing shows a symbol that is supposed to have great portent. But these potentially intriguing moments feel entirely manufactured, and the plots in between are paint-by-number plain with sometimes painfully bad dialogue.

“Don’t tell us how to run our town!” shout locals to the Feds in the West Virginia episode, sounding like torch-bearing villagers from a low-rent production of “Beauty and the Beast.” “We don’t need your kind here!”

Air Force higher-ups (Neal McDonough, Michael Harney) encourage Quinn to keep Hynek in line, always disproving the existence of UFOs, but episode two reveals the military leaders are sitting on a big secret themselves.

The third episode moves the ball forward ever so slightly as Quinn experiences firsthand a potential encounter with a UFO, but then he gets marching orders and follows right along. Viewers have seen this two-steps-forward-one-step-back shuffle in plenty of past UFO, conspiracy-minded series. There’s no reason to sit through it again.

Advertise with us

“Roswell, New Mexico”

A reboot of the 1999-2002 WB series “Roswell,” The CW’s “Roswell, New Mexico” (9 p.m. Jan. 15, WPCW-TV) adds a timely, more specific immigration overlay as border patrol not only goes after illegal human immigrants, but the military also tracks the hiding-in-plain-sight aliens who crash-landed in Roswell in 1947.

Sometimes the aliens-as-immigrants rhetoric is a little too on the nose (“They are a violent race,” says a military leader of the extraterrestrial threat. “At their core, they’re killers!”) but as remakes go, this iteration of “Roswell” seems like it will appeal to the current CW audience. (Whether fans of the original watch is immaterial to CW execs; at this point, fans of the first series are mostly outside The CW’s key demo.)

The story begins as Liz Ortecho (Jeanine Mason) returns to Roswell after working in bio research in Denver. She reconnects with her teenage crush, Max Evans (Nathan Parsons), a Roswell cop who is also an alien with powers he uses to save Liz’s life after she is shot.

When Liz starts investigating her wound — Max healed it on the spot — Max wants to tell Liz his secret, much to the chagrin of his alien sister, Isobel (Lily Cowles), and their alien friend, Michael (Michael Vlamis).

Advertise with us

Redeveloped by Carina Adly MacKenzie (“The Originals,” “The Flash”) and executive produced by Julie Plec (“The Originals,” “Legacies”), this iteration of “Roswell” ages up the characters. On the original “Roswell,” which began as a book series, the characters were all teenagers in high school. This new pilot begins with the characters attending their 10-year high school reunion.

Reimagined “Roswell” also contains a murder mystery and a gay couple, which were not part of the original mix. Isobel is married to a human, and he doesn’t know her secret (yet).

As for casting different actors as these characters who generally adhere to the same archetypes (just older), they’re fine but may be hard to embrace for fans of the original series. One potential couple has notably more chemistry than another potential couple.

Was a “Roswell” remake necessary? Probably not, but if it prevents The CW from making yet another superhero series, then it’s accomplished something positive.

Tuned In online

Advertise with us

Today’s TV Q&A column responds to questions about “Six,” “The View” and background music on TV shows. This week’s Tuned In Journal includes posts on “The Masked Singer.” Read online-only TV content at  http://communityvoices.post-gazette.com/arts-entertainment-living/tuned-in.

TV writer Rob Owen: rowen@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2582. Follow RobOwenTV on Twitter or Facebook for breaking TV news.