When Johannes Brahms — one of the capital-G Great names in classical music and the possessor of a razor-sharp, dry wit — composed his piano concerto, the music went through a series of revisions informed by his friends and fellow musicians.
Different friends weighed in on questions about the form and structure and the orchestration, with some taking a hands-on approach and offering revisions of entire sections of the music and contributing to a work of art that has endured for more than 160 years.
By contrast, the first piece of music at the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra’s Friday performance in Heinz Hall could have benefited from some constructive criticism. The brand new 13-minute work by Illinois-based composer Jacob Bancks, “The Greatest Show on Earth,” is filled with zippy gestures and humor, with bright orchestrations and trills decorating the mock-schmaltzy melodies.
Mr. Bancks described his piece as “a musical tribute to Hollywood producers and daytime talk show hosts; trapeze artists, snake-handlers and strongmen; charismatic preachers and flamboyant televangelists; as well as clowns and politicians of all varieties.”
It’s typical for a composer to make minor adjustments during rehearsals, adjusting the orchestration a little for balances to bring the music on the stage closer to the music in his head.
But this work suffers from other excesses that could have been pruned. The frequent meter changes (meter refers to the pattern of beats within a musical bar) in the opening fast section contribute to a feeling of chaos, but this quickly grew more tedious.
The slower middle section, which had some lovely colors and bits of pathos, feels stretched and empty after a time, like butter scraped over too much bread.
There’s a clear program and structure to the piece, which I appreciated in this instance. However, a good editor or collaborator could have helped trim some of the work’s overgrowth and pastiche to bring out more of the work’s core. To be fair, Mr. Bancks, who I haven’t spoken with, may have such trusted collaborators — I’m just using his piece as an illustration.
Critics in the days of Brahms, too, were less shy about voicing negative opinions about new works. There was none of the “oh, I must not be sophisticated enough to appreciate this” that we hear sometimes today.
When Beethoven’s Second Symphony premiered, for example, one critic described the music as “a crass ogre, a stabbed, unbound writhing dragon that refuses to die, and although bleeding in the Finale, angrily beats about with tail erect.”
As a reader and as a writer, I must admit there are days that I long for this kind of rock ’em sock ’em critical discourse rather than the rarefied, intellectual missives that constitutes polite criticism today.
Regardless, under the baton of Manfred Honeck, the symphony was equal parts fire and refinement in this early Beethoven work, though I wished for a touch more rhythmic precision at times.
Pianist Emanuel (“Manny”) Ax joined the orchestra for Brahms’ Piano Concerto No. 1 in the second half in the evening’s clear high point. Mr. Ax, one of the world’s great pianists, delivered a sinewy, raw account of Brahms’ concerto, dialoguing passionately with the orchestra at times and taking a commanding lead at others.
I’ve remarked before on the orchestra’s tendency to play the “main” pieces on its concert programs — the Brahms in this case — at a higher level than the others. This was yet another instance where this was clearly evident; the orchestra needs to put the same energy behind each work on its program or trim the programs. If they aren’t convinced of the quality of the music they play, why should listeners be?
This concert repeats at 2:30 p.m. Sunday. Tickets start at $32 at pittsburghsymphony.org.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.