A few years before he became the breakout star of 1976, the Pittsburgh rock fans who were really tapped in had a heads-up on Peter Frampton.
The young British singer-guitarist, sprung from the band Humble Pie, made his Pittsburgh debut in November 1973 at an ice rink — not the Civic Arena, but the Alpine Arena in Swissvale — on a bill with Black Oak Arkansas and The Marshall Tucker Band.
It was one year after Humble Pie opened for Alice Cooper at Three Rivers Stadium.
He was touring behind “Frampton's Camel,” the follow-up to his 1972 solo debut “Wind of Change.” That debut, which barely cracked the Billboard album chart (No. 177), featured backing from the likes of Ringo Starr and Billy Preston and is most remembered for its bluesy, down-tempo take on “Jumpin’ Jack Flash.”
“Frampton’s Camel,” which did marginally better (reaching No. 110), leaned into more of a band sound with his touring unit of the same name.
His third shot at the ring, the 1974 album “Somethin's Happening,” did no better, but good things were coming — and the words of Humble Pie frontman Steve Marriott to The Pittsburgh Press in 1972 were prescient.
“Album music is very different from live stuff,” Marriott said. “In a studio with no audience in front of you, you can relax and let many different sides of yourself come through. On stage, though, you’ve got to emphasize the power in your sound. Really knock ’em dead with the ‘feel’ of your music.”
No one from that era banked on that wisdom better than Kiss, which changed the game in September 1975 with “Alive!” Frampton was right behind them, with golden locks, songs for the girls, songs for the guys and exceptionally fluid guitar playing.
While the three solo records didn’t pop out of the speakers, Frampton was building a set of songs that could turn into a juggernaut: the reflective “Lines on My Face,” the shimmering “Show Me the Way,” the swoony “Baby, I Love Your Way” and the rousing talk-box jam “Do You Feel Like We Do.”
The tapes were rolling on the ’75 tour, and the band was well-seasoned by the time it hit the Civic Arena just before Thanksgiving to open for Johnny Winter.
To Pittsburgh Press critic Pete Bishop, Frampton’s opening set was … a “sin”?
Frampton, Bishop wrote, “took 40 workmanlike, thoroughly undistinguished minutes to get moving with ‘Do You Feel Like We Do’ and an encore of ‘Jumpin’ Jack Flash,’ his three bandsmen remaining workmanlike and totally undistinguished the entire time. Frampton has an OK voice and certainly can play guitar; those first 40 minutes, however, saw him foolishly limiting himself to minuscule bridges on humdrum songs, not solos, worthwhile listening, but too few and far between. Wasting 40 minutes wasn’t Frampton‘s biggest sin, though, that honor goes to the time he stole from The Winter Group…”
Coming Alive!
Fifty-five days later, on Jan. 15, 1976, he released “Frampton Comes Alive!,” a 14-song, double-album set priced at the bargain rate of $7.98 — one dollar more than the standard price of a single album that year. It came with a foldout poster of the cover, Frampton looking like a glazy-eyed rock ’n’ roll angel, like the male version of the famous Farrah Fawcett red swimsuit poster.
After four underwhelming albums, Humble Pie had won people over with its ’71 live album, “Performance: Rockin' the Fillmore,” and now it was their guitarist’s turn. The songs that fell flat in the studio were juiced, and so was the noisy audience.
Like Frampton’s career in general, “Frampton Comes Alive!” tiptoed into the marketplace, pulling a few positive reviews and debuting at No. 191 on the Billboard chart. The momentum began to build that winter for what The Washington Post, in March, declared to be “a splendid album representation of a concert performance, the best since ‘The Allman Brothers Band Live at Fillmore East.’”
On March 14, “Frampton Comes Alive!” went to No. 1 on the Billboard chart.
“That LP was like a lightning bolt!” says former WDVE DJ and program director Jimmy Roach. “Totally unexpected. Based on his previous releases, there was no inkling that something was ready to explode. Looking back, it was just the perfect combination of great songs, a friendly, Springsteen-esque crowd, and an engineer whose mix actually did make the evening come alive. We played every cut on the record for well over a year.”
“Frampton Comes Alive!” spent 10 nonconsecutive weeks at the top and remained on the charts for 97 weeks, becoming the best-selling album of 1976 on the way to eight-times platinum. The singles "Show Me the Way," "Baby, I Love Your Way" and "Do You Feel Like We Do" — with a 7-minute edit of the 14-minute song — all went Top 15 on the singles chart.
“WYDD was first to jump on ‘Comes Alive!,’ having played Humble Pie and Frampton solo records,” says former WYDD DJ Larry Gerson. “The phone never quit ringing for ‘Do You Feel Like We Do.’ I played it so many times back then that I honestly haven’t played it in 50 years. All that radio play, the song really didn’t stand the test of time and hold up well for me as so many of the truly great songs have, but it was an excellent 14-minute DJ break back then.”
On Aug. 14, 1976, Pittsburgh got its first look at Peter Frampton the superstar when he co-headlined Three Rivers Stadium with The Beach Boys and opening act Gary Wright. At the time, TRS concerts were in jeopardy due to the chaos of ZZ Top/Aerosmith that June, but the Eagles show in July calmed local authorities and the Beach Boys/Frampton lineup was smooth sailing and the biggest concert of the year, with a crowd of nearly 49,000.
Gerson’s memory of the show: “Pretty sure he was top of his game that year. Hectic, crowded, lots of distractions.”
Somewhat like every ’70s stadium concert.
Back to earth
And then came the less fun part. After a slow, then sudden rise, Frampton took a quick fall.
“Comes Alive!” was one of the best-selling albums of 1977 as well (14th), but the much-anticipated follow-up, “I'm in You,” dropped with a thud. The live energy was lacking on the self-produced album, which did have some success — a No. 2 with the title track and No. 18 with Stevie Wonder’s “Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I’m Yours)” — but was not the blockbuster or artistic endeavor fans wanted.
The disappointment was compounded by his participation in the disastrous “Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band” musical in 1978. Frampton had one more Top 40 hit after that, 1979’s "I Can't Stand It No More" and was all but cast aside during the MTV era.
“In the digital age, we’re used to people being canceled overnight,” says Roach’s WDVE partner Steve Hansen. “But back in the analog era, it took a bit longer for an overnight sensation to be destroyed. In Frampton’s case it was a little over two years. ‘Frampton Comes Alive!’ overwhelmed radio for a year and a half, and the build to ‘I’m in You’ was almost unbearable, the massive disappointment in it palpable.
“Sgt. Pepper,” he says, “landed like a direct hit to his career, taking The Bee Gees down with him.”
Nonetheless, the impact of “Comes Alive!” lived on in the wave of live albums that followed in ’76-’77: Bob Seger & the Silver Bullet Band’s “Live Bullet,” “Wings Over America,” Ted Nugent’s “Double Live Gonzo!,” REO Speedwagon’s “Live: You Get What You Play For” and Styx’s “Caught in the Act – Live” among them.
“Fortunately for Pittsburgh,” Hansen says, “the legacy of the music released in 1976 — Boston, Kansas and Tom Petty’s first, ‘Hotel California,’ Boz Scaggs’ ‘Silk Degrees,’ ‘Night Moves’ — forms a substantial part of The Electric Lunch playlist each day.”
As for Frampton, he went through a few marriages and a bout with alcohol, but he came through that whirlwind to become an artist from the ’70s performing into his 70s. His most recent trip to Pittsburgh, a fine show at the Benedum in July 2019, was on a farewell tour due to the diagnosis of a “muscle-wasting” disease.
He came out of retirement for Buddy Holly's 85th birthday celebration in 2023 and now, at 75 and with the muscles in his hand working better than he expected, he’s been able to resume touring.
In 2024, what was considered to be a long wrong became right when his friend Roger Daltrey of The Who inducted him into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
The 50th anniversary of “Frampton Comes Alive!” is celebrated with a Vinylphyle edition on Jan. 22. It is sourced from the original 1975 Doug Sax quarter-inch production master, with lacquers cut by Joe Nino-Hernes, and pressed on 180g black vinyl at RTI. The package features a four-panel insert including a new interview with Frampton and Anthony Fantano of The Needle Drop.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.