In April 2019, the world watched in horror as Notre Dame Cathedral burned, with musicians inquiring at once about the status of the cathedral’s legendary pipe organ.
Fortunately, it escaped largely unscathed. By curious coincidence, however, it wasn’t the only cathedral used for both religious services and secular performances to suffer fire damage during that particular April.
In New York City, The Cathedral Church of Saint John the Divine had a fire in its crypt, which caused significant smoke damage to many of the great organ’s 8,500 pipes, with the largest pipe weighing more than a ton and the smallest about the size of a pencil.
Both the Notre Dame organ — with its 8,000 pipes — and The Cathedral Church of Saint John the Divine’s organ sang once more in December, nearly six years after the fire.
At Saint John the Divine, the organ began to see regular use in religious services, and on Feb. 4, organist Kent Tritle, the cathedral’s director of music, performed the first public concert using the refurbished instrument.
good pipes
There will be two more concerts by a pair of Pittsburgh natives: Daniel Ficarri on Feb. 11 and Jacob Gruss on April 6.
“We had to ship the instrument to a factory in Missouri for the restoration,” said Ficarri, 28, the church’s associate director of music and an established name in the organ world.
Ficarri, who is from Franklin Park and later studied at The Juilliard School in New York City, grew up practicing and playing organs around Pittsburgh, including the instruments at Westminster Presbyterian Church and the St. Paul’s Cathedral organ in Oakland.
Since leaving the Steel City, he has performed around the country and internationally on some of the greatest organs in the world.
“Daniel is exceptional — the Pittsburgh area generates an extraordinary number of vocal and church musicians,” said Tritle. “I like to say there’s something in the water.”
Pittsburgh musical tradition
As a student in the North Allegheny School District, Ficarri began violin lessons around middle school before finding his way to the organ in high school.
“I remember distinctly tinkering around at my church on a very humble digital organ,” he said.
Later, he took lessons at St. Mary of the Assumption Church in Hampton, which had a small pipe organ.
Playing the organ differs from piano in a couple of key ways. First, organists use their feet to play “pedal tones,” adding a level of physical complexity to the performances. (Most players wear special shoes for performances.)
Second, while piano notes change “dynamics” or volume based on how much force a player uses on the keys, organs don’t respond to pressure. These instruments’ musicality is in using different pipes and combinations of pipes to adjust the volume and “color” of different pitches, with organists adjusting these settings — a practice called “registering” the organ’s “stops” — to add nuance and character.
“Not only does every organ come with its own unique sound and timbres, but using different stops can make the same organ sound like a totally different instrument,” Ficarri explained.
“It allows for an incredible amount of expression. You can play as soft as a whisper or be nearly deafening and everything in between.”
The organ is still closely tied to Christian religious traditions, and many if not most professional organists build their careers serving as music directors and musicians in churches and also performing secular recitals and concerts.
“I think organists are very lucky in that regard,” said Ficarri, who now attends and performs at The Cathedral Church of Saint John the Divine’s weekly Episcopal services.
“The church has been such a caretaker of the organ and organ music for so long, and many people can find stable employment there.”
This doesn’t necessarily mean that all organists are religious — many churches employ organists who do not belong to that faith.
Ficarri joined the musical staff at Saint John the Divine, part of the Episcopal Diocese of New York, after graduating with bachelor’s and master’s degrees from Juilliard. His duties include regular performances during worship services, composing for services and the church’s vocal ensembles and more.
He also performs recitals and concerts around the world.
“One of my favorite instruments was in Liverpool, in England, the Liverpool Cathedral organ,” he said.
“I also played at Westminster Abbey a few months after the coronation of the of King Charles, and that was really exciting. They lock you in at night to practice, and you've got all these monarchs sort of laying buried there around you while you're practicing.”
Another favorite: the organ at Yankee Stadium.
“I'm really proud of the musical tradition that I come from in Pittsburgh. People in New York recognize the Pittsburgh Symphony and also really great music programs in the schools and wonderful teachers,” he said.
An organ’s restoration
“The fire was really dramatic. It was on Palm Sunday morning,” said Tritle. “ People thought the smoke was incense and then discovered that it definitely was not. Our service took place out in the garden with fire trucks in the driveway.”
Organ restoration is a highly technical process, particularly for historic instruments. The great organ at Saint John the Divine was originally built in 1911 by Ernest M. Skinner Co., and rebuilt and enlarged in 1954 by G. Donald Harrison, who worked for a building company formed when Skinner merged with another company.
“It’s on the level of instruments you’d find at Westminster Abbey in London,” said Tritle, explaining that the builders were highly sought after and known for their “tonal artistry.”
During the restoration, the cathedral used a digital organ for services and performances.
The three recitals this month are free and open to the public and filling fast.
Saint John the Divine has a total of six organs. Tritle said that restoration is needed for two other instruments in smaller chapels now that the great organ is finished.
“The cathedral where I work is so special,” Ficarri said. “It’s about 601 feet long, so about two football fields, which gives it this amazing 10 seconds of reverberation to your playing.”
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.