It’s the rare piece of serious American theatre that touches on politics these days that doesn’t slap its audience in the face with some sort of heavy-handed messaging.
Subtlety? Who’s that? Understatement? No thanks.
And yet, Pittsburgh Opera’s production of the 2016 opera “Fellow Travelers,” which runs through Sunday at the Byham Theater, manages to center its protagonists in the height of McCarthyism and remain more invested in their personal stories than in preaching about historical tragedies.
It’s a smart, engrossing piece of theater, with a libretto adapted from Thomas Mallon’s 2007 novel by the same title by Greg Pierce. Composer Gregory Spears’ musical score weaves repetitive fragments of melody into a rich accompaniment that pulses and shimmers with slow moving harmonies.
And through it all, a love story that feels and sounds as real as the Red Scare that it invokes.
The plot
Timid youngster Timothy Laughlin — a perfectly cast Logan Wagner, a tenor — arrives in Washington D.C. and is swept off his feet by the gregarious and practiced Hawk Fuller, capably brought to life by baritone Erik Nordstrom. Both singers are in Pittsburgh Opera’s residency program for up-and-coming artists, and both proved their stage-worthiness in spades on Friday.
As their romance blossoms, Fuller’s overconfidence lands him in an interrogation room in a terse scene, while Laughlin dreams of an impossible, unrequitable future with Fuller.
Soprano Shannon Crowley distinguished herself with a light, flexible tone as Mary, Fuller’s employee, a wise and watchful eye on the naïve Laughlin. In the second act, some impressive, quick runs helped one of the work’s more emotional moments land with a poignant intensity.
Laughlin and Fuller ricochet off of one another throughout the work in a doomed romance, where the political intrigue of McCarthy and the sexual mores of the day loom large but their individual desires and character flaws loom larger.
The score
The craftsmanship is undeniably clever.
Opera progresses more slowly than a straight play, where dialogue can move freely and quickly. This work turns this to its advantage — Spears decorates repetitive phrases in the libretto with decorative snippets of melody that repeat and, puzzle-like, interlock with one another. Bits of text are re-contextualized and given new meaning when they repeat by new bits of text.
The music is attractively paced, generally pulsing along quietly and with warmth and without much drama, only occasionally sharpening to underline the opera’s most emotionally complex moments.
Pittsburgh Opera’s music director Antony Walker kept singers and instrumentalists in lockstep, though I do have to chide the orchestra a little. Violins exhibited some shaky intonation in exposed sections, while brass overpowered the musical texture at times. This is likely due to the way the work is orchestrated — the work is a “chamber” opera, meaning there are fewer string and wind players than in a full pit orchestra to balance the brass’s sound output. (A recording of the opera features some similar balance issues.)
Occasional moments of silence were deafening and powerful, much like the understatement of the narrative itself.
The point
Brain Staufenbiel’s direction kept the action clear through some complex scenes that had action in multiple locations in the drama happening simultaneously. Period costumes and projections helped suggest Washington D.C. in the 1950s without belaboring the details.
Stark lighting cast the interrogation scene in the first act into sharp relief, with baritone Daniel Teadt leaning into the more sinister, provocative edge of the interrogator’s role, pressing Fuller about his suspected “deviant behavior.”
Those engaged in such activities were considered “fellow travelers” of communism, unfit for state office or work, as they could be compromised through blackmail.
Fuller’s casual dismissal of the accusations — a high point for Nordstrom — was scant comfort.
The production doesn’t try to link the work to today to be “timely,” one of the great ephemeral undoings of many productions today when not done carefully. Instead, it offers a glimpse into a historical moment with empathy and compassion for its characters. Bravo.
“Fellow Travelers” reprises on Saturday at 7 p.m. and Sunday at 2 p.m. in the Byham Theater. Tickets start at $12.50 at pittsburghopera.org.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.