Shortly before his 21st birthday this summer, Nathan Barnhouse wrote a letter to his 9-year-old self.
It begins with some general childhood nostalgia, citing the joy of learning to cook from his mother, exploring land around Slippery Rock, having a great time at summer camp. Then it gets darker.
“I don’t mean to scare you, but there are rough days ahead. You see, grade school is fun, but next year the bullying begins.”
“A lot of bad stuff happened to me. I was bullied to the point where I just wanted to give up,” he said of the letter, which is posted on his public Facebook page.
Mr. Barnhouse is a polarizing figure on Fox’s “MasterChef,” which returns tonight at 8 with a two-hour episode. He looks like a teenager, and his high voice makes him sound younger. He’s aware of his image; he describes himself as “quirky” on his Twitter page.
On the show, Mr. Barnhouse has been depicted as a liability in the team challenges. Twice in the early going, he was picked last. In group discussions, he’s been interrupted and dismissed by others.
This isn’t the whole story, said Mr. Barnhouse, who was in Pittsburgh recently for media commitments and to visit old friends. He eventually forged good relationships with many of his fellow chefs, but it took some doing.
“[Producers] made me seem very whiny, but I really felt I was assertive,” said Mr. Barnhouse, who said he knew going in that reality TV is shaped into narratives. (“I just didn’t realize how much editing there was.”)
Slippery Rock native competes in "MasterChef"
On a hot afternoon in Downtown recently, he was wearing his signature bow tie (pink), with a blue gingham check shirt and jeans. His hair, spiky on the program, was softer and lighter from the summer sun. Still, fans recognized him. Two women approached during lunch on the patio of a Market Square restaurant. “Excuse me ...” one began.
He gets that a lot these days. Later, at a nearby market, two men spotted him and asked if he minded posing for selfies. No problem, he said.
Positive attention has been a while coming. Mr. Barnhouse has spoken on camera about his being bullied, and the letter to his younger self mentions “snide remarks about your lack of coordination and rude comments about the way you run. When you muster up the nerve to try out for sports, three older boys make fun of you and throw you into the church dumpster.”
On “MasterChef,” there has been some garden-variety meanness toward Mr. Barnhouse but not from chief judge and host Gordon Ramsay. He is infamous for his bleep-out tirades and undisguised irritation toward contestants. Mr. Ramsay has four teen-age children, and it’s possible, Mr. Barnhouse said, that he felt a fatherly influence.
“He’s really nice to me. ... He’s never sworn at me. The only swear word, I think, was ‘damn.’”
Mr. Barnhouse’s parents are Christian missionaries living in Zambia. He was there for three years, making do with scarce cooking staples. Although religious talk is a rarity on American television, “I didn’t have to get up and say, ‘Today I have to be careful and not talk about God too much.’”
There are a couple of things Mr. Barnhouse, who is a theater major at Bob Jones University, would like “MasterChef” fans to know:
• He and fellow “ChefTestant” Andrea Galan are actually good friends despite early episodes of the Fox home cooks competition showing the two often butting heads. It’s led to vigorous online debate among the show’s fans.
“Andrea is my truest friend on that show, and it truly broke my heart when she left. ... We are like brother and sister. We keep up to date to this day.”
Each posted a photo of their recent visit to “MasterChef” judge Christina Tosi’s Milk Bar restaurant in New York City. They were all smiles.
“We love each other under all that frustration, LOL,” Ms. Galan, a New York University student, wrote on her Facebook page.
• After taking flak for not knowing a basic cooking practice, he has taken corrective action.
“I now know how to make rice,” he said. “In fact, several ways.”
Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1478 or @MariaSciulloPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.