The latest addition to the brave new world is Eddie Dalton, a contemporary soul singer in the classic vein of Otis Redding.

Dalton, depicted as a gray-haired Black man with a deeply lined face, singing into a vintage microphone, is an AI creation.

This week, he had three songs climb to the iTunes Top 10 across multiple countries, the most popular being “Another Day Old,” a ballad that checks a lot of boxes for a classic blues-soul playlist: gritty vocals, tasty guitar licks, smooth keys and reflective lyrics about time passing.

“It’s a great song, if it was The Commonheart,” Pittsburgh rocker Bill Toms said with a laugh. “I find it quite disturbing to be honest.”

Advertise with us

No one in town knows soul better than singer Billy Price, who also spent decades working at Carnegie Mellon University’s Software Engineering Institute.

“It’s funny, because this, to me, crosses a line. And I don’t think of myself as a Luddite opposed to change and technology,” he said. “The genie has been out of the bottle for a long time with streaming, and as a fan and a consumer I use it a lot even though I know what a bad effect it has on the income of musicians and songwriters.

“And I’m generally more accepting of the cheesy-sounding drum machines and fake horns that have been used for a long time to cut costs on production of the contemporary Southern soul blues artists I like.

“But passing this Eddie Dalton bot off as if he’s a real human, and seeing my friends fall for it, just enrages me. The people responsible are laughing at us. They know where our buttons are and how to push them.”

iTunes rankings are driven by short bursts of paid downloads, not long-term streaming or airplay — meaning it can take relatively few purchases to push a song into the Top 10 across multiple countries at once. That makes the charts susceptible to coordinated surges, allowing even an AI-generated artist like Dalton to register as a global breakout, at least briefly.

Advertise with us

For Price, the issue goes deeper than just the fake.

“There is also something disturbingly racist about the thing too. The bot is a caricature of a soul artist. Worse in its way than the white, blackfaced minstrels of the early 1900s.”

Dalton, with more than 500,000 Spotify streams for “Another Day Old,” joins AI phenoms like R&B singer Xania Monet (730,000 monthly listeners on Spotify and 13.3 million plays for her biggest hit, “How Was I Supposed to Know?”) and folk-rock band Velvet Sundown (4.3 million plays for the song “Dust on the Wind”). He is the creation of Dallas Little, according to Songstats.

Toms, who started playing with the Houserockers in the ’90s and now leads the blues-rock band Hard Rain, said he’s grateful he came up in a different era.

“The music industry is hard enough to navigate,” he said. “I’m just glad I’m not a young musician trying to make a difference.”

Advertise with us

On the younger side is Zack Wiesinger, the guitar wizard who fronts the Pittsburgh rock band Guitar Zack. He found “Another Day Old” to be “really impressive for AI,” starting with the “generic” but also relatable lyrics.

“Musically, it sounds like a basic chord progression of a Nashville-style singer-songwriter that hired uninspired session players to just play the parts,” he said. “It lacks that extra oomph and feeling that top session players are known for; breathing some life into a track.”

He found the bridge’s chords to be “lackluster” and first guitar solo to be “rather bland,” but the second solo to be “more convincing.”

“The voice sounded in pitch and actually quite human-ish, which was the most impressive element of this song, but some parts sounded rather ‘uncanny valley,’” he said.

“I will make a prediction. The first band to do a real human cover of one of these big AI hits, will definitely go viral and get some good press for a cycle if they can do it as good or better than the AI. But if they try, and cringe-fail, they will get negative press. It’s a gamble, but there will inevitably be a band that covers an AI hit for a strategic move.”

Advertise with us

Addi Twigg, a young Pittsburgh singer with plenty of soul, said she objects to AI “stealing sounds from work created by humans” as well as the environmental impact of the data centers.

As for the music, she said, “So you generated a song: Now what? What was the point? Money? Fame? Dopamine? Seems like a hollow, fleeting pursuit to me. Connecting with other people to create something together is a reward with long-lasting, rippling effects.”

She suggests that young creatives get out and mix it up with other humans at AcoustiCafé at Mr. Smalls or the open mic or open jam at Club Cafe.

“This city is full to the brim with incredible musical talent,” she said. “Your musical kin are out there, you just have to close the apps and go find them.”