There are numerous elements and ingredients that go into any theatrical performance, but some matter more than others.
Pittsburgh Opera launched its season Saturday with an almost excellent production of “La Boheme,” one of the most-performed operas in history. This performance had most of the trappings of a successful show: gorgeous period sets and costumes, an adored musical score brought to life with warmth and precision by the orchestra, a lively chorus and a dynamic supporting cast.
The problem lay with the leads.
“La Boheme” — French for the Bohemians — is one of those slice-of-life tales of class and culture that resonates with any era. It begins simply: A group of friends devote themselves to the high ideals of art and philosophy and music rather than the mundane trappings of rent and employment. They burn their own manifestos for warmth. What are concerns about caste to a young artist in love?
The tale is indeed one of romance. Early in the opera, the poet Rodolfo encounters the lovely Mimi in one of opera’s greatest encounters, when she visits his drab apartment in search of a light for her candle in the dark of winter.
Mimi introduces herself over the sound of muted strings, kindling at moments with decorative, flickering trills in the winds to shade in her character’s charm and optimism. Puccini’s score remains one of the opera’s most attractive qualities.
Read More
Swings and misses
Pittsburgh Opera cast soprano Vuvu Mpofu as Mimi, a decorated singer who distinguished herself for her “nuance and lightness” in the Steel City in 2024 as the ill-fated lead in Verdi’s “La Traviata.”
On Saturday, she made her “role debut” in “La Boheme,” giving her first professional performance as Mimi. It wasn’t as compelling — despite some lovely shapes to her musical phrases, she didn’t bring much depth to Mimi’s inner life and development.
Tenor Daniel O’Hearn, who previously trained in Pittsburgh as a resident artist at the company, sang as her costar, Rodolfo. On Saturday, O’Hearn’s voice seemed small for the hall, sounding like he was bringing his maximum dynamic strength to try and force his voice to fill the space. The two lovers’ lack of chemistry did neither any favors, as well.
This is a typical tale at Pittsburgh Opera, which is a regional opera company that doesn’t have the financial resources to hire internationally renowned, stage-tested performers in all roles for every production.
Some of its casting is grand, operatic swings on promising younger talent. That’s part of the company’s mission in fact, to nurture earlier career singers.
Some of these swings connect spectacularly. And some miss. Misses aren’t a referendum on a singer’s long-term career.
And, to give credit where it’s due, there were more hits than misses on Saturday, overall. Another of the titular Bohemians, Marcello the painter, sung by baritone Zachary Nelson, had a particularly fine showing, bringing pathos and humor to his role as Rodolfo’s confidant and conscience and the male member of the opera’s secondary romance.
Brittany Olivia Logan made her Pittsburgh debut as the brash Musetta, Marcello’s fickle paramour, bringing fire and life and panache to the opera. (Part of the main issue Saturday was this imbalance — the “B” couple proved far more entertaining and enchanting than the “A” couple.)
Director Kristine McIntyre’s staging was lively, though it felt a bit forced and sitcom-esque during the crowd scenes. Music director Antony Walker should also take a bow — the orchestra was in fine form and his direction kept voices and instrumentalists tightly together.
About town
This was a typical season-opener for the Steel City’s opera company. Some elements were truly excellent, some were merely satisfactory and some didn’t land.
As expenses rise and ticket sales remain comparatively static, producing grand opera in the Benedum Center will become increasingly difficult. Look no further than the fact that Pittsburgh Opera is only performing twice there this season compared to three times previously and four not so many years before that.
This isn’t merely question of attendance and ticket sales declining. There are numerous factors that contribute to this evolution toward more intimate performances, though costs and attendance are certainly major factors. Other major performing arts companies that produce theater and Broadway shows are facing similar questions of “What’s next?”
Weathering this change has been easier for some of the city’s smaller arts groups, like Chatham Baroque, the early music ensemble. That organization on Sunday announced a record number of subscribers for a concert of Beethoven’s first published works from 1795, a trio of piano trios played on period-accurate instruments. (Gut strings are finicky to keep in tune, but it was a fine performance from a historical standpoint.)
As for the opera’s large-scale Benedum shows, these factors can also influence the artistic level in terms of who the opera is able to hire for its productions, but this doesn’t fully absolve the performers themselves.
“La Boheme” continues Tuesday, Friday and Sunday. Tickets and information are available at pittsburghopera.org.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.