BEVERLY HILLS, Calif. — The year of Mister Rogers isn’t only ushering in remembrances of the real man in the red cardigan: Showtime also has “Kidding” (10 p.m. Sept. 9), a half-hour dramedy starring Jim Carrey as a Mister Rogers-like children’s show host.
Like Fred Rogers, Mr. Carrey’s Jeff Pickles is kind and soft-spoken. He eschews profanity. He lives in the middle of the country (Columbus, Ohio, instead of Pittsburgh). He’s had a 30-year career in television and his show, “Mr. Pickles’ Puppet Time,” airs on PBS stations. He sings about feelings. Children ask Mr. Pickles how he got “out of the television.” Mr. Pickles is saintly and insists on doing the right thing. A future episode will address rumors that Mr. Pickles was a wartime sniper (like the untrue internet rumor about Fred Rogers being an ex-Navy Seal).
But Mr. Pickles also strays from Mister Rogers’ image and biography in significant ways. Mr. Pickles doesn’t control his own TV show, instead he’s under the thumb of his overbearing executive producer father (Frank Langella); Mr. Pickles is separated from his wife (Judy Greer) following the death of their son in a traffic accident.
Mr. Carrey said he was drawn to the series because of its themes, which somewhat echo those of “The Truman Show.”
“The idea of identity, the search for identity, who we are and what’s an authentic person is a theme that’s always been attractive to me,” Mr. Carrey said at a press conference during the Television Critics Association summer 2018 press tour.
The death of Mr. Pickles’ son is the inciting event, and Mr. Pickles’ state of being a year after that tragedy is where the story begins.
“There’s definitely something in this piece that calls [to] me as far as the idea of being hit by a freight train in life and trying to hang on to the idea of yourself that you had before it happened,” Mr. Carrey said. “That’s an incredible concept to me.”
“Kidding” creator David Holstein said he wrote the initial pilot after writing for “Weeds” and feeling anti-hero fatigue. He was interested in the journey “of somebody who didn’t want to break bad but wanted to stay good. So to me it was about finding someone who had a crisis of faith but really wanted to preserve their goodness in a world that was populated by all the dark edges of premium cable but not the character himself.”
Although promotions for “Kidding” posit the series will follow Mr. Pickles as he descends to a breaking point, Mr. Holstein said it’s really about how a person struggles to maintain who they are when everything around them has changed.
“The easy version of this show is writing ‘Mister Rogers becomes Bad Santa’ and that would have gotten old really quickly,” Mr. Holstein said. “It wasn’t about crafting an arc about here is someone having a nervous breakdown or psycho Mister Rogers.”
In a follow-up interview Mr. Holstein explained that to only follow Mr. Pickles into a breakdown would be a finite journey. He suggests Mr. Pickles may be having a breakthrough even as he struggles over the course of the series to maintain his TV show and get his broken family back together.
“I think he’ll achieve and fail at that at various points of the show,” Mr. Holstein said, noting the season one arc is Mr. Pickles burying his anger and brokering to allow that anger to emerge for certain reasons in front of only certain people.
The series deviates from reality by having the “Mr. Pickles” executive producer fret that PBS will cut off funding over an episode about death. It’s a big plot point in early episodes as it forces Mr. Pickles to repress his feelings.
Both “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood” and successor series “Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood” have featured episodes about death. Mr. Holstein sees the Mr. Pickles situation differently because if Mr. Pickles addresses the death of his son or his divorce on the air — something so personal — it will change the audience conception of the Mr. Pickles character.
Mr. Holstein said unlike the movie “Death to Smoochy,” “Kidding” is not a satire but a love letter to children’s television. He even hired a writer from “Sesame Street” to help with world building and realism (on children’s television, use the word “home;” not all children live in a “house”).
Director Michel Gondry (“Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind”) brings eye-popping visuals to “Mr. Pickles’ Puppet Time” that crosses a “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood” aesthetic with the chaos of “Pee-Wee’s Playhouse.”
Mr. Carrey, who once lampooned Mister Rogers on “In Living Color,” said he’s studied Fred Rogers but said Mr. Pickles is not an impression.
“He’s an energy,” Mr. Carrey said of Mister Rogers. “There’s a softness and understanding and just this beautiful, open person.”
Post-Gazette TV writer Rob Owen is attending the Television Critics Association summer press tour. Follow RobOwenTV at Twitter or on Facebook. You can reach Rob at 412-263-2582 or rowen@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.