It’s always risky to judge a TV show solely on its pilot episode — some shows get better; for others, the pilot is as good as it gets — but in the world of broadcast TV, that’s often all a TV critic has to go on.

The good news for ABC is two winning comedy pilots, “The Kids Are Alright” and “Single Parents,” and a solid debut from the network’s new Nathan Fillion-starring cop show, “The Rookie,” which breaks no new ground and is fairly predictable but well made for what it is.

The CW’s engaging teen drama “All American” actually does break some new ground even though it’s a familiar story of the good kid who moves from a rough neighborhood to a better neighborhood. Unlike in past teen series, like “The O.C.,” where the lead kid never goes back to the old neighborhood, “All American” plans to straddle both worlds.

As for the worst shows, I feel bad about NBC’s “I Feel Bad,” a comedy pilot with a terrific Indian-American cast that just isn’t funny and also kind of anti-#MeToo.

Advertise with us

Fox’s “The Cool Kids” wants to be a latter-day male buddy version of “Golden Girls,” but its comedy is obvious and predictable despite, again, a terrific cast that’s not well served by the script.

And there are a million little things wrong with “A Million Little Things,” ABC’s attempt at a feelings drama (a la “This is Us”), but most notably the characters are largely unlikable.

BEST

“All American” (The CW).

“The Kids Are Alright” (ABC).

Advertise with us

“The Rookie” (ABC).

“Single Parents” (ABC).

WORST

“The Cool Kids” (Fox).

“I Feel Bad” (NBC).

Advertise with us

“A Million Little Things” (ABC).

— Rob Owen, Post-Gazette TV writer