They say the neon lights are bright on Broadway. For the record, they’re pretty darn bright off-Broadway as well.

Just ask Mike Cefalo, the McCandless native currently starring as Hans Scholl in “White Rose.” This new musical inspired by the true story of a student-led resistance group in Nazi Germany is midway through a 12-week run at Theatre Row in New York City. Tickets are available via whiterosethemusical.com.

Next year, Downtown resident Nick Navari will also find out exactly how bright off-Broadway’s lights can be when he brings “Local Singles,” the musical he wrote here and first staged at the North Side’s New Hazlett Theater in 2021, to the Big Apple’s Players Theatre. Tickets for this show’s five-week engagement beginning in January 2025 are on sale at nicknavari.com.

The Post-Gazette recently caught up with both Cefalo and Navari to talk about their respective musical theater journeys and what life is like for theater professionals working adjacent to the Great White Way.

Advertise with us
Cole Thompson, left, Paolo Montalban, Jo Ellen Pellman, Kennedy Kanagawa and McCandless native Mike Cefalo in the off-Broadway musical “White Rose.” (Russ Rowland)

‘Unfortunately timely’

Cefalo is a North Allegheny High School graduate who majored in musical theater at Baldwin Wallace University in Berea, Ohio. He moved to New York City in 2017 and slowly began amassing an on-stage resume that now includes his “White Rose” stint, the COVID-interrupted 2020 national tour of “The Band’s Visit” and the short-lived 2023 Broadway musical “New York, New York.”

“White Rose” has been in the works for almost two years, and Cefalo has been involved the whole time. He was brought on by director Will Nunziata, who Cefalo got to know while acting in his 2022 short film, “The Old Guitarist.” On Jan. 25, Cefalo officially made his New York leading-man debut in “White Rose” as young freedom fighter Hans Scholl.

“This feels like my thing where I’m cementing this,” he said. “It feels very, very nice.”

The real-life Hans made “a 180 pivot” from a Hitler Youth to staunch critic of the former German chancellor’s regime. Cefalo admitted to not being particularly familiar with “White Rose” and figures like Hans and his sister, Sophie Scholl (Jo Ellen Pellman), before joining this project.

He likened the show’s songs to the pop-punk stylings of the 2006 Broadway hit musical “Spring Awakening” and expressed appreciation for how the “White Rose” soundtrack helps communicates Hans’ and other characters’ angst and internal conflicts.

Advertise with us

“It’s a show about young people kind of making their mark on the world, wanting a change and bringing their youthful energy to a lot of older people failing to make a change of any sort,” Cefalo said.

“They take it into their own hands to spread a message against these atrocities happening in the world.”

In addition to being a “an unfortunately timely show,” Cefalo touted “White Rose” for boasting a creative team that’s brimming with Broadway talent. He has cherished forging “a really special bond” with Pellman, who also starred in director Ryan Murphy’s 2020 cinematic adaptation of Broadway’s “The Prom.”

Cefalo recently helped record the “White Rose” cast album and is hoping the show gets extended beyond next month — and that his fellow Pittsburghers have the chance to check out this bold musical during its inaugural off-Broadway bow.

“Support some Pittsburgh local talent!” he implored. “If you want to see a lot of Broadway vets and fresh young talent do an important new piece, this is the time to see it.”

Advertise with us
Seth Laidlaw, left, as Richard, Sarah Chelli as Penny and Emmanuel Elliot Key as Jack in the March 2021 filmed musical “Local Singles” that was staged at the New Hazlett Theater on the North Side. (Renee Rosensteel)

‘It’s not for me anymore’

Navari, a Pine native and Kenyon College graduate, was working as an investment research analyst at a money management firm in Downtown Pittsburgh when he decided it was time to indulge his long-dormant creative side.

The former collegiate music director downloaded scriptwriting software at his desk in June 2019 and spent the next six months banging out the book, music and lyrics for what eventually became “Local Singles.”

“I could do his for the rest of my life,” Navari remembered thinking. “I have these songs, and I love these characters and this music.”

As a kid, he was annoyed that almost every movie, television show or musical he watched seemed to be set in New York.

“People are falling in love all over the world,” and Navari set out to prove that by crafting a musical set at a Pittsburgh YMCA and, more specifically, the “last remaining support group for single people.” Comedy and tragedy abound as five folks with varying backgrounds and relationship trauma get to know each other and connect in unexpected ways.

Advertise with us

The first version of “Local Singles” ended up being on film rather than in front of a live audience due to the COVID-19 pandemic. It was staged in-person for the first time at Greensburg’s Stage Right! in February 2022, according to Navari.

“Local Singles” also enjoyed brief runs in Denver last August and Charlotte, North Carolina, in January 2024 before The Players Theatre in New York’s Greenwich Village contracted it for a five-week run beginning in January 2025.

“To me, it’s exciting to see work hitting a national stage coming out of Pittsburgh,” Navari said. “That is less common than I would like it to be. I’m proud to be one of those people doing it.”

Finding success with “Local Singles” allowed him to quit his finance job. He’s currently the producing artistic director at The Strand Theater in Zelienople, though Navari has already begun the process of moving to New York as auditions for “Local Singles” ramp up and as he begins kicking around ideas for his next musical.

He is confident that anyone attending “Local Singles” will likely leave “with a song stuck in their head” and “knowing that there’s still good happening in the world.” He still can’t believe that the musical he began writing as an escape from office doldrums is less than a year away from its off-Broadway premiere.

Advertise with us

“It’s not for me anymore,” Navari said. “I was writing it for myself, but now it’s for everyone else.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and X @jaxelburgh.