Evan Mulgrave of Pittsburgh band TV’s Norm has noticed what happens when you slip a Replacements song into the set.
“Usually people will like the song,” he says, “but you'll get the ‘HELL yeah, dude’ from other musicians — especially if they’re punk-DIY adjacent. I think they've gotten their flowers there. But, I think, to the general public, if you mention the Replacements, they'd be like, ‘Who?’”
Despite being a link between punk and the indie-rock/grunge boom of the ’90s, The Replacements remain criminally underrated — due in no small part to their own lovable habit of self-sabotage.
That didn't stop Mulgrave and his mates from throwing together a Replacements cover band for a tribute show at Brillobox in 2016.
Mulgrave, then singer-guitarist from Turnpike Gardens, was joined by his band’s drummer, James Conley, along with There You Are singer-guitarist Tom Chorba and Ugly Blondes bassist Nate Cross.
From there, they just kept going as TV’s Norm — named, yes, for the barfly from “Cheers.”
“We started writing our own music,” he says, “and I would say that, definitely, there's some Replacements DNA in what we do — kind of punky, poppy, energetic music — though Paul Westerberg is a much better songwriter than I am.”
TV’s Norm will go full Mats once again to perform the 1985 classic “Tim,” as part of the Needle Drop series at Bottlerocket Social Hall, in Pittsburgh’s Allentown neighborhood. The band previously did Oasis’ “(What’s the Story) Morning Glory?” for that series.
“When we covered The Replacements [in 2016],” he says, “we probably pulled the most songs from ‘Tim.’ I think it's probably the consensus favorite Replacements album out of everybody in the band. It's just more straightforward, great pop songs on that record. You’ve got ‘Bastards of Young,’ you’ve got ‘Left of the Dial,’ ‘Little Mascara.’”
And in one of streaming’s stranger plot twists, “Swingin Party” is far and away The Replacements’ most-played song, boosted by Lorde’s moody cover issued as the B-side to “Tennis Court.”
Mulgrave expects the biggest reaction will be to “Bastards of Young,” one of the band’s most anthemic songs, with a set of absolutely devastating lyrics about love and family dynamics.
“It's really hard to beat ‘Bastards of Young,’” Mulgrave says. “It’s an incredible song. It's interesting because they have that reputation for being sloppy, for being like, ‘You know, we don't give a [expletive].’ But then you read and hear lyrics like that and there is more going on here than just, you know, four dudes from Minneapolis getting drunk and playing rock songs.”
Mulgrave says one challenge of covering the band is making sense of choices that weren’t meant to make sense.
“Some of their key changes … they don't necessarily make musical sense. You're like, ‘Why would you pick that chord?’ It was similar with the Oasis album.
“There's a bell curve when you're covering an album of, like, the early enthusiasm of, ‘I can't wait to play some of these great songs.’ And then halfway through rehearsals, you're like, ‘I can't believe we've messed this song up for the 10th time.’ ”
They’re in good company, because The Replacements themselves got tripped up quite often covering The Replacements. The most public example came on “Saturday Night Live” in January 1986, when a brilliantly ragged performance got them banned for drunkenness and Westerberg blurting the f-word at guitarist Bob Stinson.
“They released ‘Live at Maxwell's’ and the end of ‘Left of the Dial,’ where the drums drop out, they just [mess] it up so bad that they're like, ‘Yeah, the song's over.’ They don't play the last minute of the song. And this is on their live album. It’s awesome.”
It takes some of the pressure off TV’s Norm, who can turn the mistakes into things of beauty.
The show is at Bottlerocket Social Hall, Allentown, at 8 p.m. Thursday. Tickets are $12; bottlerocketpgh.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.