After nearly three decades working for the Pittsburgh Penguins, sports marketing pro James Santilli has moved from PPG Paints Arena over to Heinz Hall to work for the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra.

It’s quite a career change-up, but there are some surprising similarities between the organizations, he said.

A lifelong resident of Western Pennsylvania, Santilli earned his bachelor’s and master’s degrees from Duquesne University and started out in the Pens’ box office, during what he called the “heyday” of the team’s fame in the early ’90s.

He quickly rose through the ranks, building new programs and educational initiatives including the Little Penguins Learn to Play Program, which provided free gear and hockey lessons to more than 14,000 children in the area and kick-started a lifetime passion for hockey and attendance in many such families.

Advertise with us

A round of layoffs at the Pens in 2024 — possibly to tighten the ship for the recently announced sale of the team by Fenway Sports Group to Hoffmann Family of Companies — precipitated a change to consulting.

The Pittsburgh Symphony, an orchestra famous around the world for its bold playing and meticulous skill, brought Santilli on as a consultant, leading to him attending his first ever orchestral concert. A self-described “sports guy,” Santilli did not take up an instrument in school, either, though he has developed a taste for Broadway shows thanks to his wife.

In April, he joined the symphony as senior vice president and chief revenue and experience officer. It’s Santilli’s job to make sure attendees enjoy their experience attending concerts and to help increase ticket sales, which cover a small-but-growing fraction of the orchestra’s budget.

The Post-Gazette recently sat with Santilli in Heinz Hall to discuss his ideas for the orchestra:

This is a curious career development. What’s your take on the symphony?

Advertise with us

Here at the PSO, the mission is great music in every life, and to engage, enrich and inspire through unparalleled musical experiences. At the Pens, it’s to advance the game of hockey. There are more similarities than differences — on a basic level, both organizations are working to create access and foster emotional connections with fans.

So yes it’s a different industry, but there's not much I'm doing here that makes me think, “Wow, I've never done this before.”

What was it like to attend your first concerts?

Part of the symphony’s mission is to be welcoming to all. Well, I was brand new, and I walked into the inner lobby and, honestly, it’s not that welcoming. There are five different ways you can go but no signage to direct you — the ushers are great, but it’s not ideal for this to be on them.

Your solution?

Advertise with us

We installed a new wayfinding system to help people know where they’re headed. It’s simple but important.

What are some other early changes?

We’ve also moved to digital ticketing for concerts and parking, so now it’s all on your phone. We’re looking into making the app more user friendly.

Another simple change. It’s strange that it took so long for this to happen, isn’t it?

Yes, these things all matter. Some things you’d think would be an easy fix just aren’t. There are some limitations with the ticketing system we’re still working through.

Advertise with us

And you think these things will make a difference?

People value their time much more than they used to. It’s harder and harder to get people to commit to an event than it was even 10 years ago. In sports, a lot of this depends on team success.

You see this most in subscriptions — people don’t really want to commit to 43 hockey games or 20 concerts a year anymore.

It’s interesting, people in the arts world tend to assume that sporting events are remaining popular no matter what, but it sounds like there are similar challenges.

I’d say the rate of subscription decline is about the same, actually, between sports and arts.

Advertise with us

So what’s next for the orchestra?

Education was a huge part of our strategy at the Pens. In the first 11 or 12 years of our learn-to- play program, we put more than 14,000 kids into the game of hockey.

About 55% of them stayed involved and play organized hockey, but even the 45% that didn’t now have an appreciation for the game of hockey and appreciation for the Penguins and what we did for the community. And then we were also pulling in the parents and the grandparents.

So it was the right thing to do to give back, but it was also a great long-term investment.

So, more focus on education?

Advertise with us

Yes, leaning into existing partnerships and programs more. We have like PSO GO, which is great and gives discounted access to students to almost every concert. It’s growing, there are more than 2,600 people signed up after only a couple of years.

You talk about equipment access with the Pens — could the symphony help with instrument access?

We have a great education department here looking into things. I’m here to give insights. I think the PSO has been really good historically in providing education and free education here at Heinz Hall, but we’re always looking for ways to get out more into the community.

And what about adult audiences?

We’re doing more and more with data. Subscriptions are about customization now, and we have the means to offer more specific concert deals based on what people have come to previously.

Advertise with us

Say you come to one concert, for example. Then, you get an offer for a choose-your-own subscription package based on the concert you attended. If we can get an extra 5% increase in returns, that's what we're looking to do.

And what’s the symphony’s messaging focus right now?

On the branding side, what we need to do a better job of is we need to tell everyone in Pittsburgh that this is a world-class orchestra. This is not just the orchestra that plays in Heinz Hall. You know, classical music lovers know that and appreciate that, but how much of the region does not know that?

Everyone needs to know.