Final Judgment day was nowhere near as ominous as it sounded. In fact, it brought joy for Gabby Barrett.
The Munhall teen learned Monday night she will be moving on to the next round of ABC’s “American Idol.” Ms. Barrett, who turned 18 a few weeks ago, was featured in previous shows since Season 16 returned March 11.
We can’t tell who’s more excited that @GabbyBarrett_ made it to the Top 24 - her or her Dad! #IdolShowcase #AmericanIdol pic.twitter.com/b7PsibiGxR
— American Idol (@AmericanIdol) April 3, 2018
She and 49 others were part of a showcase at Exchange LA, performing in front of a live audience and judges Katy Perry, Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. Ms. Barrett chose to sing “Church Bells,” by country star Carrie Underwood, a former American Idol herself.
It was a gutsy choice. When Ms. Barrett stepped up for her very first audition in Nashville, those same judges stopped her from singing it. They told her that imitating Ms. Underwood was inauthentic, and urged her to sing in her own voice.
The judges told @GabbyBarrett_ not to sing a @carrieunderwood song during her audition. It’s a brave choice to pick one for her #IdolShowcase. #AmericanIdol pic.twitter.com/dFay25jwiT
— American Idol (@AmericanIdol) April 3, 2018
On Monday’s broadcast, Ms. Perry was not impressed: “She’s got it, but I don’t know why she picked that song.”
“At this point in the competition, you’ve got to give it all or nothing,” said Ms. Barrett, who ended the the song belting.
When she got her sit-down evaluation the next day, the first thing Ms. Perry said was “So, Gabby, I think yesterday was bad for you.”
But Mr. Bryan chimed in, noting “I think you’re next-level and you’re what the competition needs.”
She and 23 others will sing again next Sunday in solo arrangements, and it appears some will have “all-star duets” with celebrity guests.
Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or @MariaSciulloPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.