No one had ever heard of Oliver Anthony when he pulled off something that no one had ever done before.

The singer born Christopher Anthony Lunsford became the first artist to debut at the top of the Billboard Hot 100 with no prior chart history — and it was no feel-good party song.

He did it with “Rich Men North of Richmond,” one of the most polarizing songs, possibly, ever.

His raw cry of a blue-collar populist anthem, expressing how inflation and big government was bringing down working people like himself, tapped into a collective frustration that had been building for years. Its viral success was fueled by praise from such right-wing figures as Marjorie Taylor Greene, Jack Posobiec and Matt Walsh. He got a seat on “The Joe Rogan Experience” and an offer from John Rich to produce him. The video, shot in yard with his dogs around him, wowed YouTube reactors with the first notes of his pained wail.

Advertise with us

From the left, there was an equal and opposite reaction. Anthony was roundly condemned for “punching down,” based on one problematic verse about food stamps funding Fudge Rounds for obese people.

After Winston Marshall, the exiled Mumford and Sons member turned conservative podcaster, compared Anthony to Bob Dylan and Woody Guthrie, Matthew Cantor of The Guardian wrote, “If either of them ever recorded a song mocking the poorest of the poor, it’s been lost to history. If Anthony wants to keep moving upward, he should aim his punches in the same direction.”

Anthony, who has distanced himself from voices on both sides of the aisle, makes his Pittsburgh debut on Friday at a sold-out Stage AE show. He’s an outlier in the country music realm and could very well be a one-off, but he is also part of a wave of alternative voices on the fringes of the mainstream country scene.

Another is Tyler Childers, who only hit the country charts for the first time in 2023 with “In Your Love,” but began building a big cult following with his “Purgatory” album and the single “Whitehouse Road” in 2017. Childers, who plays a sold-out Pavilion at Star Lake on Sunday, is another singer with a raw, heartfelt style who has drawn comparisons to Steve Earle and a “country Kurt Cobain.”

While accepting the award for Emerging Artist of the Year at the 2018 Americana Music Honors & Awards, Childers took a bite of the hand feeding him, saying, "As a man who identifies as a country music singer, I feel Americana ain't no part of nothing and is a distraction from the issues that we're facing on a bigger level as country music singers. It kind of feels like purgatory.”

Advertise with us

Next wave

Whatever you want to call these singers — and you can add the mighty Chris Stapleton, Luke Combs, Zach Bryan and Jelly Roll to the list — they bear little resemblance to fifth-generation singers like Garth Brooks, Kenny Chesney, Tim McGraw and Toby Keith from the ‘90s or the so-called bro-country generation of Luke Bryan, Blake Shelton, Jason Aldean and Florida Georgia Line.

At the top of the new country wave is Morgan Wallen, who steps all over the lines into rock, pop and hip-hop. He can bro-country with the best of them (while also cleverly mocking it), but when he sits down at the piano and pours all that grit into “Sand in My Boots” or an unplugged “Wasted on You,” you realize he's built different. Sometmes the masses are right.

In early 2021, his 30-song sophomore album “Dangerous: The Double Album” became the first country album to spend its first seven weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard 200. It then became the first album since Whitney Houston’s “Whitney” to spend a total of 10 weeks at No. 1. For an encore, he came back two years later with “One Thing at a Time,” which was the most-consumed album of 2023, spending 19 weeks at No. 1.

How many rock albums topped the Billboard album chart in 2023?

One.

Advertise with us

Blink-182’s long-awaited comeback album, “One More Time…,” sold 125k units when it was released in November, which was a lower total than 12 of the Wallen weeks. (Its debut moved 501k units.)

In an interview last week with the PG, Ian Shelton of the hardcore band Militarie Gun, admitted, “It is a weird thing where I feel like all the rock singers are all in country music right now, for some reason, and a lot of the people in rock are more like pop singers. It’s a very weird time.”

Holly Gleason, Nashville editor of the trade publication “Hits,” takes that back to the Brooks breakout in the early ‘90s when he was “trying to tap into that Reo Speedwagon arena-rock mentality of the ‘70s and ‘80s: big loud guitars, lots of lights, running around a stage.

“There's always been what could have been an adjacent space that never got really filled out. The Kentucky Headhunters was the moment that might have happened. If Garth was one side of the arena-rock quotient, one twin survived, one twin didn't.”

The Headhunters offered an outlaw style that leaned into their hard-rock influences (somewhat like The Georgia Satellites right before them) that stemmed from the Southern rock of Lynyrd Skynyrd, Molly Hatchet and the like.

Advertise with us

Cousins to Satellites were the alt-country artists and neotradionalists — Steve Earle, Dwight Yoakam, Uncle Tupelo, Jason and the Scorchers — drawing upon the Hank Williams era with an occasional hint of the Stones, Faces and Gram Parsons.

Gleason sees Drive-By Truckers, stemming from the Headhunters tree, as a counterbalance to the Brooks crowd.

“Arguably, ‘Southern Rock Opera’ is, if not the gospel, one of the books of the gospel, of what we're talking about,” Gleason says.

Among the evidence for that is Zach Bryan, as a young Navy man, uploading a cover of DBT’s “Dress Blues” on the way to his viral YouTube breakout in 2017. (Bryan actually sounds much like a Ryan — Ryan Adams from Whiskeytown, another ‘90s alt-country band.) Two years later, Wallen’s version of “Cover Me Up,” from the same DBT writer, Jason Isbell, went to No. 15 on the country charts.

Despite Isbell renouncing Wallen, for the drunken use of a racial slur in 2021, “Cover Me Up” was on the set list when Wallen played two sold-out shows at PNC Park last summer. That was a few months after Combs, who had topped the country charts with Tracy Chapman's 1988 hit “Fast Car,” sold out Acrisure Stadium.

Advertise with us

In May, the same night Isbell was playing the Benedum Center, Bryan was selling out PPG Paints Arena with secondary tickets going for hundreds of dollars.

At the same moment in time we find arena artists canceling and festivals folding for weak sales, the country shows never miss.

Raw and honest

Gleason, who adds Margo Price to the list, sees this latest crop of artists as a rebuke of bro-country.

Not that those guys were vanquished.

Luke Bryan is still a thing. The “American Idol” judge, who headlined Acrisure Stadium in his 2018 heyday, is actively filling amphitheaters. Same with Aldean, who headlined PNC Park in 2014 and sold out Star Lake last year after making a similar noise as Anthony with “Try That in a Small Town," a Second Amendment anthem praised by the right and condemned by the left.

Advertise with us

Florida Georgia Line, one of the premier tight-jeans-and-tailgate bands, is on hiatus, but FGL member Tyler Hubbard is having some modest solo success. Jake Owen, Chase Rice and other mid-level bros can be found doing casinos and other smaller venues.

And because no trend is ever clear cut, the rich cowboy style of the fifth-generation singers who built modern country radio carries on with Chesney (still packing stadiums) and Cody Johnson, who draws from similar influences.

“The standard country music vocal had been more of a robust, smooth-type of vocalist,” says Devon Johnson, of the regional band Ruff Creek. “At least that was more common in my opinion. Almost cookie cutter. Tyler Childers, Oliver Anthony and Zach Bryan have more of a raw, authentic feel to them. There’s an honesty in their vocals.”

It’s a good development for Ruff Creek, he says, because “I never had that robust smooth style voice myself.”

“There seems to be a fairly dramatic shift in the type of country music that is connecting with fans in a big way,” Keith Kleinhampl and Scott Boyd, of Pittsburgh band Buckwild, said in a joint comment. “Social media has given a very immediate platform for artists who aren’t necessarily in the mainstream to connect with listeners on issues such as the political climate and societal changes that current radio platforms cannot.

Advertise with us

“Rich Men North of Richmond,” they added, “went viral because he tapped into a growing sentiment of political discontent. His vocal style wouldn’t typically be embraced by mainstream radio, but the lyrics connected to country fans in a huge way and he was able to bypass the traditional methods of mainstream exposure.”

Johnson sees the impact across the whole country spectrum.

“Real country music fans were becoming disenchanted with the more pop-style country. These guys reach back to an earlier time of more outlaw country.”

Says Gleason: “This is the ghost of the twin that didn't survive.”