The Kelly Critics is a joint program of the Post-Gazette and Pittsburgh CLO's Gene Kelly Awards for Excellence in High School Musicals, in which students at Kelly schools review musicals at other Kelly schools. Reviews are edited by Post-Gazette senior theater critic Christopher Rawson.
When I walked into Moon Area High School with my Grandma at my side and a Coke under my arm, I began to wonder what I had gotten myself into. I had tried to watch the musical “Something Rotten!” once before but only got through the first act before my mother and I decided that our pajamas and an episode of bad television was a better way to spend our Saturday night. So I’ll be honest; I was expecting the next three hours to be a little painful.
But whatever I was expecting I was certainly not prepared for the absolute masterpiece that unfolded in front of me. The second I strolled into the theater and saw a banner with the name of the show splayed across it in bright red, with the orchestra tucked in front of the stage, I knew this is going to be good.
“Something Rotten!” is inherently a clever show. It follows the Bottom Brothers, Nick (Jack Cipriani) and Nigel (Ezekiel Brown), as they try to make a name for themselves in theater. But this proves rather difficult as they constantly find themselves stuck in the shadow of “The Bard,” William Shakespeare (Sasha Konitzer).
In a final attempt to find success, Nick makes a deal with a soothsayer who looks into the future and tells Nick the next big craze in theater will be combining singing and acting. In other words, they’re doing a musical, folks!
What made Moon’s production stand out to me was how clearly devoted every single person on stage was to portraying their character. Furthermore, the cast worked exceedingly well not only with each other but with the orchestra and the technical elements.
Read More
The cast's chemistry was apparent from the start in two high-energy group numbers, “Welcome to the Renaissance” and “God, I Hate Shakespeare.” Each cast member demonstrated an individual character that very clearly had thoughts and feelings about everything going on in the main plot.
But the number that I felt truly demonstrated the interconnection between actors, tech and the orchestra was “A Musical,” where Broadway style lighting came out from the sides of the stage to highlight a huge tap break set to insanely upbeat music led by intense drum sequences.
Oh and I couldn’t go on without mentioning both Nostradamus (Tyler Coy), who had the lady next to me in tears with his commitment to the jokes, and the frequent tap numbers. The entire cast seemed to have the ungodly ability to pull out tap skills that should take years to perfect. These skills continued to be highlighted in numbers like “Make an Omelette,” which contained extensive dance breaks.
Also, the company vocals were quite impressive throughout and unusually strong for high school actors.
Everything seemed to have been extremely well thought out, planned and rehearsed, from the gorgeous costuming to the fact that when a prop was thrown off stage there was always a tech person there to catch it. And though I certainly didn’t expect to spend my Friday night seeing grim reapers with large scythes singing about the Black Death, this show was an insanely good example of what happens when you get everything right.
“Something Rotten!” ran March 16-19 at Moon Area High School.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.