Fred Rogers made an extraordinary impression on the people whose paths he crossed, mostly because he was so ordinary about it.
Anna Weltz, now director of public relations for the Laurel Highlands Visitors Bureau, cherishes meeting her “hero” in 1999 when she was a receptionist at Ligonier’s Idlewild Park and he was there for business. “He was as warm, friendly, kind and thoughtful in person as he was on TV.”
Every story is positive and not just those told on the occasion of his death in 2003. At that time, then-Post-Gazette reporter Tim Reeves reflected on how Mr. Rogers showed him special attention after the death of Mr. Reeves’ father, pastor at Sixth Presbyterian Church in Squirrel Hill.

Click here for the Post-Gazette’s 50th anniversary special section
“After that loss, I was a rather angry young man, and Fred showed me a special nurturing,” he wrote. “He invited me to swim early morning laps with him at the Pittsburgh Athletic Association, a discipline he treasured.”
Common are stories about Mr. Rogers making pool attendants, store clerks and strangers feel special. Writer Anthony Breznican told the world, via a viral thread of tweets on Twitter, how, as a struggling University of Pittsburgh student in 2001, he ran into this personality from his childhood on a campus elevator. Mr. Rogers not only hugged him, but also sat down for a long, deep and warm chat that lifted him.
“It was almost impossible to hurry him along,” says Joanne Rogers, his wife.
Especially with children, he’d stop and talk and sign autographs. Around Pittsburgh, she’d sometimes drive him so he could rush in and rush out of a store. Maybe.
Once when he needed a new sportcoat, his colleague and friend Bill Isler took him to Joseph Orlando Gentlemen’s Clothier, Downtown. Joseph Orlando Jr. recounts his father helping Mr. Rogers find one that he really liked.
“Well, Mr. Orlando, how much is this coat?” Mr. Rogers asked and was told it was several hundred dollars. “Oh my, I don’t know about that.” Mr. Isler convinced him he could afford it.
Colleen (Abraham) Sherman remembers waiting to see her regular customer when she worked at the former Squirrel Hill Bookstore as a Duquesne University grad student in the early 1990s. When she saw Mr. and Mrs. Rogers out front one day, she flew out of the store.
“I was immediately 5 years old.”
She asked him to sign one of his books for her brother, also a huge “Mister Rogers’” fan.
“I’ll never forget this: He said, ‘May I write, Through the kindness of Colleen?’ ... Oh my gosh, Mr. Rogers thinks I’m kind?! I was on cloud nine for days!
“He was completely unflappable,” adds Ms. Sherman. “He made me feel like I was the only person on Forbes Avenue that day.”
At Sixth Presbyterian Church, some still recall looking down and realizing: We’re sitting in the same pew as Mr. Rogers!
It was no big deal for the Rev. Jon McCall of Wilkinsburg, its former pastor. “We just treated him more or less like a normal guy. ... Fred was just Fred.”
“He just came to worship and to study. He really was totally inconspicuous,” agrees his adult Bible study teacher, Bill Guy, who still teaches that class on Sunday mornings at the church. “Fred’s manners were so exquisite. Every time at the end of class, he would thank me for the class. Out loud.”
Mr. Guy became Mr. Rogers’ close friend. And to be sure: Mr. Rogers was a great friend. Once in the early 1990s when Mr. Guy needed to have surgery at Presbyterian Hospital in Oakland, Mr. and Mrs. Rogers drove him there in the wee hours of the morning. Morning walks were often delayed by so many people wanting to talk with the star. As he was wont to do, Mr. Rogers would turn things around and talk about them.
“He blended into life,” says Cathy Tigano Gianella, a retired Post-Gazette designer who had the pleasure of working with him for about two decades, starting in the 1970s, when she designed and decorated sets at WQED. That’s where she met set carpenter Pat Gianella.
They’d been dating for about a year when, in July 1983, Mr. Gianella asked her to marry him. Not sure she wanted to go through a big Catholic wedding for a second time and knowing that Mr. Rogers was an ordained minister, she wisecracked that she would do it “if you get Fred to marry us.”
Fred Rogers at Cathy Tigano Gianella's wedding
Her boyfriend marched her upstairs to Mr. Rogers’ office and asked. She was shocked by his reply: “That would be wonderful! But you’d have to do it this Saturday.” After shooting “The Tonight Show,” you see, he was headed to his house on Nantucket for the rest of the summer.
So the two families threw themselves into rushed preparations, and that Saturday, Ms. Tigano found herself hiding in a bedroom, too petrified to leave the room.
Knock. Knock. It was Mr. Rogers. She recalls how soothing he was: “Cathy, there’s a lot of love out there. A lot of people would love to see this happen.”
He helped comb the bride’s hair and blow-dry the groom’s. “Things are going to be OK for both of you,” he said. “Now let’s do this.”
She remembers stepping out onto the deck, trembling as seemingly hundreds of cameras clicked and flashed. But her minister remained calm, and they all got through the ceremony.
Before a gang of stagehands helped Mr. Rogers make his escape from the adoring crowd, he said something Ms. Tigano will never forget:
“So you met in the Neighborhood of Make-Believe. And now we’ll make this real.”
Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.