U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy is adding his voice to the chorus of criticism of Dr. Phil, who interviewed actress Shelley Duvall about getting treatment for her mental illness, which was on full display throughout a Nov. 18 broadcast of his CBS television afternoon show.
Mia Farrow and Vivian Kubrick, the daughter of Stanley Kubrick, who directed Ms. Duvall in the 1980 movie “The Shining,” have called for a boycott of Phil McGraw’s show and described his actions as predatory and exploitative for showing a woman in the full throes of mental illness, regardless of his offers to help her get treatment.
During the interview, she said she was very sick and needed help, with moments of clarity about her career. But she also expressed fear that people purporting to help her actually will hurt her, adding that “the man who threatens me is the sheriff of Nottingham.” She also said she didn’t think the late Robin Williams, her co-star in the 1980 movie “Popeye,” is dead but is “shape-shifting.”
Reacting to the controversy, Mr. Murphy, a Republican congressman from Upper St. Clair, said in a statement that he was “astounded that this was broadcast under the banner of entertainment.”
“It reflects a woman in need of psychiatric medical care who lacked the basic executive functioning to understand the implications of her ‘consent’” to be interviewed, he said in a statement. “This should not have been pursued nor aired. Clearly she was not capable of consenting to this television experience due to her diminished cognitive capacity.
“Ms. Duvall has a basic right to privacy and the way in which she was exploited for afternoon entertainment is appalling,” he said.
During the broadcast, Dr. Phil offered to pay for treatment for Ms. Duvall and escorted her to a treatment center, where she ultimately declined treatment. The 67-year-old actress from Houston starred in numerous television shows and 35 movies from 1970 through 2002; besides her leading roles in “The Shining” and “Popeye,” she also had supporting roles in “Nashville” (1975) and “Annie Hall” (1977).
The media team of “Dr. Phil” did not respond Wednesday to a Post-Gazette request for comment.
After the broadcast, Ms. Farrow accused Dr. Phil online of “exploitation of the wonderful Shelley Duvall — masquerading as ‘powerful TV,’” which she described as shameful. “She’s a treasure. She deserves respect,” she said on the Deadline Hollywood website.
Ms. Kubrick said on the same website — deadline.com — that the interview was “purely a form of lurid and exploitative entertainment.”
Mr. Murphy, the only practicing psychologist in Congress, introduced the Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act that passed the House in July. The Senate is working on its own version of the bill.
It would make it easier for parents to keep tabs on children away at college, promote the use of telepsychiatry to reach rural areas where psychiatrists are in short supply and push insurers to provide comparable mental health and physical health benefits, among other provisions. It also would provide a means to increase mental health beds, improve outpatient treatment and use new strategies to keep people with mental illness out of hospitals.
He further said American society continues to exploit Americans with mental illness, who often are homeless or cycle in and out of emergency rooms and jail, with some ending up in the morgue.
“Even worse, we set them up for public mockery and ridicule,” he said. “We will only break down the stigma of mental illness by ending the lurid exploitation of the mentally ill and focus on educating the public about brain illness as a medical condition and how patients, when treated at the right time in the appropriate care setting, can and do recover.”
Ms. Duvall’s refusal to participate in treatment, he said, “reflects the desperate need to advance models of care designed for treatment-resistant patients.”
“Rather than wait for patients in the midst of a psychiatric crisis to fill up emergency rooms and often be sent out of the hospital without receiving treatment, we need to provide options for getting the treatment to those who need it most,” Mr. Murphy said.
David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.