'The Mentalist: Season One'
2 1/2 stars = Average
As a big fan of pop psychology, cognitive science and serial killer investigations, I'm a sucker for procedural police dramas that focus on lie detection, behavior reading and, well, serial killer investigations. While my only complaint about "The Mentalist: Season One" ($59.98, Warner Home Video) is the lack of attention given to the heretofore invisible serial-murderer antagonist, Red John, the series comprises all the key components of the perfect crime investigation series.
The special features are limited to a handful of deleted scenes, 24 minutes of interviews with the cast and creators, seven minutes of gag reels, and "Cracking the Crystal Ball," an 18-minute featurette of back-and-forth interviews with experts and skeptics of psychic phenomena. Although these were enjoyable and informative, the overall package left much to be desired, most notably, the absolute absence of episode commentaries on the entire six-disc set. This being the second recent DVD that has evoked this gripe, I fear this dearth of features portends some trend in future full-season DVD offerings.
-- James Hilston, Post-Gazette staff writer
'30 Rock: Season Three'
3 1/2 stars = Very good
Fresh on the heels of its third best comedy Emmy, "30 Rock" releases its complete third season ($49.98, Universal), and it's a doozy. Liz Lemon (Tina Fey) has an affair with the preternaturally handsome Drew (Jon Hamm). Jack (Baldwin) falls in love with his mother's nurse (Salma Hayak) and also discovers his real father (Alan Alda). A hilarious, dead-on celebrity benefit concert with Sheryl Crow, Elvis Costello, Mary J. Blige and more is the high point of the whole series. Megan Mullally, Jennifer Aniston, Oprah Winfrey, Steve Martin and Elaine Stritch also make guest appearances.
Of the bonus features, two deserve special mention. The making-of-the concert shows the singers taking their job completely seriously despite the song's absurd premise. And the table read for the season finale is great fun, especially when compared to the final cut. As for the other extras, the Muppet visit is cute, but don't even bother with Tracy Morgan's fake rant. It's the dumbest, most unfunny thing I've seen in years.
-- Sally Kalson, Post-Gazette staff writer
'Castle: First Season'
3 stars = Good
If you are old enough, ABC's "Castle" will seem pleasantly familiar. You have the police detective -- an attractive, no fuss intelligent woman, who's good at her job as a homicide cop in New York City. Add a mystery writer -- an attractive, intelligent man, who is a complication in the detective's life. The chemistry is there making it fun to watch ... and seem like "Moonlighting" meets "The Rockford Files."
So it has been done before. Don't let that put you off. This is a stylish and enjoyable series of mysteries that are well written, produced and acted.
Each episode starts with the murder scene that is shot beautifully and pulls you into the story. And, in most cases, they do keep you guessing and watching through the DVD's 10 episodes ($36.99, Walt Disney Studios). The extras are not the most exciting. One segment has Nathan Fillion (Rick Castle) doing background work with a real mystery writer, one of Hollywood's longtime great mystery men, Stephen J. Cannell. The rest are bloopers, audio commentary and how the show came about.
-- Liz Gray, Post-Gazette staff writer
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.