The news on Tuesday that Club Cafe will be closing at the end of the year after a 25-year run drew emotional reactions from Pittsburgh musicians, some of whom launched their careers at the South Side venue.
Here are some of the comments from social media.
Gene the Werewolf:
“We are bummed to hear that Club Cafe will be closing its doors for good. We played our very first show EVER there just about 17 years ago! What great memories!”
Clinton Clegg, The Commonheart:
“Shortly after I graduated college in 2007 I found myself living in Pittsburgh’s historic South Side. I was a young songwriter without much clue on what to do with music long term (or my life honestly). In walks Club Cafe. I attended an open mic AcoustiCafe on a Monday and I thought I would go down and maybe play a song. I found a community of amazing musicians and songwriters that took me in. The people in this space were building a special community and culture whether they knew it or not. I had to be there every Monday to hear what all these other musicians and artists were creating and being there inspired me to be a better songwriter. I am grateful that now many of these same folks are my peers and more importantly friends….”
Greg Joseph, The Clarks:
“There is a great history to this club. We had some great memories here. Now that I think of it, this is where I did my one and only solo show for my CD release show. Couldn’t have done it at a more appropriate venue. You will be missed!”
André Costello, Forestry Division:
“I cut my teeth at Club Cafe! So many memories of playing shows and seeing shows. Such a great sounding room!”
John Young, The Optimists:
“I have a lot of wonderful memories of times spent there. Getting to play original music on that stage tops them all, including opening for musical heroes like Marshall Crenshaw, Lloyd Cole and the late Tommy Keene…I stood beside Peter Buck in the restroom, and then bought a CD from him as he worked the merch table the night he played there with the Baseball Project. Yes, the seating situation at the club could be frustrating, and it wasn’t always easy getting a drink when they were short-staffed. But the sound was always good, the space intimate and the shows memorable. I’ll miss Club Cafe when it shutters.”
Anthony Lamonde, Borstal Boys:
“Nice little place gone. Played there a couple of times. Not a lot because we weren’t in the YEP list of approved artists. The few times I went to a show there I drank at Jack’s because I don’t have Wexford money. This is probably directly related to Bottlerocket success.”
Dirk Miller, Uprooted:
“Played there with nine different bands. Over 20-plus years. Always love the house guys Pete Guellard and Denny Strauser!! It was always a welcoming place for musicians and patrons! Will be missed for sure. Thank you for many great music moments!!”
Denny Strauser, soundman:
“I spent eight years there as house engineer over two stints. Too many fond memories to even recall. Many thousands of musicians and probably a few thousand shows. Norah Jones and John Mayer just months before they won their Grammys. John C. Reilly and his country band. Dave Carter and Tracy Grammer a few days before he passed away, when he gave me a personal thanks from the stage that brought me to tears. I could go on and on. So many memories that I'm eternally grateful for.”
Pete Guellard, Dichro:
“10 years of running house sound and I met my current wife in this place. Loved the owners Marco and Paula [Cardamone]. I also enjoyed playing there because the room sounds pretty decent.”
Danny Gochnour, Houserockers:
“Sad to hear this. I've been playing there regularly since it opened back when Barney Lee from AirCraft Studio owned it. It's been one of my favorite local venues to play and to see national touring acts. It's sad news for the local music scene.”
Robert Andrew Wagner, Little Wretches:
“Heard some great shows there, but I don’t lament its passing. It did NOT curate and cultivate artists from our region. I saw it as a smaller version of Graffiti—strictly pay-to-play. Tony at Graffiti, at least, would consult, advise, and encourage, but he was clear and direct about the realities of the market. I never felt any personal sense of fellowship with the management of Club Cafe, though other artists from the area may feel differently.”
John Schisler, New Invisible Joy:
“So many wonderful evenings spent there. I will forever cherish all the memories of our band playing there. Club Cafe had an amazing vibe. The sound was always spectacular and the owners and staff truly cared about their performers and patrons. They’ll be missed. Bar none, a class establishment.”
T. Mitchell Bell, singer-songwriter:
“This is disappointing. I hope someone else can step up financially and keep this great listening room open.”
Johnny Grushecky, Houserockers:
“A big loss for the Pittsburgh music scene.”
Paul Tabachneck, singer-songwriter:
“I loved opening for many of my heroes there, including Glen Phillips and Tracy Bonham, and opening for John Mayer in front of 12 people right before he went huge. Also hosting that singer-songwriter series, which was 18 of the best months of my life.”
Shy Kennedy, Funerals:
“Another hit definitely hurts.”
Jim Dofka, DOFKA:
“Nice venue, nice staff, and the pizza was [fire]. Sorry to see it close but our economy over the last four years has been horrendous and difficult to overcome. Thank you for all the years and great shows.”
Randy Baumann, Randy Baumann’s Ramble:
“Sad news that Club Cafe has announced they're closing up shop after 25 years. Has been an incredibly important venue for those 2-plus decades. Major supporters of local music and national acts in the most intimate setting imaginable. Thanks and all the best to Mike and Opus fam!”
John Roman, Microwaves:
“It just doesn’t pay to not be mega-rich.”
Anonymous promoter/presenter:
“In other news, the costs to promote shows at all other smaller venues increase, and your concert ticket prices at these venues skyrocket even above the absurdness that they're already at. Looking forward to it!”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.