Tom White, curator of special collections at Duquesne University’s Gumberg Library, pulls a box out of a metal cabinet.

“I thought this might interest you,” he says.

Inside is a neatly folded, off-white piece of fabric with the monogram “A.H.” stitched in one corner.

This was Adolf Hitler’s pillowcase from his Berlin bunker during the final days of the Third Reich.

Advertise with us

It’s part of a massive collection given to the school by the family of Michael Musmanno, a maverick Pittsburgh judge and Navy captain who presided over one of the Nuremberg war crimes trials after World War II.

Also included among his trunks, stacks of papers and manuscripts of 22 interviews he filmed in 1948 of Hitler staff members who shared the bunker with the fuhrer as the Red Army closed in.

A few in that inner circle presented the judge with souvenirs — the pillowcase, a commemorative dish, a set of Eva Braun printing plates — but the interviews gave him something more valuable than any artifact: First-hand accounts of Hitler’s suicide on April 30, 1945.

“He wanted to prove that Hitler was dead,” said Mr. White. “It’s amazing how fascinated people still are by Hitler.”

That fascination is what drives a new Smithsonian Channel documentary airing Monday night, “The Day Hitler Died,” showing the Musmanno interviews for the first time on American television.

Advertise with us

The program, produced by a Scottish company, uses recreations of bunker scenes interspersed with Musmanno’s one-on-one interviews, which he filmed on his own time and his own dime.

Although some accounts have maintained that these films were lost to history, they were never really missing - just tucked away unlabeled in Musmanno’s collection.

In 1948, he used the transcripts as the basis of a front page, first-person series he wrote for The Pittsburgh Press, complete with a diagram of the bunker, the first detailed accounting of Hitler’s demise.

He followed that up two years later with his best-seller, “Ten Days to Die,” which later became a movie. And parts of his films also appeared in a German production two years ago called “Witnesses of Doom.”

But no American audience has ever seen the interviews.

Advertise with us

David Royle, executive vice president of programming and production at Smithsonian Channel, said the interviews are the work of a “remarkable American naval officer” who recognized that the world would need a definitive answer for what happened to history’s “ultimate villain.”

Speculation that he had not killed himself in the bunker began almost immediately in April 1945, fueled in part by Josef Stalin, who suggested that Hitler had escaped to Spain or Argentina even though his own troops had reportedly found and secured Hitler’s jawbone.

Musmanno was determined to end any speculation.

“He was a man of purpose,” said Mr. Royle. “It was remarkably prescient, what he did. He knew the danger of this sort of mythology that Hitler survived.”

The mythology continues to this day. The History Channel, for example, just last week premiered an eight-episode series called “Hunting Hitler,” relying in part on declassified FBI documents indicating the bureau investigated reports that Hitler faked his death and fled by u-boat to South America.

Advertise with us

The possibility intrigues World War II conspiracy buffs in part because some top Nazis did escape, most notably Adolf Eichmann, the main architect of Hitler’s plan to exterminate the Jews, who was captured by Israeli agents in Argentina in 1960.

But most responsible historians reject the idea, as did Musmanno.

“I think it [‘Hunting Hitler’ and shows like it] would have made him angry,” said Mr. White. “It kind of bothered him for people to say Hitler was still alive.”

One tough judge

Musmanno was no one to trifle with.

Advertise with us

A diminutive dynamo — The Pittsburgh Press called him the “little jurist” — he was a tough self-made man from Stowe, having gone to work in Western Pennsylvania steel mills and mines at age 14.

A champion of the working man who once defended the doomed Italian anarchists Sacco and Vanzetti, he was full of passion and bombast, almost a force of nature.

He became a lawyer, the youngest member of the state House of Representatives, the youngest Allegheny County judge and later a state Supreme Court justice, the author of 16 books and an anti-Communist during the Cold War who once personally led a raid on the Grant Street headquarters of the Communist Party. Naturally, he turned that episode into a book.

Many saw him as larger than life despite his short stature and he regarded himself that way; in his will, he asked that he be buried near John F. Kennedy, “our beloved president,” in Arlington National Cemetery. And in 1968, he was.

“’Judge Mike’ enjoyed the center of the stage,” his Press obituary said, “and had the flamboyance to keep himself there.”

Advertise with us

In World War II, Musmanno joined the Navy’s Judge Advocate Corps and served as a naval aide to Gen. Mark Clark during the invasion of Italy. He was twice wounded in action, once by bomb fragments during the battle of Cassino, and later served as military governor of the Sorrentine Peninsula. At Nuremberg he presided over what he called the largest murder case in history — the trial of 23 members of the Einsatzgruppen, mobile SS killing units accused of slaughtering more than a million people in occupied eastern Europe. He ended up sentencing 14 of them to hang despite his opposition to the death penalty.

In his spare time, he led the investigation into determining what happened to Hitler. In a first-person Press account in 1968, he said he’d been in Italy when the war ended and noticed that the German generals “seemed almost gay” because they thought Hitler was still alive and would reassemble his forces to win the war. He said he informed his Navy superiors and they suggested he investigate the events in that Berlin bunker.

He set out on a three-year mission, he said, traveling across Germany and interviewing 200 witnesses.

He brought it all home with him after the war in big trunks. The judge was the type to keep everything, and for decades he maintained his collection of personal items in his Downtown court chambers.

“When you walked in, it was like a museum,” said his great-niece, Pat Homer, a retired school superintendent in Mercer County.

Advertise with us

He had no children or wife, and after his death his relatives donated the collection to Duquesne in 1980.

The archive contains all of his correspondence — at one point he had three secretaries to take dictation - as well as his combat helmet, campaign posters, plaques, his old desk and chair, his cases, original Nuremberg trial transcripts, his books and even a screenplay about Hitler’s last days that he tried to sell to Alfred Hitchcock.

The reel-to-reel 8mm films sat among the items, untouched for decades, until Duquesne had them transferred to DVDs in 2007 for a German production by Der Spiegel TV, which finally aired in 2013.

The story is told

The Smithsonian’s documentary includes more extensive excerpts from the films than the German version.

Advertise with us

In all of them, Musmanno sits stiffly in his Navy whites while his subjects answer his questions. The interviews are somewhat stilted because he had asked them to re-record earlier conversations. Some spoke English, but others needed a translator.

Among the witnesses was Hitler’s secretary, Traudl Junge, who was once in charge of receiving all the love letters women wrote to Hitler and in the bunker took down his will as he dictated. She said Hitler was determined to avoid the fate of fellow dictator Benito Mussolini, shot on April 28, his body strung up and abused by an Italian mob the following day.

“This unnerved him more than anything else,” Junge tells Musmanno. “He had a great fear that if captured dead or alive his body would be exposed to ridicule and degradation.”

Ilse Brown, sister of Hitler’s long-time girlfriend Eva Braun, describes to the judge Hitler’s appearance as the end neared: “His face was gray as ashes. His hands were in a constant state of agitation. He was bent over like an old man. It seemed to me he didn’t have the energy to live much longer.”

Heinz Lorenz, Hitler’s press attache, says that Hitler had ordered his armies to stop the Russian advance. Told they could not, Lorenz says, “He collapsed and said ‘It’s all over’ and ‘I’ll shoot myself.’ ”

Advertise with us

Major Baron Freytag von Loringhoven, Hitler’s Army adjutant and an anti-Nazi, felt Hitler had lost his sanity.

“The bunker became a mortuary and the people in it, living corpses,” he tells Musmanno. “No one dared to mention defeat to Hitler. To do so, one could lose one’s life.”

In fact, one did. After learning on April 28 that Heinrich Himmler, head of the SS, was trying to negotiate peace behind his back, Hitler had Himmler’s SS representative in the bunker shot. The man was Eva Braun’s brother-in-law, but he ignored her pleas for his life. An hour after the execution, he married Braun in a macabre ceremony.

As the Red Army moved closer, Hitler’s world had shrunk to 16 gloomy rooms with walls 12 feet thick buried 30 feet beneath the Reich Chancellery. About 20 people were in the bunker, all preparing for death or a desperate escape.

The witnesses paint a picture for Musmanno ripe with details: Hitler doing “a little dance” when he learns of Roosevelt’s death on April 12; his irrational hope that the German 12th Army, then fighting on the Elbe River, would come to his rescue; Magda Goebbels begging him to fight on and then poisoning her six children because she didn’t want them to grow up in a world without national socialism; Hitler sitting with his pistol and staring at a portrait of Frederick the Great as he contemplates his suicide; testing his cyanide capsules on his beloved German shepherd, Blondi; sharing his last meal, spaghetti and cabbage with raisin salad, with Junge and Eva Braun.

Advertise with us

When the hour came for Hitler to kill himself, he shook everyone’s hand. Traudl Junge was the last to hold his hand.

“He looked at me but I don’t think he saw me,” she tells Musmannno. “I don’t think he saw anybody.”

He and Eva Braun, wearing Hitler’s favorite dress, her nails freshly painted, retired to their room. Everyone heard a gunshot. Artur Axmann, head of the Hitler Youth, and Joseph Goebbels, Hitler’s propaganda minister, ran to the room.

“We found Eva Braun sitting on the sofa, her head resting on Hitler’s left shoulder,” he says. “She wore a black chiffon dress. She was dead but she had no marks of violence on her body. She died of poison.”

Hitler had shot himself in the mouth.

Advertise with us

“The blast of the pistol had ruptured the veins on either side of his head,” Axmann says. “The sofa was stained with blood and the pistol lay at his feet.”

As Russian artillery boomed, the bodies were carried outside to the chancellery garden, placed in a shell hole, drenched in gasoline and set afire with a flaming rag.

Guard Hernan Karnau, who gave Musmanno a special commemorative plate inlaid with the German eagle, recounted how he watched the bodies burn over several hours as he stood watch.

“I touched the burning remains with my feet, and they fell apart,” he says. “I lifted my arm in salute.”

At the end of all his interviews, Musmanno looks into the camera and delivers his assessment with the kind of over-the-top pronouncement that marked all of his writings and speeches:

Advertise with us

“There can be no doubt that Adolf Hitler — the Fuhrer of Germany, the master criminal of the world, the greatest gangster who ever disgraced the human race — is dead!”

Even so, Hitler was not officially declared dead until 1956.

Many of those Musmanno spoke to went on to give other interviews, write books or be consultants on various films through the years. But his interviews were the first accounting of Hitler’s final hours, recorded while Germany still lay in ruin and memories were fresh.

“I’m looking forward to seeing [the documentary],” said Ms. Homer, who controls the rights to the films. “I am amazed and impressed that there is still a lot of interest.”

‘Colorful and loquacious’

Advertise with us

Born in 1897, Musmanno grew up poor in a big Italian family and filled his life with enough adventure for two or three people.

As a boy in 1911, he said he witnessed the Iron and Coal Police, private thugs hired by company owners, shoot a miner in McKees Rocks, an experience that fueled a lifelong desire to protect the ethnic working men in Pennsylvania’s heavy industries. In later years he would be instrumental in abolishing the police force.

As a teenager, he worked in the coal mines and steel mills while he went to school at night.

He entered Georgetown University in 1915, but his studies were interrupted by World War I, in which he served as an infantryman. After the war he resumed his education and ultimately earned six degrees, joining the Pennsylvania Bar in 1923.

He initially worked for a Philadelphia lawyer and won 42 straight cases before his first loss. But he later lost more cases and resigned, heading to Europe to re-examine his life and studying criminology and law at the University of Rome, where he earned his seventh degree.

Advertise with us

He returned home in 1925 and set up a law practice at a time when the nation was gripped by the Sacco-Vanzetti case.

Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti were Italian anarchists convicted of the 1920 murder of a guard and a paymaster of a Massachusetts shoe company. Many observers felt they were the victims of anti-immigrant sentiment and were being railroaded.

Musmanno thought so, too, so he quit his law practice and traveled to Boston in 1927 to defend them. He had no income, and his family back home sent him boxes of macaroni to live on. He joined the defense team after the two men had been sentenced to death, but despite his efforts the pair was executed in 1927.

Many years later, in 1939, Musmanno wrote a book about the case, arguing that the men were falsely convicted.

In 1926, Musmanno had run for a seat in the state house and lost, but he tried again and won in 1928. He made an impression immediately. On his first day, he rose to address the assembly and the house speaker, thinking he was a spectator in the gallery, asked, “Are you, sir, a member of this house?” His answer was typically pugnacious: “Mr. Speaker, I am,” he said. “Furthermore, this is the first time and, I believe, the last time you will ever be in doubt of that.”

During his second term, he worked to abolish the Coal and Iron Police, which in 1929 had killed a striking coal miner in Imperial. The case outraged Musmanno, who called the company police “vicious human tigers,” and he wrote a short story about it called “Jan Volkanik” that later became the 1935 movie “Black Fury.”

In 1932 Musmanno became a judge, the youngest in Allegheny County, and went on to enjoy a distinguished career as a jurist and, starting in 1951, a Supreme Court justice.

News accounts of the time often referred to him as “fiery,” “controversial” and “loquacious,” and his many quirks were legendary.

“He once held court on the roof because it was too hot. He wrote an opinion in the form of a limerick. He was a colorful character,” said Mr. White.

He issued an order confirming the existence of Santa Claus; he sentenced himself to prison so he could experience both sides of the law; he once debated Clarence Darrow on immortality.

He wrote more dissenting opinions in his first five years on the high court than all other judges had in the previous 50 years. His opinions were full of the grandiloquent language that marked most of his writing.

Dissenting from a 1966 ruling that Henry Miller’s “Tropic of Cancer” was not obscene, he wrote that the book is a “a cesspool, an open sewer, a pit of putrefaction, a slimy gathering of all that is rotten in the debris of human depravity. And in the center of all this waste and stench, besmearing himself with its foulest defilement, splashes, leaps, cavorts and wallows a bifurcated specimen that responds to the name of Henry Miller.”

In his life away from the court, he was deeply religious, quick to take offense and especially proud of his Italian heritage. He wrote one of his books, “Columbus WAS First,” in response to research indicating that the Vikings had landed in North America long before Christopher Columbus. (He died on Columbus Day.)

In 1961, he was asked to be a prosecution witness in the trial of Adolf Eichmann. He traveled to Israel and testified. It was Musmanno’s direct knowledge of the Einsatzgruppen, which ultimately reported to Eichmann, that made him an important witness.

Eichmann was hanged in 1962.

Other Nazis have also been dragged out of hiding through the years and prosecuted, but Musmanno never wavered in his belief that their leader had died in 1945.

“There was never a question about that,” said Pat Homer. “He was there, he interviewed the people and he found them all to be credible. He was very passionate and very dedicated to his work.”

The mission was especially important to him because he had undertaken it largely on his own. He even bought his own film in New York to take to Germany for the interviews, and he felt strongly that the recordings would make a good documentary.

Trying to duplicate the success he had with “Black Fury,” he planned to sell the film to Hollywood. The Duquesne archives contain letters he wrote in 1948 to Alfred Hitchcock and Warner Brothers in which he says he shot 6,000 feet of film, enough for several hours, and intended to title his project “What Happened to Hitler?”

He said his idea was to recreate the bunker scenes “which I believe to have no counterpart in history for sheer drama.” The documentary, he promised, “would be entertainment which could rival any murder story on the screen.”

His papers include a screenplay, complete with descriptions of scenes and narration.

But the project went nowhere. The Smithsonian program suggests it was because people were tired of war and just wanted to move on. It’s also likely, however, that the judge’s anti-Communist bent didn’t go over well in liberal Hollywood.

Either way, the film ended up in a studio vault, but the studio changed hands several times over the decades. The film was probably thrown out and disappeared from history.

A condensed hour-long version, however, remained with Musmanno, although Mr. White said the interviews were mixed in with other films and starting to fall apart after so many years.

When Der Spiegel approached the family for the rights and contacted Duquesne in 2007, the school had the interviews digitized.

After the German rights expired, a Scottish company, Finestripe Productions, bought the rights and began working with the Musmanno family and Duquesne to make its documentary, allowing the films to be seen for the first time outside Germany.

Seventy years after the war, obsession with Hitler lives on. There are hundreds of books about him, including several new ones this year.

But the scene of his last stand is long gone, covered over by nondescript apartment buildings, with only a small plaque erected in 2006 indicating that Hitler’s compound was once 30 feet below the street.

“Today the site of the Fuhrerbunker in Berlin, where Hitler died and his body was burned,” the Smithsonian documentary intones, “is a car park.”

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com