There’s a lot of music history at 56 S. 12th St., going back to the late ’80s, and, after a brief scare, there’s a lot more to come, thanks to two young women who didn't want to see it dark.

After seven months of nothing, Club Cafe returns on Thursday with no less than powerhouse Pittsburgh soul-rock band The Commonheart breaking it in.

The intimate music venue closed at the end of 2024, ending 36 years of music by the likes of John Mayer, Tori Amos, Billy Strings, Norah Jones, The Avett Brothers, Brandi Carlile, Drive-By Truckers, Gang of Four, The Blasters, Glass Animals, Robyn Hitchcock, Mike Doughty and St. Paul and Broken Bones.

That run began in 1988 when it opened as Cardillo’s Club Cafe, where two grand pianos sat in the room for father-son jazz pianists Bob and Harry Cardillo. In 1999, it was purchased by former Cafe Allegro owner Marco Cardamone, who adopted a Triple A format for the room somewhat akin to the nearby WYEP-FM. Then, in 2011, promoter Michael Sanders and his Opus One Productions, which does most of the bookings at Mr. Smalls, took over the space.

Advertise with us

Opus One’s announcement in September that it would close Club Cafe didn’t sit well with Maddy Lafferty and Danielle Mashuda, who co-own the local entertainment management firm Keystone Artist Connect.

“It's been one of our favorite venues for so many years,” Lafferty says, “and we jokingly had a text exchange about, you know, ‘What if we purchased it?’ We emailed Mike [Sanders], the previous owner, and got coffee with him in October and figured out every way we could to get a loan and get a team together. And it all came to fruition after months of paperwork and hard work and collaboration, and we got the keys in April.”

Working with their partners Read Connolly, Kristen Whitlinger and Elliott Sussman, they’re going to stick with a similar format in the 140-capacity room of local and national singer-songwriters and indie acts with a schedule that, so far, includes Sugar Nova, Glitterbox, Jim Lauderdale, Toledo and the Billy Price Band.

“We're gonna have a little bit of everything,” Lafferty says. “We're really trying to represent all genres and all sorts of different acts. We’ll definitely have a ton of nationally touring acts, but still, like Opus, give the opportunity for local bands to support them where it's feasible.”

Their plan to keep it viable is to expand the hours and the versatility of the space.

Advertise with us

“Club Cafe was just open whenever there was a show,” Lafferty says. “We're going to have a regular bar program and cocktail program here. The bar is going to be open 5 p.m. to midnight Monday through Saturday. And then, we're waiting on our espresso machine to get delivered, but we're going to open a coffee shop during the day from 8 to 3, and that'll allow a younger crowd, the college kids, to come and work, and maybe the possibility for some all-ages open-mic nights and, really, just like a community space during the day.”

Artists will notice that the green room and dressing room have been brightened with new paint, flooring and decor, and guests will see a different look in the main room.

“We kind of made it a giant gallery wall of things that are important to us and our partners,” Lafferty says.

Lafferty, who grew up in Dormont, came out of Duquesne University and was working as an insurance agent before delving into the local music scene in 2018.

“My dad, who is a photographer, gave me a camera that he wasn't using very often,” she says. “I started going to the Millvale Music Festival and the Deutschtown Music Festival and taking shots of local bands and connecting with them.”

Advertise with us

From there, she began working for the production company Hearcorp, where she met Mashuda, who was working at Tech25 in the same building in Mount Oliver.

In 2022, they co-founded Keystone Artist Connect, an artist management, event production and booking company that has worked with WYEP Summer Music Festival, Barrel & Flow Fest, Millvale Music Festival and with such artists as Rosie Flores, Nick Guckert, Tiny Wars and The Waymores.

Now, they have a home base off Carson Street, where there never seems to be a dull moment.

“I think with every city across the world, you run into some of the issues that the South Side is going through right now,” Lafferty says. “But there's a really strong community within the business owners down here, and they all really care about revamping the neighborhood and making it what It used to be, where people were coming down every weekend and going to the shops.

“We have some new businesses coming and we have meetings semi-monthly to go over stuff that's happening and what we can do better. And the business ownership community has been really welcoming and really great down here.”

Advertise with us

The sold-out Commonheart show is at 8 p.m. Thursday with Paul Luc and Friday with Tiny Wars.

Saturday features rapper-singer Benji, Livefromthecity, Andre Costello, Buffalo Rose, Alyssa Hankey, Adam Fitz, Laurel Lowlifes, Nick Guckert & Friends, Xhristopher, Caleb Pogyor and the Soft Wake, Dr. D & the Earthtones, Ancient History and Cam Chambers,

Sunday features NASH.V.Ill, Coltt Winter Lepley, Dave Shepherd, Fusion Illusion, Iron Riddim, Jeff Taylor, Crisp Lake, Dizzier, Sailor Dia, Kuf Knotz & Christine Elise and A.J. Haynes. Doors open at noon for the Saturday-Sunday shows. $10; clubcafelive.com.