Around the U.S., top orchestras are sweating and fretting as they return to the stage for the fall classical season.
The National Symphony Orchestra in Washington, D.C. went on a brief, three-and-a-half hour strike on Friday over a new union contract for musicians. The San Francisco Symphony musicians have authorized a strike but not yet pulled the trigger — the San Francisco Symphony Chorus, however, struck about 90 minutes before the season opening concert.
The artists contend that there’s more than dollar signs at stake. Higher wages mean attracting better artistic talent. This is the line at every orchestra during negotiations.
But what does that mean? Artistic quality is tough to measure, beyond a certain threshold.
On Friday, the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra launched its classical subscription season in Heinz Hall after settling their own contract negotiation in August. There are objective and subjective elements to evaluating an orchestra’s performance. The objective metrics are whether the musicians are playing in tune and rhythmically together and whether balance is at least good enough to hear some of the complexity of the music as opposed to one section only.
Professional orchestras of this caliber tend to be strong enough with these variables that it can take a pretty discerning ear to parse whether there’s room for improvement.
That’s where I come in.
First performance
Friday’s concert, with music director Manfred Honeck opened with a Mexican work — something of a rarity on Eurocentric classical programs. Arturo Marquez’s “Danzon No. 2” is a pulsing, slinking sort of work that’s pretty impossible not to groove to. The Danzon is the official musical and genre and dance of Cuba, with consistent syncopation and long dramatic pauses. On Friday, the symphony delivered an energetic but mushy performance, carrying the piece with their enthusiasm (the cellists spun their instruments at one point!) but missing some of the sharper rhythmic snaps of the work.
It sounded a bit like an Austrian trying on a sombrero.
The orchestra tightened up for Mendelssohn’s violin concerto with Italian violin wizard Augustin Hadelich. Some players have tendency to simper a bit in the opening of this work, but not Hadelich. He launched into the work with an intense but conversational tone that projected brilliantly, captivating from beginning to close. His pitch rode just on the sharp side of “in tune,” helping to carry his playing to the farthest corners of Heinz Hall. The final movement was especially whimsical, never sacrificing detail and nuance for speed and yet racing with true bravura technical skill.
For an encore: Hadelich’s own arrangement of the fiddle tune “Orange Blossom Special.” A cowboy hat wouldn’t have been out of place.
To close, the Russian composer Rachmaninoff’s “Symphonic Dances,” a trio of orchestral dances that conclude with quotes from the Latin death hymn, the “Dies Irae.” (This was indeed Rachmaninoff’s last completed work.) The Pittsburgh Symphony’s opening movement was filled with life and vigor, but I found the second a bit overly fussy and surprisingly mannered as opposed to the bitingly sarcastic piece it can be. The finale, however, raced to a thrilling close.
Closing notes
The Pittsburgh Symphony musicians agreed to a new contract in August that included a 12.6% raise over the three-year life of the collective bargaining agreement. The orchestra is also fresh off a European tour that earned glowing international press reviews and sold out almost every venue, as well as its annual fundraising gala that raised a record $1.12 million.
When it’s playing music it knows well, it’s one of the great orchestras in the U.S. When it tackles something less familiar, the result can be a little less compelling.
I’ve been reviewing this orchestra for seven years. I’d like to hear the ensemble branch out and take on works like the “Danzon No. 2” with the same ferocity as its favorite Beethoven overtures.
I mean, they’re pretty good, to put it mildly. But there’s always room for growth. Here’s to another season.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.