At a 1983 concert with the Boston Symphony Orchestra, Leonard Bernstein, then 65, conducted the entirety of Beethoven’s third symphony with his left hand, or “southpaw,” a trick about as difficult as a right-hander writing for half an hour with the other hand.
With his right hand, the legendary conductor clutched at his chest, resting his right shoulder and arthritic right hand.
For years, he carried a cigarette in his left hand and a glass of whiskey in his right when not holding a baton, and the effects were catching up. The end was only a few years off.
Playing in the Boston Symphony that day was a young William Caballero, now principal French horn player in the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra and one of the orchestra’s star members.
“By then, he was getting a little harder to follow,” Caballero said. “But he was conducting more of the emotion than the timing as he aged. My God, it was thrilling to play for him.”
It’s that raw emotion in Bernstein’s conducting that endeared him to musicians and listeners around the world and that actor and director Bradley Cooper sought to emulate in the new Bernstein biopic, “Maestro.” It’s the latest in a spate of recent films focused on classical music including the fictional “TAR,” the historically fictional “Chevalier,” and the upcoming Maria Callas biopic “Callas.”
Read More
In one particularly praised scene, Cooper spends several minutes conducting a movement of Mahler’s “Resurrection” Symphony, an iconic performance from 1973. He certainly captures something of Bernstein’s raw fervor and vigor.
The film opened in theaters earlier this month and began streaming on Netflix on Wednesday. In reviews, film and music critics alike agree that the movie captures something raw, something deep and complex about the man, his art and his legacy.
Beyond the film and his music — the famous “West Side Story,” “On the Town,” assorted concert works, seminal recordings of the great works of classical music with the world’s greatest orchestras, and profoundly approachable writings and musings on the nature of art — Bernstein’s memory lives on through the thousands of musicians he met and taught and conducted before he died in 1990.
Quite a few such musicians still live and perform in Pittsburgh, where Bernstein conducted often throughout the 20th century in both Heinz Hall and the old Syria Mosque.
“Even in the trailer, oh my God, I don’t know who helped Cooper learn to conduct, but it’s obvious that he watched a lot of footage and has Bernstein’s conducting mannerisms down pat,” said Cynthia DeAlmeida, principal oboist in the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra and the wife of Caballero.
DeAlmeida first met Bernstein in 1984 at the Tanglewood Institute, essentially a summer camp for pre-professional musicians, where Bernstein also once studied. She is the same age as Bernstein’s daughter, Jamie, portrayed in the film by Maya Hawke.
“He was always really affectionate with a drink in his hand, happy to snap pictures with everybody,” DeAlmeida said.
Manfred Honeck, the Pittsburgh Symphony’s music director and a world-renowned conductor himself, credits Bernstein with helping push him onto the podium.
The Austrian conductor met Bernstein as a young violinist playing in the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra in the early 1980s.
“I remember when we were playing a week for the opening of the new concert house in Berlin, still in communistic time, we had our rehearsal before the concert and I saw many young people standing outside because the officers wouldn’t allow them to hear the concert,” Honeck recalled.
“We were onstage, and I heard Lenny say, ‘If these people are not allowed to come and listen to the rehearsal, then I will not conduct the concert.’”
The doors were immediately opened.
Later, Honeck asked Bernstein for advice before taking his first major conducting post.
“I was a nobody! But he spent an hour with me to talk about conducting and the responsibility. He truly cared about people.”
Honeck took the post. He reminisced about Bernstein sitting at a scenic pool in Beverly Hills singing the Strauss opera “Der Rosenkavalier” and about the time he infuriated members of the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra by asking them to play a simple musical scale for several minutes as a warmup in front of a group of students, leading the orchestra to play softer and louder.
“I don’t know why he did that,” Honeck said. “He loved surprising people, but orchestra players stood up after five minutes and said, ‘Maestro! It is enough!’
“I think the famous Vienna Philharmonic was angry at being forced to play only a scale, but I found it quite funny.”
In his younger years, Bernstein was known for leaping onto the podium to physically demonstrate the excitement and scale of the music. He landed with such loud thumps that his assistants would put change in his pockets to remind him not to jump so high.
“Obviously it rattled terribly, but in the end he did not care and jumped anyway,” Honeck said. “He was so much in the emotion.”
Bernstein once led the Vienna Philharmonic in an encore using only his face to conduct. The video is available on YouTube and quite famous. (Honeck is visible in the viola section.)
Bernstein premiered his first symphony, the “Jeremiah,” with the Pittsburgh Symphony in 1944. His final concert with the PSO was in 1984 in Heinz Hall, a program of Beethoven and Rossini and Stravinsky.
“Bernstein took a lot of joy in his teaching and seeing young people play his music,” DeAlmeida said. “I can remember him singing an old cowboy tune for the orchestra from the podium to share with us what the music meant. It was just such a sweet moment.”
He showed up to a barbecue in 1981 wearing a jacket commemorating the 25th anniversary of “West Side Story.”
“He really got to know your name and hung out,” Caballero said. “Off the podium, he was a musician’s musician.”
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.