The Kelly Critics is a joint program of the Post-Gazette and Pittsburgh CLO's Gene Kelly Awards for Excellence in High School Musicals, in which students at Kelly schools review musicals at other Kelly schools. Reviews are edited by Post-Gazette senior theater critic Christopher Rawson

People were packed shoulder to shoulder and the lobby was buzzing with excitement. Exceptionally kind (and patient) ushers passed out programs to the long line of patrons. There were parents, siblings of all ages, classmates and friends eagerly waiting to find their seats.

It was evident that Baldwin High School’s rendition of “Matilda: The Musical” was highly anticipated in the community, and rightfully so.

Played by Lexie Ogrosky, Matilda is a gifted young girl with self-absorbed and absent parents, Mr. and Mrs. Wormwood. She goes to school, where she meets a gentle and kind teacher, Miss Honey, the driving force of positivity and support in her life, in contrast to the evil, mountain-of-a-woman head mistress, Miss Trunchbull. Matilda’s story is one of self-discovery, newfound confidence and finding a sense of belonging in a world that seems largely unwelcoming.

Advertise with us

The opening Birthday Party scene was lively, and as the cast sang “Miracle,” we realized how little Matilda’s parents cared for her. She was no miracle to them, only a disappointment.

A juxtaposing scene showed Matilda’s deeply felt struggles as a neglected child. The stage was kept fairly simple, but without a detail missing. The doodles around Matilda’s bed reflected her creative mind and a personalized, comfortable space in a house that fostered hostility.

The focus of the set was alphabet blocks that served multiple functions — setting the scene and acting as props for the cast to perform on. Later in the show, the blocks reappeared during the Alphabet Song and were impressively used. The cast strategically turned each block to reveal a letter of the alphabet as it was being sung — an act that could have easily gone awry, but it was performed seamlessly.

The Dance Break scene was my personal favorite. The bejeweled costumes caught the attention of the entire audience and energy filled the room. Mrs. Wormwood, played by Lila Kelley, shined — literally in her sparkling dress, and through her polished dancing and singing.

It was a light-hearted and exciting moment that contrasted with the bleak, unsettling nature of the story. Matilda’s life is one of measuring up, met with constant belittlement by those who are meant to care for her. The dance scene showed the talents of the performers and was a pleasant distraction from Matilda’s struggles.

Advertise with us

The performers excellently captured the essence of each character. When Matilda switched her parents' hair care products and happened to turn her father’s hair green, Mr. Wormwood revealed his slimy character and Matilda displayed her mischievous side — sometimes she has to be a little bit naughty. Although the bathroom set was small, the mirror that looked into the audience was an effective prop. Mr. Wormwood’s facial expressions were fully visible, which contributed to the comedic scene.

Miss Trunchbull, played by Kelly Campion, was outstanding as the embodiment of the evil woman from her facial expressions to her walk. The iconic scene when Miss Trunchbull forces a student to eat an entire chocolate cake as punishment was perfectly grotesque. The only thing that could have been better was a real cake!

Through the entirety of the show, the audience was captivated. Seeing a familiar and nostalgic story, it was easy to follow the well-known plot while also enjoying unique twists from the cast. Watching a childhood favorite live was a wholesome experience and reminded me to embrace being naughty and wrangle the magic inside me, just like Matilda.

“Matilda” ran March 22-25.