Pittsburgh has had its share of gritty comeback stories, so it was fitting for Gabby Barrett to dedicate Journey’s “Don’t Stop Believin’” to her hometown Sunday night. ABC even brought in the band’s former lead vocalist to surprise the Munhall teen after she’d finished.

“She was amazing, that was my critique,” Steve Perry said.

Just what level of amazing will be revealed Monday (9 p.m.). Ms. Barrett, 18, certainly has her fans: Judge Luke Bryan remarked, late in the night’s broadcast, that she’s “one of the best singers I’ve ever heard, and she proves it night in, night out.”

Also in the running are Caleb Lee Hutchinson, 19, of Dallas, Ga., and Maddie Poppe, 20, of Clarksville, Iowa. Mr. Hutchinson, with an extraordinarily deep voice, is a country singer. Ms. Poppe has more of an indie style, “authentic as heck,” according to judge Katy Perry.

Advertise with us

Hometown visits, shot last Tuesday, were a feature in the second half of Sunday’s broadcast. Highlights of Ms. Barrett’s mini-concert at the Rivers Casino on the North Shore and a visit to the Goodwill of West Mifflin were part of the package.

Perhaps it was a good omen that for her final number, dedicated to the city of Pittsburgh, Ms. Barrett wore a short dress encrusted with tiny mirrors. It looked rather like the Mirrorball Trophy that will be handed over to the winner of ABC’s “Dancing With the Stars: Athletes” shortly before Monday’s “AI” finale.

Yet all three finalists got off to tentative starts. Each performed an original song relatively unknown to the general public. Mr. Hutchinson came in too soon at the beginning of “Johnny Cash Heart,” and Ms. Barrett’s gospel-flavored “Rivers Deep” took a while to get rolling.

It’s tough, debuting a song the crowd is not familiar with, the judges said, and Ms. Perry later deemed the round “a disaster.”

“From now on, when you select a song, select from ‘stage back,’” judge Lionel Richie told Ms. Barrett. “You want the impact of it all [on stage].”

Advertise with us

“You’re flipping into the role of ‘Hey, I’ve got to get out there and sell myself, sell this song,’” Mr. Bryan said. Then he added that, fortunately, Ms. Barrett stuck the landing on the finish.

The judges said Ms. Poppe, with “Going Going Gone,” seemed the most comfortable.

All three responded with fine versions of songs they’d previously performed on “American Idol.” Ms. Barrett, in a fringed black miniskirt and silver high-heeled boots, danced through Miranda Lambert’s “Little Red Wagon.”

When she finished, Ms. Perry waited through a long pause, then said quietly, “There she is. Hey, girl. That was awesome.”

Although Mr. Bryan complained, half-jokingly, that he was missing Ms. Barrett’s signature hair flip, it was clear the panel approved of the Pittsburgh teen. (She did the flip later, during “Don’t Stop Believin’.”)

Advertise with us

“The wonderful part of this is you’re owning the stage,” Mr. Richie said, adding that the next step is selling the Gabby Barrett brand with each performance.

Host Ryan Seacrest noted that “Little Red Wagon” could be a signature song. “That’s Gabby Barrett, right there,” the singer replied, smiling.

The voting window via “American Idol” app, online, text and social media (Ms. Barrett’s number is 14) goes from 8 p.m. Sunday through 9 a.m. Monday.

Turns out, one local institution that has been a local advertiser of the show sent a “cheer package” to Ms. Barrett Saturday. Eat’n Park delivered black-and-gold Smileys as well as signature sugar cookies with Ms. Barrett’s logo of “B” and “G.” According to a press release, she also gets Smiley cookies for life at the Waterfront location.

What could be sweeter than that? Being named the next “American Idol,” of course.

Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or @MariaSciulloPG.